Are you able to help?: Can you help... - Atrial Fibrillati...

Atrial Fibrillation Support

31,322 members36,989 posts

Are you able to help?

TracyAdmin profile image
TracyAdminPartner
18 Replies

Can you help NICE by completing a 5 minute survey to show a better understanding on how the AliveCor Kardia Mobile was helpful in detecting arrhythmias and AF?

Please click on the following link to participate :

nice.researchfeedback.net/K...

Thank you for your time and co-operation.

Written by
TracyAdmin profile image
TracyAdmin
Partner
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
18 Replies
Jalia profile image
Jalia

Only applicable to those given device by their GP??

Finvola profile image
Finvola in reply to Jalia

It seems to assume the device was recommended or provided by a doctor which means my answers don't fit to the choices available.

momist profile image
momist in reply to Finvola

I just ignored that bit.

CDreamer profile image
CDreamer in reply to momist

I also ignored - that’s what I meant by slanted against the device. The whole tone of the questions seemed biased toward professional medical protectionism rather than patient involvement in AF management.

KG70 profile image
KG70

The questions assume you were given the device to trial by a doctor but I used my own which was critical in getting the care I needed so I completed the survey anyway and explained that in the notes. I hope others will do the same to show how many of us are having to prove our own symptoms to get care.

rosyG profile image
rosyG in reply to KG70

Yes I had to adapt it too

Finvola profile image
Finvola in reply to KG70

Good point KG - I now have worked around the assumption in the survey that no-one would buy their own monitor.

LindaDaisy profile image
LindaDaisy in reply to KG70

I did the same.

rosyG profile image
rosyG

Please take the survey as apparently NICE are now not accepting diagnosis via devices like Kardia and this will delay anti coagulation - I filled in how our medical director diagnosed new AF cases in screening with Kardia in town centre it's excellent!

CDreamer profile image
CDreamer in reply to rosyG

The whole tone smacks of medical protectionism against patient autonomy and that only creeps in with fear of loss of control.

meadfoot profile image
meadfoot

Done and submitted.

Frances123 profile image
Frances123

I trialled one years ago and think you did @BobD where we had to send daily readings for 60/90 days (can’t quite remember) and then the kardia was ours to keep. I later bought newer model. Still filled survey in and explained in absence of any cardiac care for 10 years + and symptoms changing I was able to show EP when I paid for initial consultation what was happening.

MarkS profile image
MarkS

I filled in the survey. I own my own so borrowing was not relevant. I explained that I would bypass the GP and go straight to my EP if I thought any action was required.

Cally53 profile image
Cally53

I was advised by my heart consultant to get a kardia. Thank goodness I did, because I was never in af when I went for a hospital appointment or when I wore a 48 hour monitor. I am now on the waiting list for a second ablation.

Snookersteve profile image
Snookersteve

I, like many others, purchased my own KardiaMobile and filled in the questionnaire accordingly. I think this is a vital piece of kit for anyone with a history of AF (except maybe permanent AF). For a tiny cost of £100 this could save lives and avoid strokes. How much does a stroke cost the NHS and how many KardiaMobiles could be purchased for the cost of just one stroke? It's a no brainer for me. Steve.

Goldfish7 profile image
Goldfish7

I completed it with difficulty - its more for if you were given one by a Dr, the other problem being that they are asking for comments and then making sure there is no space to leave anything but the most sketchy comment. Not a good survey but worth doing on the off chance it results in greater availability of Kardia devices or Dr's paying attention to Kardia reports.

One of the questions is:

“Did you use it for the full amount of time you were loaned the monitor?”

This looks like a feedback form for a specific research project in which a KardiaMobile device was loaned to users.

I doubt that it was meant to be shared more generally.

CDreamer profile image
CDreamer in reply to

It’s a NICE survey - a consultation survey not research and very important one.

All NHS practice and some insurance companies will only abide by NICE guidelines so if a 12 lead ECG is required for every diagnosis -one has to question the reasoning behind that and I can’t for the life of me think of any positive reasons - especially for those with PAF still seeking diagnosis.

It’s outrageous!

If you have used a Kardia - own purchase or loaned from GP - please complete the survey.

You may also like...

Are you able to help the A F Association?

18/08/21 You must be available for a 1 hour call via Zoom or Teams platform. Thank you in...

Magnesium - why do you think it helps you?

hear how Mag helps you, or if it didn't, and why you feel it is definitely the Mag that is helping...

Big thank you and things that help

heart warming. And all helping one another get on with the life we've got!Thank you so much....

Something to help you sleep or relax

tailor it to suit your needs and time you have available. You need a smart phone with Android...

Help Us, Help You - NHS 111 first campaign

injuries then you should continue to dial 999. Arrhythmia Alliance are here to help and support you...