Doctor knows best!!: Haha you'll like... - Atrial Fibrillati...

Atrial Fibrillation Support

31,322 members36,990 posts

Doctor knows best!!

Bagrat profile image
30 Replies

Haha you'll like this! I asked for copy of GPs letter following husband's private consult with cardiologist he has always see n via NHS. Didn't arrive so left message for his sec.Apparently Consultant does not like sending copy letters as people Google then bombard him with questions and he'd rather it was discussed with GP to avoid misunderstandings! I said I was retired nurse, had specifically asked for letter ( who knows how much or how little GP will share) saying my husband would not read it but I would!

She's sending one today!! I wanted access to his recommendations ( for brain scan, memory clinic and neurologist was what he said to us) as I know these can only be recommendations.

I have complete faith in the clinical decisions of both but these are our issues qnd as is so often said here, "knowledge is power". Many of my friends ( and my husband!) would rather not know too much.

Written by
Bagrat profile image
Bagrat
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
30 Replies
pottypete1 profile image
pottypete1

My EP copies me with all the letters he sends to my GP. He has always been an excellent communicator.

Pete

Fibber222 profile image
Fibber222 in reply to pottypete1

And me too.

mjames1 profile image
mjames1

It was like that in the US until a few years ago. You had to beg and sometimes that wasn't enough. Now, everything -- test results, doctors notes, etc, goes online as soon as they are generated. In most cases I would get the test results before my doctors 😀 Was that because all of a sudden our doctors became enlightened and prescribed to shared medical decision making? Oh No. It was because Federal and State laws were passed. So write your MP (hope I got that right. 😀

jeanjeannie50 profile image
jeanjeannie50

I always get copies of all my consultants letters to my GP. Different areas of the UK all vary so much.

in reply to jeanjeannie50

yes, we do too, but sometimes our notes on the patient access medical history are not correct-a case pinpoint-I was scanning through mine a week or so ago, and saw that someone had written my thyroxine dose was 1000mcg!! They meant 100mcg, but what a terrible mistake to make if another medic needed to check! I was furious and got them to change it PDQ. Also, another incident, I have a branch retinal vein occlusion, which causes no symptoms by requires an injection into my eye every 4 weeks. It won't deteriorate into macular degeneration, but, because I have been tagged onto the AMD clinic (so I see the same dr each time-my choice) my surgery have assumed I have AMD and it is on my notes! Another change is imminent!

baba profile image
baba

Everyone is entitled to have copies of all letters and test results, in UK

momist profile image
momist in reply to baba

Sadly, 'entitled' doesn't mean that it happens. ☹️

baba profile image
baba in reply to momist

Tell “them” you want access to “your” information under GDPR rules

GDPR (General Data Protection Regulations)

“One of the aims of the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) is to empower individuals and give them control over their personal data. The GDPR has a chapter on the rights of data subjects (individuals) which includes the right of access, the right to rectification, the right to erasure, the right to restrict processing, the right to data portability, the right to object and the right not to be subject to a decision based solely on automated processing”

Bagrat profile image
Bagrat in reply to baba

Thanks, interesting, I'm sure it will arrive now but good to know

baba profile image
baba in reply to Bagrat

You are not entitled to your husband's information without his permission!!!!

Bagrat profile image
Bagrat in reply to baba

Yes I know: we've signed all forms at surgery, he has complex selection of ailments so 2 heads better than one, especially as he buries head in sand!!

Gumbie_Cat profile image
Gumbie_Cat

it seems to vary between consultants. I would rather be copied in, though I can ask my GP practice.

Bagrat profile image
Bagrat in reply to Gumbie_Cat

Never had an issue before.

Gumbie_Cat profile image
Gumbie_Cat

I’ve found it recently, though other consultants send me a copy of the letter following a consultation. Seems rather paternalistic though!

Omniscient1 profile image
Omniscient1

Double bad marks to the consultant as you are his customer, you're paying him!!

DevonHubby1 profile image
DevonHubby1

Here in Devon they have an electronic system called 'MyCare'. If you sign up for it you get all your hospital appointments by email and see all test results and letters. Its not perfect but allows us to nag GP when we don't see them actioning what the consultant has requested.

Meg24rd profile image
Meg24rd in reply to DevonHubby1

thats interesting to know, will look into it, very fortunate with my cardiologist at Derriford

Singwell profile image
Singwell

Yes, that made me 😁. You can sort of understand when so many of us use Dr Google, put 2 and 2 together to make 55 and then jump to conclusions because we don't have the training. Not in your case of course! But anybody can find anything on the Internet these days and instantly think they're now an expert. My profession for instance!! But holding back the patient's info isn't the solution either. We also need more access to pur GPs do they can explain implications of test results. Preferably in a meeting- not just a phonecall.

1290Duke profile image
1290Duke

Get your husband on the NHS website, sign up for an account then fill in a form at the GP to enable online access to his medicals records. Job done, you will have access to all test reports and letters.

Bagrat profile image
Bagrat in reply to 1290Duke

We both have that but in our area you can't see letters or we in spite of diligent searches have not found them. In any case this was a private consult which was why I particularly wanted a copy.

Carew profile image
Carew in reply to Bagrat

If nothing else works, put in a Subject Access Request to the consultant.

(Maybe the consultant's records are actually held by a private clinic/hospital? In which case consultant should, indeed must, pass on request to them. You don't need to know or care.)

Finite length of time to respond. Check the Information Commissioner's website for details.

Carrie27 profile image
Carrie27

Have never heard of this before and it does not comply with NHS guidelines that patients should be fully informed so that they can give informed consent. In past 2 years I have been seen by several different consultants, from several different specialties, due to various complications following GCA and not one has not sent me a copy of the letter they send to my GP.

Cat04 profile image
Cat04

You can access your medical letters to your GP on the NHS app or Patient Access.

Carew profile image
Carew in reply to Cat04

Not available everywhere.

Cat04 profile image
Cat04 in reply to Carew

I'm sorry, I thought the NHS app/Patient Access was available to all. I did have to get permission from my GP's practice to register to view my documents & hosp letters. Apologies for my mistake.

Carew profile image
Carew in reply to Cat04

Apologies absolutely NOT needed. :-)

Not in Wales and Scotland and I doubt in Northern Ireland. Plus there are issues at quite a number of GP surgeries in England.

Ducky2003 profile image
Ducky2003

My consultants, across all disciplines, send me a copy of the letter sent to my GP (I'm in the Midlands) and yes, there's been a couple of "what's that???" moments but I phone or email, not Google.

Vonnegut profile image
Vonnegut

I tried to “like” what you have written but it went from “4”to “unlike” ! I think your contribution is very good and I’m sure others do too, so far more than 4 of us!!

Fibber222 profile image
Fibber222

I would have thought that as he has paid for the service that he should get a report back from the consultant for sure. Anyone correct me if I’m wrong.

kkatz profile image
kkatz

Hi I have access to my online records at GP and can usually read & download.However I do get copies from EP & Neurologist.Sometimes before my GP practice puts online.

You may also like...

Patient knows best

do the Digoxin test. I asked her to check with the doctor, she said she would when one was free. A...

Does your doctor know about AF association/HealthUnlocked?

well for 4 years until recently. 3 cardiologists, 2 EPs, 6 GPs, having moved twice. All good chaps.

Its not who you are but who you know.

system. When I had my chat with my consultant last month he said he would arrange an...

Help...I don't know what to do!

appointment next Wednesday with an EP at his private clinic. He also works at the Cardiology unit...

Can a doctor legally oblige you to follow their dosing advice?

days ago, gaygay45 said \\"I self test and would like to self-regulate, but the clinic does not...