? Different manufacturers of medication - Atrial Fibrillati...

Atrial Fibrillation Support

32,400 members38,733 posts

? Different manufacturers of medication

JFJ131 profile image
21 Replies

hi all… just wondering of different thoughts regarding the make of meditation we are prescribed. I am taking bisoprolol and apixaban, and seem to be getting different makes each time from the chemist. When I ask for the same make usually am met with ‘they are all the same’ …but I also gather the fillers are different and can cause different effects/side-effects.

Any thoughts or knowledge re this would be appreciated.

Written by
JFJ131 profile image
JFJ131
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
21 Replies
CDreamer profile image
CDreamer

You don’t normally have a choice unless you react to a filler. I’ve had that once only and GP then wrote a script to specify the branded version but as that cost £8/script more the practice weren’t particularly happy.

Never had a problem with generic Apixaban, can’t comment on Biso as stopped taking that 10 years ago as I couldn’t tolerate it at all.

JFJ131 profile image
JFJ131 in reply toCDreamer

Hi thanks for your reply. Sorry to be ignorant but… what is the difference / what do you mean when you say ‘branded’ version or generic’?

CDreamer profile image
CDreamer in reply toJFJ131

EG:- Apixaban is the generic name for Eliquis which is the Branded name. When a pharmaceutical company brings a product to market they will brand the product and give it a name to advertise it. Whilst the product is licensed they will be the only people to produce the drug for the years of the patent, often 20 years. After the patent expires any company can produce the drug, usually at much less cost. This is perfectly reasonable to help pharmaceutical companies to recoup the cost of research and development but in countries where patients need to pay for their drugs, can make them simply unaffordable. That is why drugs mostly have 2 names but the only one the medical profession will go by is the generic name and as drugs have never been allowed to be advertised in the UK, the only name we tend to recognise is the generic.

Different generics use different fillers or in the case of gel capsules - coatings.

There is great advantages to this as certain classes of drugs will carry the same suffix eg:- anything ending in ‘olol’ will always be a beta blocker, ‘em’ calcium channel blocker etc.

JFJ131 profile image
JFJ131 in reply toCDreamer

Thanks for explaining this.

JOY2THEWORLD49 profile image
JOY2THEWORLD49 in reply toJFJ131

Hi

Yes my bisoprolol was in foil and now its not.

Chemist told me it is the same but if you were wanting to 1/2 the tablet so much more difficult now.

Others were grey and now they are white.

Tolerance to sleepiness the same I think.

cheri joy. 75. (NZ)

Buffafly profile image
Buffafly

The one medication that always has to be the same formula is Diltiazem because they all differ slightly. If one doesn’t suit another one might - Adizem was bad for me but Slozem fine. Of course this doesn’t affect your prescription but giving as general info. If you do find one brand is much better for you you can ask the GP to specify but that could cause problems.

JFJ131 profile image
JFJ131 in reply toBuffafly

Thanks for your reply.

FraserB profile image
FraserB

I take diltiazem extended release and at refill time the pharmacist did not have that manufacturer so he substituted a different one. And he also told me they are all the same. A couple of days later I reacted with short breakthrough runs of tachycardia. It wasn't severe but it was very unusual. I phoned up two independent pharmacists and they confirmed that while the active ingredient in both Diltiazems are the same, the differences are the inactives, the formulation, and especially the time release mechanisms that influence how medication is absorbed and processed.

And I use to take the brand name Eliquis but now I take generic apixaban. The difference....cost.

JFJ131 profile image
JFJ131 in reply toFraserB

Yes, exactly how i understand it… that the fillers/inactive ingredients do make a difference. Thanks for your reply

BenHall1 profile image
BenHall1

My Felodopine and Sotalol is always same make, as is my Warfarin. Simvastatin can and does vary with each prescription repeat. No sweat with this arrangement.

Bagrat profile image
Bagrat

Most people (me included) seem to be absolutely fine with any "make" of meds. As you say some people react to fillers. The branded drug is the one originally developed and they have a monopoly on production for up to 20 years which helps to pay for the huge costs of developing a new drug. After that, other companies can make it having obtained a licence to do so.

My only concern is that the change of packaging can for some cause confusion.

Another exception as well as diltiazem is Lanoxin ( branded digoxin) as its bioavailibility is different.

JFJ131 profile image
JFJ131 in reply toBagrat

Thanks for your reply.

JOY2THEWORLD49 profile image
JOY2THEWORLD49 in reply toBagrat

Hi

In NZ Diltiazem was changed to ACCORD as other had a problem with nanufacture. But now back to original and accord did not have tghe PASS, SAfety RATE.

cheri JOY. 75. (NZ)

HGates profile image
HGates

I’ve had 4 or 5 different brands of Bisoprolol but did once have one brand that appeared to actually aggravate symptoms rather than reduce. When I spoke to the pharmacist at my surgery to ask for another prescription I got the impression it was a problem he was not unfamiliar with. I now check the brands available at the pharmacy before collecting.

JFJ131 profile image
JFJ131 in reply toHGates

Yes, .. I am planning to do this as seem to be given different ones each time…frustrating.

Thanks for your reply.

ibuputih profile image
ibuputih

Hi - I take Bisoprolol and Edoxaban. Always the same Edoxaban but the Bisoprolol brand differs frequently. The most prevalent batch of late has tiny little tablets and stiff packaging which is a nightmare.

Years ago I took omeprazole and was supplied different brands. One had a red gel coating. After a short time I had grim skin rashes all over. Surgery pharmacy refused to accept the medication was to blame and would not supply an alternative. Basically they ordered stock in and I had to accept what they had, despite GP putting note on scrip. So I went to a different pharmacy who were great. They used to order in a few of an alternative brand and keep them especially for me.

As others have said, the drug remains the same it’s the other bits that differ brand to brand.

JFJ131 profile image
JFJ131 in reply toibuputih

Yes…all quite frustrating, as I do definitely think the fillers will make a difference . Thanks for your reply.

pusillanimous profile image
pusillanimous

I agree, the only Biso that I can happily take is Cardicor by Merck. My Cardiologist prescribes it on the basis 'as needed' - I take 1.25mg if my HR touches late 90s. It brings it down quite quickly with just a a little tiredness.

JFJ131 profile image
JFJ131 in reply topusillanimous

Thanks for your reply, and good you have found one that suits you. Best wishes

Takamine profile image
Takamine

hi I’m on same meds and noticed the difference I also take acid suppressants which are very crumbly as are the apixaban. Personally I feel the fillers are irritating my stomach. I didn’t ask pharmacy suspect they are cheaper.

JFJ131 profile image
JFJ131 in reply toTakamine

I suspect you are right, re cost! Thanks for your reply.

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Medication query

My cardiologist prescribed Adizam (also known as Diltizam) 180mg Xl capsules. but, when I...
Gowers profile image

experiences with medication

I suffer from Paroxsymal AF and have had two ablations, I have been on a low dose of Dronederone...
rinty25 profile image

Ablation or Medication

I wanted to pick the forum's brains regarding Ablation or Medication. I'm sure people will have...
Jason1971 profile image

Afib Medication

Permanent Afib was diagnosed years ago. No symptoms until heart rate is checked. Doctor prescribed...
Jedburgh profile image

Changing medication

Been to see GP this morning for some blood results. While there asked again to change from...
Suzy1954 profile image

Moderation team

See all
Kelley-Admin profile image
Kelley-AdminAdministrator
jess-admin profile image
jess-adminAdministrator
Emily-Admin profile image
Emily-AdminAdministrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.