Can too many ablations cause “stiff h... - Atrial Fibrillati...

Atrial Fibrillation Support

32,400 members38,735 posts

Can too many ablations cause “stiff heart”?

jsanta profile image
16 Replies

i’m at 69-year-old male that has had four oblations in the last eight years for a fib. I am now in a flutter persistent 100% of the time. I’m considering another ablation in November by one of the top doctors in the country. I Heard that sometimes too many oblations can cause a stiff heart which I am told that I have already.

I don’t know if that’s correct or not and if it is, what is the downside of having a stiff heart. I’m trying to weigh the Opportunity of being in sinus rhythm or make heart stiffer making it worse?

I am also having issues with my liver with the backflow of one of the venal veins, which could be as a result of the a flutter.

Has anybody heard of this or dealt with it before?

Written by
jsanta profile image
jsanta
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
16 Replies

I had 5 ablations between 2014-2019, the last one January 2019 was technically difficult is he had difficulty penetrating the septum. I was late 30s.

Buffafly profile image
Buffafly

When I looked up ‘stiff heart’ I was taken to ‘cardiomyopathy’. This was very interesting and might answer your question:

nhs.uk/conditions/cardiomyo...

jsanta profile image
jsanta in reply toBuffafly

TY very helpful!

I’m not sure about this, but it might prompt others to answer but I think having several ablations can cause fibrosis affecting tissue within the heart from excessive scarring. I think techniques have improved over the years and EP’s are now more able to prevent this from happening. I’m sure that if you raise your concerns with your EP you will get answers to your questions.

Buffafly profile image
Buffafly in reply to

I’m pretty sure Jean had that problem

BeeBee79 profile image
BeeBee79

Are there any any toons for a stiff heart? I’m 44 and have had 4 ablations within 18 months 🥹

jeanjeannie50 profile image
jeanjeannie50 in reply toBeeBee79

Toons? Has predictive text taken over?

BeeBee79 profile image
BeeBee79 in reply tojeanjeannie50

😆😆 I meant to type “symptoms” 🤦🏼‍♀️

Cat04 profile image
Cat04

As I understand it afib ablations are done to the left atrium. If you have typical flutter that would be the right atrium ablation, a lot easier & quicker to perform and a very high success rate (>95% ?).

I've now had an RF afib catheter ablation and a surgical atypical flutter ablation both on the left atrium and no one has mentioned a stiff heart to me.

As Flapjack suggests check it out with your EP.

mike1961 profile image
mike1961

Cat04 is on it above:

"If you have typical flutter that would be the right atrium ablation, a lot easier & quicker to perform and a very high success rate (>95% ?)."

If I was you the 5th ablation for TAF in the RA would be a WAY better option to my mind going forward than being in Aflutter 100% of the time.

By the way, what is your ventricular response rate when in Aflutter? Maybe if it was 4:1 (atria to ventricular) all of the time (rather than jumping about from 2:1 to 3:1 to 4:1) with a ventricular rate of just 70 or 80 then staying in it could be an option depending on your age and co-morbitities.

jeanjeannie50 profile image
jeanjeannie50

Quite a few years ago, having been admitted to a hospital ward with my heart racing, a cardiologist told me that my heart may have become a bit stiff after having had 2 ablations. I did go on to have a third ablation in 2016 and haven't had a really high heart-rate since. It's now usually between 60-90bpm.and I'm in constant AF.

I guess with ablations forming scar tissue to block the rogue beats, there is always the chance of it making the heart stiff in it's working. That cardiologist was the only person who suggested that over the 18 years of my having AF. I had an echocardiogram last year and all was fine.

Jean

jsanta profile image
jsanta in reply tojeanjeannie50

Thank you so much!! Sounds like you are doing great!

JOY2THEWORLD49 profile image
JOY2THEWORLD49 in reply tojsanta

Hi

A friend said that after 3rd ablation given the 'NO MORE ABLATIONS".

I am NZ.

Another friend had his first whereby they found 2 rogue places to abate. He was on 5 medications. No more AF. 2 years ago now.

I can't have ablations, cardioversions or antirhthymic meds as structurally my

heart is enlarged in one chamber.

cheri JOY. 74. (NZ)

jsanta profile image
jsanta in reply tojeanjeannie50

Thanks Jean! Very helpful! Jury still out!!

marcyh profile image
marcyh

I did a little looking and "stiff heart syndrome" came up. The Franciscan article was the most helpful one I found although I've never heard of this source. Are you short of breath? BP problems?

I was quite surprised when my cardiologist told me this week that if I have a 3rd ablation I would probably get a pacemaker. Of course I never think to ask the obvious, "Why?" and I assumed it was my age (almost 80).

This article lists shortness of breath as connected to stiff heart syndrome. This has gotten me thinking because SoB is one of my biggest problems. He's scheduling another echo. I also had untreated hypertension years ago so that's an interesting link. I attribute my kidney disease to it.

Best wishes...

franciscanhealth.org/commun...

jsanta profile image
jsanta

Thank you so much! Very helpful

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

heart keep healing after ablations

I was first diagnosed in Dec 2021. Had my first cyro ablation end of June 2022 which didn’t work at...
Afib_girl profile image

Tikosyn so far Success

I’m a 65-year-old male that’s had three oblations and a cardioversion that have not been able to...
jsanta profile image

How many Ablations can you have, how many can you have

Hello I am normally on the BHF site however I joined this site as my condition crosses into both I...
shwills profile image

a flutter ablation versus a fib ablation

I’m a 70-year-old male that’s had four ablations all unsuccessful. Three years ago I had a...
jsanta profile image

How many Ablations can you have?

Hi, I have had 2 ablations so far, first one went wrong and second one I opted for Cryo, this...
Ch43351 profile image

Moderation team

See all
Kelley-Admin profile image
Kelley-AdminAdministrator
jess-admin profile image
jess-adminAdministrator
Emily-Admin profile image
Emily-AdminAdministrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.