Sleep Aid 2: Asked my PCP and... - Atrial Fibrillati...

Atrial Fibrillation Support

32,309 members38,580 posts

Sleep Aid 2

Jafib profile image
16 Replies

Asked my PCP and Cardiologist for sleep aid recommendations and got these responses:

PCP: "I would stick to things like melatonin and antihistamines to avoid complications with your arrythmia as most others are going to be sedatives which can adversely affect those."

Cardiologist: "Over the counter melatonin is ok. Otherwise, you may want to discuss with your PCP."

Not quite what I was expecting...

Several members of my extended family have tried melatonin over the years, but none seemed to think it helped...

Written by
Jafib profile image
Jafib
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
16 Replies
sleeksheep profile image
sleeksheep

members of my extended family have tried melatonin over the years, but none seemed to think it helped...

Start with the lowest dose possible and then work up till the dose works, high doses have been shown to not be as effective because they stop your own production.

300mcg / 500mcg should be sufficient in most cases.

Be careful with antihistamines as they can give you tachycardia .

I take 25mg diphenhydramine for sinus but wouldnt take more than that in 24hr period.

Paulbounce profile image
Paulbounce

Hi Jafib.

It's OK. I use it and it helps a little. If you buy over the counter at a pharmacist you'll pay top dollar. PM me if you want a really good online supplier - they have an offer on now and you'll pick up a box of 100 for 3 or 4 quid. They sell all sorts of vitamins and are the cheapest and best quality I have found online - they've never let me anyway. I'll point out I'm not affiliated with them in any way - just a happy customer.

My other suggestion is to ask your doctor for either Zolpidem or Zopiclone. These aren't long-term solutions but do work. Ask your doctor if it's OK to take them with afib (I think I know what the answer will be) and consider taking one as a PIP if you have a few sleepless nights on the trot.

Paul

etheral profile image
etheral in reply toPaulbounce

Zolpidem works great when taken occasionally for me and hasn't affected my afib..

CDreamer profile image
CDreamer

If your circadian rhythms are the cause of your sleeplessness then Melatonin can help. I used in when travelling and found it great. If your sleeplessness is caused by stress, or anything else then you need to try other therapies.

There are a lot of Sleep Clinics around and I saw this lady about 15 years ago now who helped me with my regaining my sleep patterns - no drugs involved. I saw her on the NHS but unfortunately they weren’t able to support the research she wanted to do so is now in private practice. All I can say is worked for me - I went from sleeping barely 3 hours a night to full 8 hours now, granted I was also treated for Sleep Apnea.

There is really good information on her site though and on-line group sessions about CBTi which is a behavioural method so no drugs involved

sleepyheadclinic.co.uk/

There are Sleep Clinics all over the country these days but most doctors don’t seem to know about them. There is one NHS clinic near where I live now but the waiting list is ridiculous.

Hope some of that helps.

PlanetaryKim profile image
PlanetaryKim

I have tried melatonin quite a lot. someimtes as a one-off, sometimes for a couple weeks. prolonged usage for me seems to cause afib each time. That's why I stop.

I researched online and found one paper that did indeed outline 2 cases of men who exhibited afib on as little as 1 mg melatonin nightly... and the afib problem disappeared when they discontinued the melatonin. I too have noticed this if I take as little as 1 mg (which is quite a small amount). The other thing for me with melatonin is I quicky develop tolerance to it and need to take more to get same result. So even if I start at 0.5 mg, after a few nights or a week, I need 1.0 mg, and after a few nights of that, I will likely be having an afib episode.

also, melatonin is not something to take nightly long-term because it will suppress/halt the brain's ability to produce melatonin... and you might have trouble getting that ability back.

if you're just loooking for an occasional sleep aid , melatonin might be okay if it works for you. Start small. Like 0.5 mg. Melatonin is somethng that in higher doses can make some people agitated or at least alert - the opposite of what you want. I'm one of those people who would be alert if I take several mg of melatonin, but i can get mildly drowsy on 0.5 mg. and 0.5 mg has never seemd to cause afib in me. it just stops working after a few nights at at that low dose.

I have used zopiclone (3.75 mg) nightly for several years now. as sleep aids go, this is the best solution I have found for long-term use (although you will be told not to use it long-term, but I am better of with it than without it, which would mean living with relentelss sleep loss).

I have also sometimes used diphenhydramine, dimenhydrinate, GABA, 5-HTP, L-Theanine. None are quite as good and clean as zopiclone - especially for long-term use. But they are all availble OTC. whereas zopiclone requires prescription

Hennerton profile image
Hennerton

I used to have trouble sleeping and then someone on this site, years ago, made suggestions and now I have a “sleep routine “ that has helped enormously. Here goes:-

Don’t watch an exciting film or read an exciting book late at night.

Don’t try to do work that stimulates the brain late at night.

Don’t use anything with blue light, like a Kindle.

Develop a calm routine and try to go to bed at the same time most nights,

Have a milky drink if you like and sip it in bed.

Read a calming book for a while until feeling a little sleepy.

Turn off light, have a totally dark bedroom and then do slow breathing. Take a deep breath, hold for count of seven and then expel air firmly for a count of 8 . Do this four times. Lie quietly and you will soon be fast asleep. (Do not suddenly remember you need to do something urgently, as you will ruin all your efforts.)

CDreamer profile image
CDreamer in reply toHennerton

Agree with everything you have said - sleep hygiene as it called is very important- I would add one mor - keep pen/pad next to your bed to note things if urgent thoughts do come into your head - do a mind dump.

secondtry profile image
secondtry in reply toCDreamer

Agree totally with you both.

Physalis profile image
Physalis

Up until a year or so ago I didn't go off to sleep that quickly but then I discovered BBC Sounds and podcasts. Now I lie down, listen to something and I'm asleep within minutes.

For me the BBC's From Our Own Correspondent or the World Service's Inside Science are the most effective but others might want to listen to something else or music.

I should add that I get the Sounds app on my Amazon Fire tablet. I sometimes listen to Dr John Campbell on YouTube. I set it to turn off in 30 minutes.

There's even something called The Sleeping Forecast - out like a light - but that's not my thing!

Countrydweller2 profile image
Countrydweller2

Solgar magnesium citrate changed my life. Stopped my afib and cured a lifetime of insomnia and constipation.

Jafib profile image
Jafib in reply toCountrydweller2

Thanks for the response! How much do you take and at what time of day?

Countrydweller2 profile image
Countrydweller2 in reply toJafib

I am sorry I may have raised your hopes too much but it was a miracle for me. I read The Magnesium Miracle by Carolyn Dean and then took Solgar citrate 400mg tabs from Amazon. I can't remember how many I took back in 2015 but it was obviously right for me at that time ending my insomnia and constipation as well as Afib. But the Afib returned after two years so I stopped taking it, it's not right for everyone.

My sister took it just for insomnia and it made her heart race, So you need to find out more about the different types of magnesium to see what's best for you.

I now get one or two AFibs a year. Unfortunately I had one last June and had a stroke a day or two later, and I had an Afib a week or so ago, nine months apart. I am considering trying magnesium again but I haven't suffered from insomnia since I took it last so it might not be right for me this time. I need to find the book again.... or buy it again. 🙄

Jafib profile image
Jafib in reply toCountrydweller2

Also, I see they have a wide variety of options - Calcium Magnesium Citrate; Liquid form, tablet form, chelated magnesium; chelated Calcium Magnesium; and on and on it goes. Just want to make sure I get the right thing! Thanks

secondtry profile image
secondtry

I would first try the excellent routines already mentioned above before supplements. A test for sleep apnoea is also good as are nasal strips, lip strip and slow breathing exercises during the day. Also, I have found a spiritual element in a quiet time before bed is helpful, for me it is prayer and visualising a calm scene in Nature that I know well from regular walks - this takes you out of your normal thought patterns.

Latest, I have decreased my CoQ10 supplement (I was already at the top of the normal range) as I suspected it was boosting my heart rate keeping me buzzing in the evening instead of slowing down. I think this has helped.

Hennerton profile image
Hennerton

you have had many useful replies and people have taken their time to try to help you. It would be good to have some kind of response from you, (if only to say that you have tried all suggestions without success).

Jafib profile image
Jafib in reply toHennerton

Sorry, whole family sick, wife was in the hospital - really wasn’t focused on this last few days. I’ll try to give an update soon.

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

AF and sleep

Just to ask and give an update. Thanks for the Cheery juice recipe but it was so expensive with...
Norm profile image

Sleep Aid

Anyone use children’s Benadryl or Unisom to help sleep? Or another remedy? My doctor actually...
Jafib profile image

sleep

Good morning my husband has just been diagnosed with AF waiting to see cardiologist has been given...
Maisiemay13 profile image

Sleeping aid with Afib.

Just curious to see what you folks that have problems going to sleep have been prescribed to help...
riffjack846 profile image

AF triggered by sleep apnea

Hello - My first post! Question to others here experiencing paroxysmal AF, has the use of a CPAP...
moleman37 profile image

Moderation team

See all
Emily-Admin profile image
Emily-AdminAdministrator
Kelley-Admin profile image
Kelley-AdminAdministrator
jess-admin profile image
jess-adminAdministrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.