Phone app: Are apps to your phone any... - Atrial Fibrillati...

Atrial Fibrillation Support

32,400 members38,733 posts

Phone app

Vonnieruth profile image
21 Replies

Are apps to your phone any good .I found on titled AF detector where you place finger on your camera and it takes reading You then can save reading in history .

Sorry had to have a go didn't I lol apparently no AF was detected but I have not felt any palpitations so far today

Written by
Vonnieruth profile image
Vonnieruth
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
21 Replies
Alpaca555 profile image
Alpaca555

Hi... yes I have an app ... I think it’s quite accurate and I’ve sent the readings to my EP who finds it very helpful... 😊

Vonnieruth profile image
Vonnieruth in reply toAlpaca555

Thanks May I ask what app you use

Alpaca555 profile image
Alpaca555 in reply toVonnieruth

Hi... I have Instant Heart Rate (free version) and Runtastic Heart Rate Monitor. I’m on an iPhone. 😊

Vonnieruth profile image
Vonnieruth

Thank you

Kaz747 profile image
Kaz747

I've tested the Instant Heartrate app when I've been in hospital hooked up to all the leads and the pulse rate is exactly the same as what the hospital monitor shows so I believe that is accurate. There are a few apps that say the detect AF but I'm not convinced about their accuracy. They have mixed reviews.

bennie06 profile image
bennie06

I use "Cardiograph" which i find from experience will let you know if your in AF because it wil have difficulty in taking a reading. Currently takes a reading with no problem (which is accurate). Long may it continue. Good luck.

momist profile image
momist

The difficulty with all the phone apps is the same as that with using the 'heart rate monitor' on a Fitbit or similar. Whilst you are in normal sinus rhythm, all is well and the app will be accurate. When you go into AF, it will only show those heart heats which have resulted in a pulse of blood pressure, not the in-between beats which are the heart beating while it is still empty from the last one. I find that my Fitbit will read about 78 while the Kardia shows AF at 135 or similar, resting. The beats are all over the place, some piling up one on another while others are spaced apart.

They all use the camera (or Fitbit's optical cell) to detect the slight pinking up of the skin as the capillaries dilate under the increased pressure during a pulse. Really, they are a pulse monitor, not a heart monitor.

I also tried a pulse monitor on my Android phone which had worked fine (NSR) on my old phone. On my newer one it got readings OK but the flash light used to illuminate the finger got way too hot to use and gave me a slight burn, so it depends on your phone.

KMRobbo profile image
KMRobbo

I have one on a Samsung called cardiac diagnosis. It has me in bradycardia quite a lot which I don't suffer from , and my pulse rate seems to vary a lot which is not what my Garmin chest belt/hr monitor tells me when I compare it.

Consequently I do not trust it. I have never been in AF since I got it so I do not know if it would pick it up.

What I do know is when I saw the red warning sign on the screen when it detected the Bradycardia I instantly felt worried and upset ( an "oh no! What now? I am so fed up!" response) . And I have not been in afib for months following an ablation!

Then I engaged my brain and thought why am I believing an app I have just downoaded produced by persons unknown and with unknown medical knowledge, when I feel perfectly fine and have no other indication that anything is wrong?

If you are already feeling fragile these feelings/ stress must be worse.

If you think you may have an issue you need to go and get some measurements from a trained person using specialist ecg equipment and don't dwell on the readings from a cheap app. The worry it is causing you is probably causing you more issues than your underlying problem.

Best wishes

Annpatricia profile image
Annpatricia in reply toKMRobbo

Couldn’t agree more

Mikeafib profile image
Mikeafib in reply toKMRobbo

Can you share your experience w the ablation procedure ? I am contemplating on having one. Any info would be helpful. How long did you have Afib for before deciding on having an ablation? I assume you were in meds ? Did they work ? Any side effects ? Thx

KMRobbo profile image
KMRobbo in reply toMikeafib

Mike I will but an just busy now - if you can find some of my previous replies I have described my experiences quite recently in the last week I think

In any case ib will get back to you later today.

My experiences are good so far by the way.

Currently off drugs with no af

Mikeafib profile image
Mikeafib in reply toKMRobbo

Not sure how to look for your previous posts. But I ll try and thanks for the quick response. When you have time hit me up. Thx

Vonnieruth profile image
Vonnieruth

Totally agree with you to be honest. It's called photo af detector

Jollies profile image
Jollies

I decided to have a bit of fun with my sons devices as I am in permanent af. Got totally different readings from his phone and his Fitbit within a space of 5 mins x

KathFrances profile image
KathFrances

My cardiologist will only accept a Kardia reading, which I can email to him. He said that the other apps aren't reliable or accurate enough, but Kardia is to professional ECG standards.

Vonnieruth profile image
Vonnieruth in reply toKathFrances

Lot more expensive though for people like me on limited income

KathFrances profile image
KathFrances

Yes, I'm also on limited income so I had to save up, but am really pleased I paid the £92 to get Kardia and now I have free checks and peace of mind about potential AF symptoms, hopefully for the rest of my life. It's proving more than worth the initial outlay.

Vonnieruth profile image
Vonnieruth in reply toKathFrances

What time of phone do you need for it to work

Vonnieruth profile image
Vonnieruth

Did you get it off amazon

KathFrances profile image
KathFrances

I don't think it was Amazon, but it was a UK company - I googled something like: Kardia cheapest buy UK and checked the best deal. Not sure what types of phone - I've got an old iPhone 5S. The seller or Kardia will have a list of which phones it works on. Good luck!

Bshersey profile image
Bshersey

I use Samsung Health and Heart Rate Plus on my Samsung G7 Galaxy. I have read that the fingertip apps are actually much more accurate than the wrist-based apps like Fitbit. But if you want an accurate reading you really need a chest strap. I have a Wahoo Tickr that I bought off Amazon for about $50 that reads on my phone.

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Alivecor vs phone app....for a friend

My friend (doesn't have AF) is using a free heart rate phone app, but wants something that will...
Wightbaby profile image

Phone

Yesterday in a chat over bruising I mentioned that I had put my medication and info if my AF on the...
Vonnieruth profile image

Ablation for all types of AF?

I was reading a recent post - To 'ablate or not to ablate' by Tamgirl. Most responses were yes to...
OzRob profile image

Persistent/ permanent AF episode and exercise

Hello to all again , I have been reading your postings as usual with interest. I would be...
Bahman profile image

Cardiologist app

So I was diagnosed with persistent AF three weeks ago after a few days in hospital. No follow up...
Horns99 profile image

Moderation team

See all
Kelley-Admin profile image
Kelley-AdminAdministrator
jess-admin profile image
jess-adminAdministrator
Emily-Admin profile image
Emily-AdminAdministrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.