Overdiagnosis Only a Matter of Time W... - Atrial Fibrillati...

Atrial Fibrillation Support

32,312 members38,584 posts

Overdiagnosis Only a Matter of Time With ECG Watches

EngMac profile image
12 Replies

Dr. Mandrola often has a different point of view than what seems to be the norm.

This could be worth a read since he gives an opinion about stroke risk different from the norm, at least as I know it.

I haven't been reading all posts of late, so I apologize if this has already been posted.

Written by
EngMac profile image
EngMac
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
12 Replies
EngMac profile image
EngMac

Apparently, when I posted the Medscape link it took a person to my email. I will need to repost the link when I figure this out.

dommydops profile image
dommydops

I just read that article myself: it's very interesting. Aspects of the association between AF and stroke have always seemed puzzling to me - e.g. the fact that - as I've read, anyway - the data haven't yielded a definite distinction between the stroke risks accompanying paroxysmal and permanent AF, and the fact that they don't provide evidence that ablation reduces stroke risk, even when it does reduce the AF burden. There's a lot left to learn!

EngMac profile image
EngMac in reply todommydops

Try this website for the article on Medscape: medscape.com/viewarticle/88....

The article below about computers reading ECG recordings is a bit disconcerting.

medscape.com/viewarticle/87...

You may need to log into Medscape to get the articles. Apparently, the link I originally included gives my email if you do not have a Medscape account which is inappropriate for them to do this.

in reply toEngMac

Thank you. A fascinating article. I wonder what data Alivecor use to claim 98% specificity for their device. Presumably not real world data. Well not with my Kardia.

souljacs4 profile image
souljacs4

Cant find a link

EngMac profile image
EngMac

souljacs4 try with the new links.

doodle68 profile image
doodle68

Hi EngMac :-) the conclusion to the article states...

[quote=Conclusion......

The goal of stroke prevention with mobile personal ECGs is reasonable. Giving patients control of their data is, too. And no doubt, future doctors will better understand the normal range of ambient arrhythmias. An AF episode that today begins an overtesting cascade may someday be considered normal.

But once again, I worry that mobile ECGs will distract both patients and doctors. We already have effective ways to prevent stroke. In a study of more than 11,000 high-risk patients, Swedish authors observed a 72% lower risk of stroke in those who ate well, moved, maintained a normal body weight, drank low to moderate amounts of alcohol, and did not smoke.[16] Two recent large observational studies confirmed the cardiovascular benefits of physical activity.[17,18]

I know this may seem like nonspecific, unsexy advice, but lifestyle modification is safe, and everyone agrees it delivers huge health benefits.

The mobile ECG is a nice tool for specific tasks. It's fun. But it's fantasy to think it will improve health outcome]

That sounds logical to me ....

secondtry profile image
secondtry in reply todoodle68

Totally agree!

Peddling profile image
Peddling

Interesting article and one with which I heartily agree (no pun intended).

Finvola profile image
Finvola

Fascinating article and the analysis of strokes in AF patients is rather sobering. John Mandrola is not afraid to think outside the box. Thank you for posting.

BobD profile image
BobDVolunteer

I think most people are aware of my views on these sorts of devices so I won't bore you any more. I do agree that life style changes and whole life treatment of conditions has a valuable place in today's world.

CDreamer profile image
CDreamer

I don’t really see that it will lead to over diagnosis as in my experience although self monitoring can be very helpful, medics tend to only diagnose when they capture ECG traces on their own machines and under supervision. But it could be reflection of poor protocol procedures and medics taking short cuts.

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

From a newbie-Night time only problems!

Hello, can you advise whether this sounds like A Fib or Flutter? I seem to be perfectly fine in the...
Chappy1 profile image

3rd time in 8 months rushed to A + E with AF

Sorry i'm new to all this & never blogged anything, probs got it all wrong & should be writing this...
krich69 profile image

Heart of the matter

I am so grateful for all of your kind responses to my questions. I have another- it might sound...
Clarajoan profile image

Flecainde and eposides

Experience. What is the norm for an episode of afib. Dosage 100x2. Longest abd shortest. Was a...
Grace4291 profile image

Having a grim time of things...

My AF seems to have taken a turn for the worst. After a long and stressful day yesterday I had...

Moderation team

See all
Kelley-Admin profile image
Kelley-AdminAdministrator
Emily-Admin profile image
Emily-AdminAdministrator
jess-admin profile image
jess-adminAdministrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.