Care-worker death rate twice that of ... - Lung Conditions C...

Lung Conditions Community Forum

56,170 members66,796 posts

Care-worker death rate twice that of health workers.

2greys profile image
6 Replies

Of the 2,494 deaths analysed, 131 were care workers - 86 female and 45 male.

But because many more social care workers are female, this equates to a death rate of 23.4 per 100,000 for men and 9.6 per 100,000 for women.

However, despite their close proximity to patients, healthcare workers, including doctors and nurses, had much lower death rates. This may be because they had better access to personal protective equipment (PPE) than other workers.

bbc.co.uk/news/health-52616080

Written by
2greys profile image
2greys
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
6 Replies
Corin1950 profile image
Corin1950

Yes I feel very sad that many of these deaths were totally preventable.Every statistic is a member of someone’s family or a loved one and a tragedy for them. Caused I feel by a very casual attitude to the virus initially, then mismanagement ever since.

We are lucky that we can self isolate but the poor patients and staff in care homes do not have that luxury and without PPE had no chance. It was the same in hospitals for the first few weeks. I know this from my daughter. In the hospital where she works over 200 people have died from the virus so far and one member of staff. He was a nursing assistant in his forties with young children. The ambulance men who brought my husband home from our local hospital 3 weeks ago weren’t even wearing masks!

Sometimes I just despair.

Hope Sharon, her colleagues and patients stay safe

Take care 2greys

X

2greys profile image
2greys in reply toCorin1950

Sharon was infected through a lack of PPE, in turn I caught it from her despite taking all the recommended precautions. The other night she was in tears, because she blamed herself for the state it has left me in. She wanted to stay off work to care for me and I had to insist that it was not necessary, that she was needed more at the nursing home. So in reality I blame the lack of PPE in a nursing home for my infection, I could so easily have been seriously ill and died. I am sure that I am not alone, that other families have suffered after a carer has taken the virus home to their loved ones. Those families are not included in the statistics of course, covering up the full cost of lives.

Corin1950 profile image
Corin1950 in reply to2greys

I was offered support of a care worker when my husband was sent home but I refused as I was afraid of the risks of someone coming into the house. The respiratory nurse and physio have been in touch to visit but I’ve said I’d prefer it if they just rang but it’s a dilemma because we could really do with the support.

X

Cateran profile image
Cateran in reply to2greys

I fully share your analysis of the division between healthcare workers and care home workers and the woeful lack of elementary PPE provision, hence the spread of infection which is wider and deeper than it should be, 2G.

Can the basic divide between the two lie in technology and its uptake? In general hospitals and their huge size and scale of operation, there is frequently the prevalence of high tech and medical machinery, with its skilled operators, and the low touch of patient care by nurses and medics, whereas the opposite prevails in care homes, much smaller in scale and use of technology but with high touch in terms of residents care by nursing and other staff but with the use of relatively low tech machinery such as hoists, but low tech handling, with relatively fewer sophisticated diagnostic tech devices compared with hospitals.

Therefore , does low tech high touch depend and use more personal, contact and risk of spreading disease than within hospitals where there is more high tech but lower touching of patients? I am generalising here 2G but i want to draw attention to low skilled labour as more exploited and put at risk no matter the wonderfully humane work the social care element of our care homes. My heart goes out to Charon as a victim of sorts within all this. As if nursing homes and their lack of advanced technology didn't matter as much as hospitals with their highly trained and qualified personnel and expensive machinery. If you are old and ill you become somehow invisible to politicians and the state. It is not right and not fair. There you go, that's my humanist rant over, for now.

RoadRunner44 profile image
RoadRunner44

I completely agree with you! It's only now we can reflect on the situation and realize the shortcomings.

crashdoll profile image
crashdoll

It’s very sad and worrying.

I read an article earlier and there have been an unusually high number of social workers who have died due to Covid19. My colleagues are probably luckier than others as we have an adequate supply of PPE. Not all local authorities are that fortunate. Nevertheless, I worry about my colleagues, my friends.

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

High rate of symptomless COVID-19 infection among grocery store workers: study.

Grocery store employees are likely to be at heightened risk of COVID-19 infection, with those in...
2greys profile image

After years of decline, death rate from lung clots on the rise.

After nearly a decade of steady decline, the death rate for people with blood clots in the lungs...
2greys profile image

Truly Tragic : Final plea of asbestos victim: warn young workers of dust danger

Charlie Bridgewater, pictured with daughter Donna, was exposed to asbestos at work. Photograph:...

Trading health care systems...

Hi all, I would love to understand how the NHS works. In the States we have, at least momentarily,...
TomTitTot profile image

Do not read this if you are easily upset. Care home death rate. (updated)

I have not divulged the details or identity of the nursing home that Sharon works in, as a...
2greys profile image

Moderation team

See all
AsthmaandLung profile image
AsthmaandLungAdministrator
moderator_AandLUK profile image
moderator_AandLUKAdministrator
AdminTeam profile image
AdminTeamAdministrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.