ET CALR+ & Venesection?: Hi I had my 4 monthly... - MPN Voice

MPN Voice

10,874 members15,189 posts

ET CALR+ & Venesection?

Jonnymitts profile image
10 Replies

Hi I had my 4 monthly check up this week and my consultant was concerned about my haematocrit and to review it in 6 weeks with a possible venesection.

I always assumed venesections were a PV thing.

I have been asked to increase fluids and have been feeling more tired than usual so would this also help with fatigue? My consultant said it was a ET PV crossover?

I would be interested in if anyone else has had one with ET CALR+

Thanks

Written by
Jonnymitts profile image
Jonnymitts
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
10 Replies
mhos61 profile image
mhos61

I thought it was unheard of to have PV with the CalR mutation, so don’t understand the ‘crossover’ bit.

I suppose your haematocrit could elevate due to various things, such as being dehydrated etc. Maybe your Consultant is just being vigilant with regards to increased thrombotic risk. Having said that, people with the CalR mutation are deemed less at risk of thrombotic events?

You pose an interesting question! Hope someone can help.

Jonnymitts profile image
Jonnymitts in reply tomhos61

Yes indeed thanks for your input. I wasn’t expecting it so I will have a few more questions when I go back and will drink more water to see if it brings it down. Though he did say my platelets would likely rise after a venesection and were at 840.

socrates_8 profile image
socrates_8

Hey Jonny... :-)

Indeed, Mary makes an interesting observation below.

I am also CALR+ Type2, and although originally diagnosed as ET I am now MF.

My understanding is also that it would be an extremely rare event if someone with PV had a CALR+ mutation...

However, that said, there are mainly two (2) types of CALR+ mutations, 1 & 2. But there are many other even more rarer types too... that I know very little about at present, just that they do indeed occur.

While many people state that being of a CALR+ mutation means that one is less at risk of a thrombotic event, I have already had two (2) TIAs, (minor brain strokes), which are thrombotic events... Hence, I guess that in reality such statements are generalisations by the medical fraternity...

We are all quite unique, and all of us bring together a greater pool of variables, which in turn might makes us all just a tad different from each other too...

Anyways, please do keep us posted. It will be interesting to learn the outcome of this mystery of yours... Try to be patient, as you are doing all you can and the results will come in time I am sure...

Best wishes

Steven

(Sydney)

Jonnymitts profile image
Jonnymitts in reply tosocrates_8

Hi Steven, thanks for your reply.

I’m not sure what type I am I did ask and got a vague answer so maybe I’m one of the rarer types, though on my CALR result it mentions type 34?

Like you say we are all different and have other things going on so I guess we are getting closer to being treated individually rather than you’re under 60 so just aspirin and blood tests for now :)

I will be mostly drinking water for the next few weeks.

Thanks

Jonny

socrates_8 profile image
socrates_8 in reply toJonnymitts

Jonny...

Quick tip... write down the questions that you most want & need answered, and pull them out and ask them when next you see your specialist.

Nail them on their responses too, so you are not left in any murky waters of uncertainty, where you do not completely understand the answer...

Personally, I have copies of all of my results from all tests I have ever taken, including every blood test for the past three (3) years...

There are fewer doubts or uncertainty when it is all in Black & White, in my view...

Keep us posted... :-)

Steven

PS. Have not heard of Type 34, but then there is much I have not heard of as yet... Best wishes... :-)

Anag profile image
Anag in reply toJonnymitts

Im also CALR but don’t know 1 or 2? I’m 54 and had my 3rd thrombotic events (TIAs) at 49, 51and 52. then diagnosis. 2 more TIAs at 53, despite Anagrelid and Aspirin. Yes. We are all different. My red cells and hematocrit are low, since I have an inborn anemia. (That’s why I cant take HU). Keep cool and asks lots of questions. Make sure you get understandable and clear answers. Cheers!

Jonnymitts profile image
Jonnymitts in reply toAnag

Thanks for your reply. Sorry to hear about the TIAs. I’ve not had any yet as my ET was picked up in a routine blood test for high blood pressure & then a bmb to confirm diagnosis. I saw my GP yesterday and she was surprised about the possible venesection, she must be a rare GP that knows about MPNS.

Anag profile image
Anag in reply toJonnymitts

If she knows about MPNs, don’t let go of her. Unfortunately, my top endocrinologist was also a close friend and didn’t ring alarm even at 750! She checked my blood twice yearly (Hashimoto thyroiditis) and refused to believe someone so strong and full of life could have anything. She saw the thrombos rising by 50,000 year after year and still didn’t get it!!! That’s why you don’t go to doctor friends. They either see too much or too little. They’re not objective. The 3. TIA led to my diagnosis. I had already had ET for over 7 years. Take care about the blood pressure, especially when the weather gets warmer. Cheers. Anag

Chaz1 profile image
Chaz1

Can't offer insight in to the Calr mutation & ET/PV crossover however Hubby (48) has ET (under British Guidelines) & is considered PV (under WHO) he has venesections & doesn't have a massive rise in his platelets. He's just had a Venesection & his platelets at the test before were the lowest they had been for years (638). This maybe because he had his gallbladder out 6 weeks ago so had an amount of blood loss from that but we don't see a massive rise. He has venesections usually every 3 months, they rise to the mid 800s but generally seems to keep them stable too. Its something that his consultant is pleased with as was risk of increasing. As we all know its a different story in most cases but just wanted to say venesections don't automatically mean a rise in platelets. Hope you get all your questions answered.

Jonnymitts profile image
Jonnymitts in reply toChaz1

Thank for this it is quite interesting to hear about different treatments. Also good to hear only every 3 months as was hoping this wouldn’t become a more regular occurrence.

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

ET CALR

Hi guys! I am feeling anxious tonight. I have some question for you. Is it anybody Who has ET with...
Johan2021 profile image

ET and PV - holiday insurance

Happy New Year everyone - I have just returned from my visit to the Consultant and when he was...

ET or PV

I was diagnosed with ET about a year and a half ago I just take an aspirin a day, so I had my 6...
doglover49 profile image

Unexplained Bruising (ET-CALR)

Hi all. At every appointment my doctor asks if I’ve had easy or unexplained bruising. I’ve always...
GrammyG profile image

ET or PV

Hi, I was originally diagnosed with ET 18 months ago by my haematologist, I later requested a...
JP1952 profile image

Moderation team

Debinha profile image
DebinhaAdministrator
Mazcd profile image
MazcdPartner

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.