Post RP, MRI or mpMRI imaging? - Prostate Cancer N...

Prostate Cancer Network

5,157 members3,240 posts

Post RP, MRI or mpMRI imaging?

8 Replies

RO prescribes ordinary MRI for sRT planning. I have read a number of papers showing preference to mpMRI for its DCE (Dynamic Contrast Enhancement) component, as an aid for resolving false positive ambiguities. Any personal precedents will be much appreciated. TIA.

8 Replies
Tall_Allen profile image
Tall_Allen

Radiation planning is usually done with MRI and CT, both or either. The goal is to contour where the radiation is going, not to find cancer.

in reply to Tall_Allen

Thanks TA but my interest, as noted, is for personal precedents. Theoretical reasoning is nice to know but at the end of the day I will do what makes more sense to me. I am not the type "I have confidence in my drs and do as they say". In fact the one such I knew is now RIP.

Tall_Allen profile image
Tall_Allen in reply to

What I'm saying is that you are confusing two things:

(1) imaging to find cancer (which is used to guide biopsy)

(2) imaging for radiation planning (which is used for beam contouring)

The purposes are different.

in reply to Tall_Allen

Killing two birds with one stone is not invented yet. Hopefully, my RO sounds better than that Said that if something shows up will get a larger chunk of the radiation dose.

Tall_Allen profile image
Tall_Allen in reply to

So what you are trying to do is identify cancer in the prostate bed and lymph nodes and give higher doses to those? (This is called "dose painting" or a "simultaneous integrated boost.") It is unknown whether it improves outcomes. Some use PET imaging for this, which has better sensitivity and specificity than mpMRI. However, at low PSA, PET isn't very sensitive. For the prostate bed, the best way to detect areas to obtain a boost dose is at the site of the positive margins, if there were any. For pelvic LNs, a Combidex MRI, available only at Radboud University, exceeds the sensitivity of PET scans,

in reply to Tall_Allen

Wholeheartly agreed. The economics of it:

a) MRI is free

b) mpMRI upgrade add 200 Euros

c) PSMA PET/CT = 1800 Euros

d) Ferrotran MRI = 4000 Euros + travel expenses

All counted in in an accending manner.

The most expensive and difficult to find part is a RO that can read all these having also access to the latest breed of lineac with enough precision for realization. Otherwise it is money thrown out of the window.

But we have diverted from my original call for personal presedents. Let's go back there.

in reply to

An update for anyone interested.

I opted for an mpMRI instead of an MRI that the RO prescribed. Yes, I am my own advocate and follow my own judgement. Had to pay 150 Euros out of pocket for the upgrade. The finding is a "very suspicious ~6mm mitotic focus" at the anatomical level of the base of the (preexisting) prostate on the left side. Interestingly enough and under my very limited anatomical knowledge, this is adjacent to my left seminal vesicle which had been found invaded during RP. My current PSA is only 0.05. I asked for the MRI when I saw it rising steadily from 0.02 . I am forwarding the mpMRI images to get a second opinion, as false positives have their chances.

Take home message: Blanket statements of the sort: "MRI shows nothing at low PSA levels" have limited application. Better stay vigilant for an early warning!

in reply to

Update on (blinded) second opinion.

"Status post prostatectomy. No suspecious residual tissue seen in the surgical bed"

Go figure...

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Post RP Questions...

I had a robotic assisted radical prostatectomy 3 weeks ago. No urinary control issues since the...

Two weeks post RP

Today marks two weeks post prostatectomy. I have my first follow up appointment tomorrow where the...

mpMRI after biopsy

How long should it take for your prostate to heal after a biopsy before doing an mpMRI?

Likelihood of post-RP radiation?

Can anyone share their opinion as to my chances of escaping the need for post RP radiation...

Question about my annual post RP psa reading???

I’m 9 years post RP 3+4 for 7 Good patho post RP My psa since has been Always undetectable <.1...