Negative metacolin challenge test but... - Asthma Community ...

Asthma Community Forum

22,480 members24,864 posts

Negative metacolin challenge test but bad asthma worsened by allergies

HLMB22 profile image
9 Replies

hi there,

I’m feeling rather desperate. I have always had asthma that was largely well controlled, but in October I had a hole in my lung and air trapped round my heart. They don’t know if that was caused by worsening asthma or whether the breathlessness I was feeling was caused by that.

Anyway since then my asthma has been really bad and super sensitive to my allergy triggers. I’ve now been on montelukast since christmas alongside my normal fostair, which has made some difference. However, I am still so so sensitive to my allergies in a way I never have been but only in how much they effect my breathing- for example I grew up with dogs despite being a little allergic but now I can’t go home because my asthma dramatically worsens the second I get there. A big trigger for me is also dust mites which is super hard to manage.

I recently had a metacolin challenge test to see whether I could qualify for the biological injections on the NHS but apparently the test came back fine despite me nearly fainting multiple times whilst doing it. I had to come off my inhaler for two days before and I could barely breath so I’m finding it so hard if doctors are saying it doesn’t seem to be asthma. I’ve also seen an ent and gastroligist and been tested negative for silent reflux. I have an elevated aspergillius IgG count but the doctors seem to be ignoring that right now.

I know this is long but has anyone got any advice on what to do next? I’m 23 and I currently can’t work because it’s been so bad.

Written by
HLMB22 profile image
HLMB22
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
9 Replies
Homely2 profile image
Homely2Administrator

You need to ring the asthma UK helpline on 0300 2225800, office hours. The nurses there are helpful and well informed. They will chat through this with you with no time limit and help you prepare an action plan.

I had a methacholine test, that was positive for severe asthma. However that was because my breathing was good when I started the test, so there was room for it to worsen. I do not know how the test works if your breathing is already bad when you start.

Chip_y2kuk profile image
Chip_y2kuk

I've had negative methacoline and mannitol challenges ... the people in the know (doctors) have decided I do indeed have asthma... they just can't prove it (despite there best efforts)

peege profile image
peege

I'm so sorry you're going through this. If I were you I'd ask for a CT scan to 'see' whats going on - especially to check the aspergillus isn't established in your lungs. If it is an antifungal would be prescribed to manage it. I do hope they get to tge bottom of this for you. Do give the helpline a call or copy your post to their WhatsApp number. Good luck,

Gwalltarian profile image
Gwalltarian

I am so sorry to hear of your breathing problems. Strongly request a second opinion and further tests. You are entitled to a second opinion and there’s no reason why you shouldn’t get it.

I don’t know where in the country you live but people on this site talk of tertiary centres, hospitals like the Royal Brompton get favourable mention - ask to see someone there, write to them.

I’m afraid I don’t understand a lot of the tests and language connected to modern tests - which I haven’t had - but recently I read an explanation of eosinphilic asthma, wherein it was said that the eosinophils are white blood cells that line the surfaces of the lungs and cause severe constrictions of the tubes resulting from, or in, an over reactive immune response. Further, this was linked to sinus issues and middle ear infections and something else. I could immediately identify with this because as a child whose asthma would cause my lungs to seize up for three weeks at a time whenever I had an asthma attack - I was also frequently plagued with bad nosebleeds, abscesses in my ear and vomiting. It being Asthma, I had no symptoms on the day I saw the consultant as a 7 year old and he told my parents he could do nothing for me, my childhood was ruined, I had no ‘pump’ - as the then inhaler was called.

Get whatever support you can and insist on a second opinion. What would it cost them to give you one course of a biological treatment that you obviously, so desperately, need?

Patk1 profile image
Patk1 in reply toGwalltarian

U had an awful time.thank gdness for more treatment options now.ive severe eosinophilac asthma with rhinosinusitis.biologics r helping me x

Gwalltarian profile image
Gwalltarian in reply toPatk1

👍

runcyclexcski profile image
runcyclexcski

Another criterion for getting on a biologic is having been on prednisone treatment at least 4 times a year (others can correct me -- could be 5 times). This is how they got me on a biologic in the UK. So, make sure to take your pred when you are feeling sick, and have a record of this.

I have never had the methacoline challenge done, b.c. they were afraid to do it. Instead, they gave me vontolin/albuterl/nebulizer and watched the lung function improve. That, and variations in sprirometry from day to day, was enough to diagnose.

Patk1 profile image
Patk1

Ru on antihistamines? Sounds like u need to see a respiratory consultant ASAP.do u have a salbutamol inhaler? X

HLMB22 profile image
HLMB22

Thank you so much everyone for your kind and thoughtful responses they’ve really helped! I have a follow up appointment on Tuesday and I am going to be strong in asking for further tests for asthma. I think asthma is a hard thing for the doctors and other people to really understand which can make me feel quite lonely but it’s nice to have forums like this to feel like your less alone. I did also ring the asthma uk support line and their doctors were really helpful. Thanks everyone

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

asthma worsened by naproxen

I get seasonal and exercise induced asthma. I badly pulled the muscles in my side and shoulder...
BFlying profile image

Asthma challenge test

Firstly, huge thanks to the asthma helpline for super advice in this subject. What a fab service....
Lizzie1956 profile image

asthma & respiratory illnesses

Hi - I’m asthmatic and it’s always been mild for the most part (managed by salamol & clenil for my...

Bad asthma but good SATS. A&E experience

Had a bad attack yesterday and my daughter, a nurse (now community, formerly A&E staff nurse) took...
Cagsy27 profile image

More Breathless

Hi everyone I hope your all keeping safe and well. I’ve not written on here for a long time. I am...
fallon12 profile image

Moderation team

See all
Homely2 profile image
Homely2Administrator
Lysistrata profile image
LysistrataAdministrator
ALUK_Nurses profile image
ALUK_NursesAdministrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.