The Black Stuff!: Hi folks. Just wanted to... - Cure Parkinson's

Cure Parkinson's

26,583 members27,899 posts

The Black Stuff!

jeeves19 profile image
56 Replies

Hi folks. Just wanted to get the community view on this: I use the 98% Mucuna. It’s great and gives me about 3/4 hour’s of good on time. I have no issues regarding it’s efficacy. But I DO wonder about what my insides might look like after a couple of years of ingesting this stuff. Sounds trivial but I’m being serious: if I rinse out a glass that has had the potion in, the sink is spattered with black stains. I used to think that it was the green tea but it’s definitely the MP that creates thus rather unsightly residue. What sort of concerns me is that the sink only cleans up after an application of bleach! So I’m just wondering a) if my insides are stained black and b) if this could be a problem?

Your thoughts appreciated. Thanks

Written by
jeeves19 profile image
jeeves19
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
56 Replies
laglag profile image
laglag

Jeeves, that is kind of the same thing I've been curious about lately. For some time I've been seeing black stains in my sinks & counter tops and couldn't figure it out. Last week I sorted my meds on the dining room table and then wiped it off with the dish rag. I put the rag in the washer and when it came out I noticed it had black stains all over it. I asked my husband if he had used it but he had not. The next day I told him that I thought it was from wiping the table off. So I'm sure it was from my ODT C/L. My pill cutter also has stains and that's the only pill I cut. Weird, huh? I didn't think about my insides being black !

maryalice profile image
maryalice

I take 100% pharmaceutical, pure L-Ddopa from NUTRI VICA from ebay. It is white ...... .. Maybe you .should.ld try it,.

jeeves19 profile image
jeeves19 in reply tomaryalice

My Mucuna is pure white also but leaves black stains just as lag lag described

rideabike profile image
rideabike in reply tojeeves19

Yes Nutrivita MP does all that. Annoying more than anything because of the stained washcloths and dish rags. Now I'm so careful to keep things away from it. At least it comes off the counters. Digestive juices probably clean our guts....😛 but I don't have to see it so no worries there. I usually chew xylitol gum while it's going down to keep it off my teeth or suck on a lozenge.

jeeves19 profile image
jeeves19 in reply torideabike

Thanks 🙏

sharoncrayn profile image
sharoncrayn in reply tojeeves19

J19:

Whatever you are taking, and who knows what it is since you give no info, isn't pure 100% L-DOPA. If it was, it wouldn't leave any residue...anywhere. Particularly if it is a medicinal or pharmaceutical grade with > 98% purity which is the typical grade. Pharma grade is always > 99%.

98% MP doesn't mean anything other than it is MP without any additional fillers such as "Zandopa" uses to mask the flavor of MP.

Since you provide no info on the brand or source, I assume it is out of India without a Certificate of Analysis.

It is just 98% MP without fillers and probably not an extract of any noticeable strength.

Therefore, expect some type of residue. Nothing unusual.

Sharon

jeeves19 profile image
jeeves19 in reply tosharoncrayn

Sharon. I have procured the certificate of analysis but try as I might I cannot seem to paste it into this discussion. Do you have an email or something that I could send it to as I’d be interested in your opinion? Thanks

sharoncrayn profile image
sharoncrayn in reply tojeeves19

The keys with COAs are 1) purity, 2) heavy metals, 3)current 2019.2020, and 4) country of origin.

bita94 profile image
bita94 in reply tosharoncrayn

....help us with a photo, a site for mucuna

sharoncrayn profile image
sharoncrayn in reply tobita94

see my 2 links to Jeeves below. Just cut and paste into your browser.

parkie13 profile image
parkie13 in reply tojeeves19

You could take a photo and post it as a new thread with the same title. It's the only way that I was able to do something like that.

jeeves19 profile image
jeeves19 in reply tosharoncrayn

Just had an idea that doesn’t require you to publish a personal email: if you go to Blackburn Distributions on Google ( they’re UK based) and search for Mucuna on their website they offer the certificate of analysis with the product page. Thanks

sharoncrayn profile image
sharoncrayn in reply tojeeves19

let me check later tonight.

jeeves19 profile image
jeeves19 in reply tosharoncrayn

Thanks. Appreciate it 🙏

sharoncrayn profile image
sharoncrayn in reply tojeeves19

I think I might have figured out as to where the black residue comes from.

L-dopa can come from black or dark germinated seeds and can possibly remain in the L-dopa in minute amounts when the purity is relatively low due to faulty filtration techniques.

IOW, Blackburn is possibly buying L-dopa with this residue in it, which means it isn't 98-99% pure. Can't be.

It isn't synthetic L-dopa a la sinemet.

Sharon

jeeves19 profile image
jeeves19 in reply tosharoncrayn

Cheers Sharon. Lord knows what my intestines look like 🤔😫

sharoncrayn profile image
sharoncrayn in reply tojeeves19

Remember, they probably used an undefined grade of ethanol in the extraction process. Who knows the quality and purity of the ethanol they used in the batch you are ingesting. This issue of the grade of solvent used is never covered in any COA where a herbal product is extracted. Reality.

Sharon

jeeves19 profile image
jeeves19 in reply tosharoncrayn

😕

sharoncrayn profile image
sharoncrayn in reply tojeeves19

Thanks to one of my gracious support group members....

Results from test #1 --- using 1) regular MP, 2) 20:1 extract MP, and 3)Barleans 40% extracted MP.

NO staining, black or brown, nor any other, on damp, white utility sink overnight. No peculiar residue noted.

1/2 teaspoon of powder for each sample simply dumped. Left overnight. Morning clean up required "scrubbing" to remove all of them.

NO bleach or soap required to remove samples.

Sharon

sharoncrayn profile image
sharoncrayn in reply tojeeves19

I just checked. 250 grams for $64.50 is the typical price range for this purity.

COA should be current (no older than 2019) or related to your specific batch #, no heavy metals of any kind or below poison levels, greater > than 98% purity, and provided by and done by legitimate UK/US lab.

A valid COA costs money, which many retailers never spend.

Sharon

sharoncrayn profile image
sharoncrayn in reply tojeeves19

Probably USP FCC grade which is acceptable. Not ACS which would cost much more.

Can you get a bad batch due to poor QC? Of course. Even if the COA looks good without drilling down it.

sharoncrayn profile image
sharoncrayn in reply tojeeves19

looked at it. No date. No lab name or country where lab is located. No signature.

jeeves19 profile image
jeeves19 in reply tosharoncrayn

That sounds rather damning! I’ll ring the firm tomorrow and see where/how they source. This is the trouble with taking this route of course: you’re at commercial enterprise’s mercy. 😕

sharoncrayn profile image
sharoncrayn in reply tojeeves19

Sometimes it is better to "pay up" for quality when it comes to putting something in your mouth. Some brands care; some don't.

Same goes for some generics. Squeeze a penny here and there.

JeanieBeanie profile image
JeanieBeanie in reply tojeeves19

Sinemet leaves a dark stain if one gets wet in the pocket. Try Pure Selva on Ebay uk. From Scarborough. I have never noticed that leaving marks.

luba1 profile image
luba1

Hi all,

I do not take Mucuna, but my doctor before she went to retirement suggest me to make from Sinemet liquid Sinemet and take every hour. But unfortunately it did not work out. I have a lot of dyskinesia. She told me if liquid Sinemet make a spot on your shirt it will be black color, so do not be scared. I believe similar happened with Mucuna. I am taking Sinemet 1,5 pills 25/100 every 2 hours including night time ER. If somebody can help me to start Mucuna along with Sinemet. I will deeply appreciate, I have at home Zandopa.

Thank you very much in advance! I was diagnosed in 2012, but had it I bet 8 years before. Any advice I appreciate!

Prakash1 profile image
Prakash1

I’ve been taking Mucuna for 4 years and I believe it gets drained through the urinary system

jeeves19 profile image
jeeves19

I think I just worry that my insides have turned black! It’s powerful stuff when only bleach can clean it from my sink 😕

pdpatient profile image
pdpatient in reply tojeeves19

Hi Jeeves, I take synthetic Levodopa aka Rytary and I have taken Sinemet before and ever since day one my ”excrement" or "stool" has always been black from day one. I read the tiny " million word" insert that comes with the bottle and voila, it is disclosed right there in the side effects.

BTW, I am not a fan of processed Mucuna beans with all of the peripheral nutrients stripped away.

I have learned that the organic, unprocessed powder such as from Banyan Pharmaceuticals is the real deal and I have received the benefits of natural levodopa. However, my stools still came out black. So, I would dare say that the 2% ”impurities” still give you a benefit 😊

LAJ12345 profile image
LAJ12345

Mm I wonder if mine turn purple from beetroot.😊

CapSage profile image
CapSage

In reading the warnings insert on my prescription of Sinemet 50/200 it says that taking it may cause one's sweat to stain one's clothes some degree of tan or brown . I saw no evidence personally of this until I did a purification program involving intense vitamins, minerals, and special oil intake, exercise, sauna and sweating. I surmise that this purification program was doing what it was supposed to do which included cleaning out the body and I would absolutely recommend this to anyone including Parkinsons patients. Doing this purification program improved all of my myriad Parkinson's symptoms. I was diagnosed in 2014 after having symptoms for at least two years.

jeeves19 profile image
jeeves19 in reply toCapSage

Could you amplify on this protocol please if you have time?

CapSage profile image
CapSage in reply tojeeves19

Here's a link that gives some information on the purification program I and my wife did:

scientologynews.org/faq/wha...

It's pretty intense, but it certainly helped. I may even do it again. Where are you located?

jeeves19 profile image
jeeves19 in reply toCapSage

UK? Birmingham

CapSage profile image
CapSage in reply tojeeves19

Yeah, there's a place in Birmingham that delivers that program, but I don't know what's open yet in the U.K. because of Covid....

laglag profile image
laglag

Mucuna isn't in the synthetic prescription Sinemet is it?

sharoncrayn profile image
sharoncrayn in reply tolaglag

Sinemet is a mfg. synthetic drug.

laglag profile image
laglag in reply tosharoncrayn

Why would it be staining things? And it won't wash out either?

sharoncrayn profile image
sharoncrayn in reply tolaglag

because it is probably a micro level insoluble residue contained in the product due to either the solvent used in extraction or from the original germinated seeds used which they couldn't or didn't remove.

It should not occur regardless. I doubt it was processed in the UK or USA. Probably the Middle East, India, or China.

Sharon

Eliza-Jane profile image
Eliza-Jane

Thank you!!! What perfect timing. Last week I had a biopsy checking for cervical cancer, everything was OK. My specialist can't understand why I have dark staining on my panty liners. I have had many blood tests and urine tests over the last few years for various reasons and nothing sinister has shown up, but I have this problem of staining. I will print out these comments and show her on my next visit. Thanks Adam for raising the issue and thanks to all who contributed.

jeeves19 profile image
jeeves19 in reply toEliza-Jane

Where’s my email girl?!

Eliza-Jane profile image
Eliza-Jane in reply tojeeves19

Tomorrow. Promise. :)

sharoncrayn profile image
sharoncrayn

Staining of clothing (a la urine drips) from continual (3x or 4x) daily use of sinemet is one thing (as it is with some B vitamins); residue in your glass and sink that requires bleach to remove is another thing altogether.

Someone test it by crushing a sinemet tablet in a damp sink over night.

jeeves19 profile image
jeeves19 in reply tosharoncrayn

I did. The sink went black BUT the residue was washed away fairly easily unlike the Mucuna which needs bleach.

JeanieBeanie profile image
JeanieBeanie in reply tojeeves19

I have tested mine and it doesnt leave a stain in the sink.

jeeves19 profile image
jeeves19 in reply toJeanieBeanie

I looked up Pure Selva on EBay and couldn’t find it?

sharoncrayn profile image
sharoncrayn

Thanks to one of my gracious support group members....

Results from test #1 --- using 1) regular MP, 2) 20:1 extract MP, and 3)Barleans 40% extracted MP.

NO staining, black or brown, nor any other, on damp, white utility sink overnight. No peculiar residue noted.

1/2 teaspoon of powder for each sample simply dumped. Left overnight. Morning clean up required "scrubbing" to remove all of them.

NO bleach or soap required to remove samples from sink since no color was found.

Sharon

jeeves19 profile image
jeeves19 in reply tosharoncrayn

Thanks Sharon. I’m in the UK so probably can’t access some the Mucuna that is available in the US but I’ll shop around here and see what other stockists exist. Bit of a downer as the ‘black’ MP works very well. 😕

JeanieBeanie profile image
JeanieBeanie in reply tojeeves19

I will try ours. Do I just sprinkle it in the sink?

sharoncrayn profile image
sharoncrayn

Barleans 40% is a very reputable brand and used by Hinz in his case studies...white or brown, cap or powder. barlowesherbalelixirs.com/m..., one pound for $90 USD. International shipping. Returns in 30 days. shipped from the state of Washington.

Nutrivita is another very good brand at 98-100%. $120 USD for 500 grams. Claims pharmaceutical grade. HPLC. Can't get any better. 50 grams for$30.

nutrivitashop.com/l-dopa-10... from California.

Stick with the known quality brands.

Sharon

rideabike profile image
rideabike in reply tosharoncrayn

Nutrivita from US is what I use and it leaves a black stain as my post above said. B12 (and beets) also stain my unders so stains don't bother me. Don't know what all the fuss is about.

sharoncrayn profile image
sharoncrayn in reply torideabike

RB:

If it is 100% pure, it shouldn't leave any stains, none. Same goes for pharmaceutical grade methyl B-12.

Beet powder is different matter as are many herbal/plant products sourced from India and other countries like curcumin, curry, etc. Otherwise urine stains are usually the result of excreting excess water soluble waste (drips and drabs) after urination or IC episodes coming from functional kidney filtration and normal levels of hydration of H2O.

I seriously doubt Nutrivita sources the raw material for their 100% L-DOPA from a source here in the USA, and I doubt seriously they do their own extraction to reach the 100% claimed pharma grade. I'll bet on it.

I am not saying all the Chinese chem companies do a lousy job of controlling QC, (some don't depending on the price) but distributors do shop around for the best deal many times assuming the all batch COAs are valid and up to date.

Some USA brands do their own "in-house" testing to ensure Chinese or Indian QC.

MOST DON'T, or do so only randomly to save costs.

Generic copies of patented drugs fit the same M.O. Nothing different. QC is almost always the issue.

Sharon

rideabike profile image
rideabike in reply tosharoncrayn

These are your own words>>>"Nutrivita is another very good brand at 98-100%. $120 USD for 500 grams. Claims pharmaceutical grade. HPLC. Can't get any better. 50 grams for$30." It's where I buy mine from. It stains!

nutrivitashop.com/l-dopa-10... from California.

"Stick with the known quality brands."

sharoncrayn profile image
sharoncrayn in reply torideabike

I hate to nitpick my own words, but If you re-read my comment you will notice I deliberately chose the phrase: " Claims pharmaceutical grade." "Claims" is the critical word, and I chose it carefully because Nutrivita doesn't offer a COA on your or any other powder's batch # that I am aware of. They might if you insist, but they don't offer it.

All other things being equal, Barleans and Nutrivita are the best of the high % L-DOPA powders out there. Banyan and MicroIngredients are one step down but not truly what I would call high% powders.

In capsules, NOW and Double Woods (standardized extracts probably somewhere around 15-20%... both "claiming testing done in the USA"... Manufacturing probably refers only to encapsulation) are generally very reliable brands but not high% L-DOPA products.

Every thing depends on the specific batch in which your order resides, which is why COAs refer to a specific batch. Not all batches meet or exceed specifications. Things can and do change.

I have never bought MP or L-DOPA from any of these brands, and I have no vested interest in them.

Sharon

bita94 profile image
bita94

......and Madopar leaves gray marks on the sink that need bleach

JeanieBeanie profile image
JeanieBeanie

Its under mucuna pruriens about 19th down the page. He does tablets but not as economical. Despatched from Nth Yorkshire.

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Black pepper and C/L

Has anybody experimented with taking black pepper along with C/L? According to reports, it...
HeartSong profile image

Black Jack in Vegas

We went to Las Vegas not too long ago. What a time we had. I didn't see many Parkinsonians at...
Koko profile image

The Black Box Gift and my new Username

Hi All, I hope this post finds you well. I wanted to update you regarding my username. I used to...
Jockboy17 profile image

Still skiing black runs 😎

Towards the end of last year I was chatting privately with a forum friend, and noting that my pd...
WinnieThePoo profile image

The problematic 2nd dose of the day

Good evening. Wondering if anybody else experienced similar or if you’ve any idea why the following...
jeeves19 profile image

Moderation team

See all
CPT_Aleksandra profile image
CPT_AleksandraAdministrator
CPT_Anaya profile image
CPT_AnayaAdministrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.