Most effective ablation method? - Atrial Fibrillati...

Atrial Fibrillation Support

32,849 members39,204 posts

Most effective ablation method?

Jafib profile image
16 Replies

I am scheduled to have open heart surgery (OHS) to replace my aortic valve and while my chest is open the surgeon said they believe it would be a good time to perform a Maze ablation for my persistent afib. FYI: I was diagnosed with afib and tach back in 2008 - both were controlled well with flecainide until this past winter when I got Covid. Anyway, is the Maze procedure fairly effective? Is it the only method available during OHS? How does it compare to other methods? I had RF ablation in 2018 that only lasted 9 months.

Thanks in advance.

Written by
Jafib profile image
Jafib
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
16 Replies
BobD profile image
BobDVolunteer

Until the invention of catheter ablation a maze was the only intervention available. Catheter ablation was invented to make the process more easliy accessible to more people; .I think one can consider it effective.

Jafib profile image
Jafib in reply toBobD

Thanks Bob!

mjames1 profile image
mjames1

the surgeon said they believe it would be a good time to perform a Maze ablation for my persistent afib.

Your surgeon is 100% correct.

The Maze is the gold standard with the best results for atrial fibrillation.

The only reason it's not used more often is because it usually involved more invasive traditional open heart surgery. In your case, you're already having open-heart surgery, so that is not an issue.

Hopefully you can expect a very good result for your atrial fibrillation.

Jim

Jafib profile image
Jafib in reply tomjames1

Thanks Jim!

Millbrook profile image
Millbrook

There is also Pulse Field Ablation -PFA- which our cardiologist considers as the gold standard.

Jafib profile image
Jafib in reply toMillbrook

Can that be done during open heart surgery or is that one they do through the leg?

mjames1 profile image
mjames1 in reply toJafib

Maze must better than Pulse Field Ablation (PFA) in your case. Better results and would not involve going though the groin as it's catheter based. PFA results similar to RF and Cryo. Maze has better results.

Jim

mjames1 profile image
mjames1 in reply toMillbrook

Arguably the gold standard in catheter ablations, but Maze is gold standard overall. The only reason it isn't used more is because it's a more invasive procedure, but since the OP is already having open heart surgery, that is not an issue.

JIm

Millbrook profile image
Millbrook

They did it through the leg. I do not know if it can be done during open heart

Mrsvemb profile image
Mrsvemb

The only way you can get the maze procedure is if you are already having OHS. It is the most effective way of curing afib.

I am pretty certain that there are no other options for afib during OHS.

I would certainly jump at the chance of the maze, if undergoing OHS. It is the best treatment that you can get for afib. Certainly beats any type of ablation.

Cardiologists don’t have the same level of success with their toolbox of ablations. This is on another level. Go for it.

Let us know what you decide.

mjames1 profile image
mjames1 in reply toMrsvemb

The only way you can get the maze procedure is if you are already having OHS.

The latest version of the maze is Cox Maze IV. It can be performed with and without opening the sternum and a heart lung machine.

Because of this, the version without opening the sternum is being offered by major centers (at least in the US) as a standalone procedure for afib and is considered minimally invasive surgery.

This is not to be confused with the Wolff Mini Maze -- also minimally, invasive heart surgery for afib -- that does not do the complete Cox lesion set, but focuses more on the pulmonary veins.

Jim

mav7 profile image
mav7

Jafib Please pardon while I go a little off course.

I have persistent afib and at this time moderate aortic stenosis, meaning in the future I will face the same decision.

Was a transcatheter aortic valve replacement (TAVR) not an option or did the doctors recommend open heart surgery (OHS) in your particular case ?

And did the doctor feel the aortic stenosis contributed/caused afib ?

I have read in some case OHS is best if the aortic valve is heavily calcified.

As to your question and as others indicate, it definitely would be best to do the Maze.

Best to You !

Jafib profile image
Jafib in reply tomav7

Hello Mav7. I discussed TAVR with the docs, however, there are a couple reasons it is not recommended at my age (55): First, the valve in your aorta is not round, it is more oblong, I believe, which may cause fit issues with the inserted bio valve (bio valve is round). Now, of course, that is not always an issue or even an issue much of the time or they would not perform TAVR regularly. The second concern is that if I had TAVR now at 55 that the valve would likely wear out before I would die of other causes and would then require OHS at an older age, which could be riskier at that time - especially if the bio valve lasted 20+ years. The reason OHS would be required at that time is that they would probably not want to place a TAVR valve inside another TAVR valve - it would have to be quite small.

There was no mention of the bicuspid valve or its stenosis having any relation to my afib.

mav7 profile image
mav7

Certainly appreciate your detailed info.

Sounds as if you have good doctors. I can understand the reasoning. I am 77 so a different ballgame. 🙂

Best to You !

Jafib profile image
Jafib in reply tomav7

It is certainly a different ballgame at age 77, however, I wouldn't completely rule out open heart surgery - Barbara Walters had her aortic valve replaced via open heart at age 80! Personally, however, if I had my original valve, I would probably lean toward TAVR if I were 77. Another thought, if you are only at moderate stenosis at age 77, you may never progress to severe...

mav7 profile image
mav7

you may never progress to severe...

Very much appreciate those encouraging words.

Did not know about Barbara Walters. Thanks for info.

.

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Ablation success record

Which of the following treatments for AFib has the best success record? Radiofrequency ablation...
dave205 profile image

Zio Monitor Results

I have a 16 year history of afib and for the majority of that time it was controlled through...
Jafib profile image

Mini Maze Procedures, there is a place for all, my personal view

I am sure I am not the only one who has been saddened by the recent heated discussions on the mini...
MummyLuv profile image

Afib following Ablation

Had an ablation done 11 days ago. Was feeling great and no Afib up until this morning. Been in...
Nickr282 profile image

ABLATION

Hi i have a pre assessment coming up for catheter ablation what does it involve ? and i am still in...
Pinky100 profile image

Moderation team

See all
Kelley-Admin profile image
Kelley-AdminAdministrator
Emily-Admin profile image
Emily-AdminAdministrator
jess-admin profile image
jess-adminAdministrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.