Coronavirus infection and medication ... - British Heart Fou...

British Heart Foundation

54,708 membersโ€ข34,240 posts

Coronavirus infection and medication for cardiovascular disease

โ€ข39 Replies

Given the recent publication in the Lancet medical journal which questions whether the severity of COVID-19 is greater in patients taking ACE inhibitors, please as a matter of urgency could the BHF obtain empirical data from China or Italy to determine whether this is the case. The NNT for ACE inhibitors in secondary prevention is high (1:100 over 5 years) and thus the risk associated with drug discontinuation may be less than the risk asociated with contracting COVID-19. Similar concerns could also be raised over the use of statins, with some studies suggesting that these might decrease disease severity (through reducing inflammation in the lung), whereas others suggest that statins might reduce the anti-viral interferon response and thus increase the severity of the disease. I do not feel that "keep on taking the medication" is an acceptable stance given that guidance could be based on data from other countries where there are far more COVID-19 cases.

Reference: Are patients with hypertension and diabetes mellitus at increased risk for COVID-19 infection? Lancet, March 11th 2020.

Read more about...
39 Replies
โ€ข
Prada47 profile image
Prada47

One thing I do know for certain is I have Heart Disease and Currently I think I don't have Corona Virus. So would your advice be to continue with the Heart Meds or just let them Go !!!

Denae011 profile image
Denae011

Hi I have just emailed my gp about this awaiting reply

Harrison4 profile image
Harrison4โ€ข in reply toDenae011

did you have a reply on this one

โ€ข in reply toHarrison4

This is from a letter to be published in the American Journal of Physiology......."Furthermore, preliminary available data from infected patients illustrate that patients treated with angiotensin-II inhibitors (ACE-I)/angiotensin receptor blockers (ARBs) or non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) exhibit severe symptoms with a higher mortality rate as compared to non-user counterparts. See: journals.physiology.org/doi...

Denae011 profile image
Denae011โ€ข in reply toHarrison4

Hi yes my gp rang me and said this may not be correct. He did send me another study. And that said you must keep on taking the drugs. My gp thinks ace inhibitors offer more protection. He told me to stop reading stuff as well ๐Ÿ˜‚

โ€ข in reply toDenae011

Perhaps your gp should view this - from Nobel prize winner Richard Feynman ! youtube.com/watch?v=b240PGC...

Denae011 profile image
Denae011โ€ข in reply to

Hi will I canโ€™t uoload the link he sent me but it was from escardio.com /council on hypertension.

Chappychap profile image
Chappychap

Interesting that you mention this. I stumbled across this same "Lancet" article yesterday and have been pondering over the implications ever since. For anyone wanting to read the original text, here's a link,

thelancet.com/pdfs/journals...

It's important to remember that this is currently only a hypothesis, as the article itself clearly states,

"We therefore hypothesise that diabetes and hypertension treatment with ACE2-stimulating drugs increases the risk of developing severe and fatal COVID-19."

Consequently I doubt we'll get more than shrugged shoulders from our GP's or cardiologists as this hypothesis is still months or years away from being proven or accepted.

On the other hand the explanation given within the article seems entirely plausible, and "The Lancet" is one of the most respected publications on the planet, so hypothesis or not this is still an idea that demands respectful consideration. The ravings of some internet crank, this is certainly not!

After chewing this over here's my personal plan. I should emphasise that I am not a doctor and in no way am I recommending this as appropriate for anyone else. But during these extraordinary times we are all responsible for taking our own decisions, for the sake of prompting debate here are mine.

My blood pressure is now very well controlled, well within even the most stringent safety measures. Consequently I think the door is open for me to temporarily suspend taking Ramipril, the ACE Inhibitor that I am prescribed.

However, I'll also be taking three other steps,

1. Daily measurement of my blood pressure using a good quality and calibrated device. I plan on tracking the trend and if my blood pressure increases then I'll revisit my decision.

2. Double down on the non-medication steps I've already been successfully practising to reduce my blood pressure. Namely, well over 150 minutes of aerobic exercise each week, reduce caffeine intake, keep my weight down within BMI height/waist ratio guidelines, reduce my salt intake, strictly limit alcohol, avoid packaged or processed foods with their notoriously high salt content, eat a balanced Mediterranean diet, and practise mindfulness and stress management. Other things not relevant to me but possibly relevant to others would include stopping smoking/vaping/nicotine intake and avoiding any ibuprofen based pain killers.

3. Discuss with my GP switching from Ramipril to a calcium channel blocker, driven by this comment from "The Lancet" article,

"Based on a PubMed search on Feb 28, 2020, we did not find any evidence to suggest that antihypertensive calcium channel blockers increased ACE2 expression or activity, therefore these could be a suitable alternative".

Incidentally, there is another very recent article in "The Lancet" which is attracting a lot of praise around the world for being a particularly insightful summary of Covid-19. If anyone's interested here's a link,

thelancet.com/action/showPd...

Good luck!

โ€ข in reply toChappychap

Iโ€™m wondering in forming the research question whether they looked at the medication the departed where taking. I am concerned because I take ramipril.

Chappychap profile image
Chappychapโ€ข in reply to

I'm pretty sure the answer to your question is "no".

Basically they look at how corona virus works, and they look at how ACE Inhibitors (such as Ramipril) work, and they say look, here's a clear mechanism whereby Ramipril might be exacerbating the potentially fatal effects of the virus.

It's interesting that other data I've seen indicates that the number one risk factor for fatal corona virus infection is high blood pressure. What this article is suggesting is that it's maybe not just high blood pressure on its own that's the risk, it's perhaps the medication that an awful lot of high blood pressure sufferers are taking.

SpiritoftheFloyd profile image
SpiritoftheFloydโ€ข in reply toChappychap

The high blood pressure question first came up when doctors in China were analysing fatalities in China and reported that a large number of people who had died had high blood pressure.

When you look at data for BP in the population of China, over 50% of people between the age of 35 and 75 have high blood pressure, and only about a third of them are having any sort of medication/treatment for it.

So I imagine that in light of the percentage who have high BP the incidence of fatalities with high BP could be expected. Additionally as only a third of those with high BP are on any sort of medication, the link (at least in China) between BP medication and mortality could be weak.

Handel profile image
Handelโ€ข in reply toSpiritoftheFloyd

Well said xx

lettingoffsteam profile image
lettingoffsteamโ€ข in reply toSpiritoftheFloyd

Interesting and encouraging point.

Harrison4 profile image
Harrison4โ€ข in reply toSpiritoftheFloyd

also did they discontinue the heart meds re bp during the treatment for covid 19

SpiritoftheFloyd profile image
SpiritoftheFloydโ€ข in reply toHarrison4

I don't know - the article I read just said that there was an observation of the fatalities in China, that a large number had high blood pressure, as far as I'm aware, in that article there was no reference to heart disease

Milkfairy profile image
MilkfairyHeart Starโ€ข in reply toChappychap

Perhaps we could try group Mindfulness meditation sessions to help us through the the uncertainty of the next few months.

๐Ÿง˜โ€โ™€๏ธ

lettingoffsteam profile image
lettingoffsteamโ€ข in reply toChappychap

That's all well and good but I'm on ramipril and amlodipine so no use for me to think I could swap ramipril for a calcium channel blocker.๐Ÿ˜’ Better just hide myself away until this blows over!

Many thanks to those who responded - it would be interesting to compare mortality data from patients receiving either ACE-inhibitors or calcium channel blockers.

โ€ข in reply to

Agreed

lettingoffsteam profile image
lettingoffsteamโ€ข in reply to

I'm on both.

Prada47 profile image
Prada47

Come on Boys and Girls

These articles are written by Experts for Experts to try to start to understand exactly what they are saying you need to be part of the Expert Team . Me I am happy to leave it to the experts.

I think GPs even don't have the knowledge to Advise on this.

Regards

SpiritoftheFloyd profile image
SpiritoftheFloyd

Here's a link to what the European Society of Cardiology have to say on the subject - basically there is no evidence of a link so keep taking the meds! Hope this helps to reassure people

escardio.org/Councils/Counc...

โ€ข in reply toSpiritoftheFloyd

Thatโ€™s reassuring news. Good post

โ€ข in reply toSpiritoftheFloyd

OK many thanks - there must surely be sufficient data from China or Italy to answer these concerns ?

SpiritoftheFloyd profile image
SpiritoftheFloydโ€ข in reply to

There's lots of data, but as it's a new virus the medics and science are trying to get their heads around it. They will, and with the technology at our disposal they shouldn't take that look to figure it all out, compared to how long it took in 1918 with Spanish Flu. And to go back further - the Black Death in 1347 which ravaged Asia and Europe was put down to "Bad Air" - thankfully we've come a long way since then!

โ€ข in reply toSpiritoftheFloyd

I forgot to say - the Lancet article does not suggest people stop taking ACE inhibitors - it actually proposes switching to a different type of medication - calcium channel blocker - presumably this should not be a problem, and only reinforces the need for an evidence based solution. Once again many thanks.

SpiritoftheFloyd profile image
SpiritoftheFloydโ€ข in reply to

No I agree. The Lancet has not said to stop.

I think the European Society of Cardiology has said not to stop because other media sources have picked up what the Lancet has published and sort of twisted it a bit and left a suggestion that people should consider not taking it

lettingoffsteam profile image
lettingoffsteamโ€ข in reply to

Problem for me though...I'm on both already.

Chappychap profile image
Chappychapโ€ข in reply toSpiritoftheFloyd

Excellent find, thanks for the link.

Handel profile image
Handelโ€ข in reply toSpiritoftheFloyd

Nice one. Thank you xx

lettingoffsteam profile image
lettingoffsteamโ€ข in reply toSpiritoftheFloyd

Thanks SpiritoftheFloyd.

Hatchjd profile image
Hatchjd

Another article saying that there is no reason to stop ACE or ARB meds but statins are protective.

tctmd.com/news/covid-19-and...

GracieOS profile image
GracieOS

These are indeed very worrying times. For me, my peace of mind, I've flipped the statistics. Worse case scenario for those of us with cardiovascular disease is a morality rate of around 10%, that means we have a 90% chance of surviving covid-19 if we got infected. I'm doing all I can to avoid getting it but it may not be completely under my control so I find it helpful to focus on the 90% survival rate rather than the other way round ๐Ÿ™‚. Just a thought.

Silverfox2 profile image
Silverfox2

Well If thats the case I've had it then as due to terrible side effects I cannot take any other type of meds. :(

tunybgur profile image
tunybgur

In the last few days Italy has just published details of the Covid-19 deaths and their 'underlying' medical conditions exacerbating the infection.

More than 76% had high blood pressure listed as the underlying condition...I wonder what meds they were on?

We really do need some answers here!

tunybgur profile image
tunybgur

epicentro.iss.it/coronaviru...

It's in Italian, Ipertensione arteriosa is hypertension (high blood pressure)

DavidG1971 profile image
DavidG1971

Sorry to be dumb - are Beta Blockers part this conversation. Are they inhibitors?

Sunnie2day profile image
Sunnie2dayโ€ข in reply toDavidG1971

Not dumb at all - I had the same question a few days ago. From what I read (Mayo Clinic, yes, a US site but credible and well written information there), the short answer is no - but I took that 'no' with a bit of a grain of salt. My take-away was ace inhibitors are not the same but beta blockers are used sometimes for BP concerns whilst being very good at controlling angina - but I'm not medically trained and could be mistaken in how I understood the information.

bfachet profile image
bfachet

youtube.com/watch?v=1vZDVbq...

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Covid-19 and high blood pressure medication

I have just been speaking with my GP about the link between ACE inhibitors and ARB drugs prescribed...
tunybgur profile image
โ€ข

Blood pressure medication and certain foods

This evening I took my blood pressure and found that it was slightly raised - 134 / 77, okay...
MountainGoat52 profile image
โ€ข

Importance of Cardiovascular Disease Risk Factors

Hello Does anyone have knowledge or a view on the overall modifiable cardiovascular disease...
Jo198919 profile image
โ€ข

The main underlying health condition in men under 65 dying from coronavirus is ischmaetic heart disease.

I have just read an analysis published in the Daily Mail online about underlying health conditions...
fergusthegreat profile image
โ€ข

Statins and side effects

At the end of last month there was a Lancet report on statins:...
anynewheart42 profile image
โ€ข

Moderation team

See all
HUModerator profile image
HUModeratorAdministrator
Luke_BHF profile image
Luke_BHFPartner
Amy-BHF profile image
Amy-BHFPartner

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.