PSA projection model?: is there a... - Advanced Prostate...

Advanced Prostate Cancer

22,373 members28,135 posts

PSA projection model?

Chugach profile image
16 Replies

is there a mathematical model that is used to estimate trajectory of PSA rise? Certainly doubling rate is a consideration easy enough to calculate, but at what point do these rates become non-linear?

My last 3-yrs on Keytruda have been great - life pretty much back to normal. Yr 1undetectable PSA; Yr 2-3 slow creep from 0 to 1

I’m starting Yr 4 and trying to estimate how long I have before this reaches ~10 and then 20 at that point lutetium is the next (last?) recommended arrow in the quiver.

How much longer can I expect to ride the Keytruda Train?

Written by
Chugach profile image
Chugach
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
16 Replies
Tall_Allen profile image
Tall_Allen

PSADT is non-linear. You need at least 3 values over 0.1 to fit the curve. But the error of estimate increases with time. It's pretty useless for finding the kind of projection you want.

Chugach profile image
Chugach in reply toTall_Allen

Thanks Allen - I’ll give it a shot. I know it’s non-linear but at low values over 2 years mine has appeared overall linear. It just seems I’m about at the inflection point where it starts to switch to exponential.. (or at least that’s my fear). As always thank you!!

dac500 profile image
dac500

I have been pretty successful in predicting in what narrow range my next PSA reading would be during the last four years on iADT for my metastatic prostate cancer. But recently things changed. I was expecting my PSA on January 23 would be in the range 0.15 to 0.20. But it was actually 0.32 slightly up from 0.29 three months ago with castrate level testosterone. Honestly speaking it makes little sense trying to fit PSA to a mathematical formula.

Poowater profile image
Poowater

The normal doubling time is once a year. Mine was doubling every 2 weeks ie aggressive cancer. Now I'm on 2nd treatment Pluvicto. That has brought psa down by 59% in a month.

cesces profile image
cesces

I recollect there was some radiation oncologist who had a PSA algorithm he used for another purpose.

He would use it to calculate the doubling rate.

People take PSA tests whenever. So it is hard to calculate a doubling rate.

I guess this , or a similar, algorithm could do what you want.

Though as Tall Allen says, it will be of limited utility.

Still it might be comforting.

Actually I bet there are a number of people here who could whip up something like on a shareable Google spreadsheet in minutes.

Boywonder56 profile image
Boywonder56 in reply tocesces

Your in a room full of castrated men....we cant " whip" up anything. BW

Justfor_ profile image
Justfor_

If your detectable (undetectable don't count) time series comprises 10 or more 2 decimal places samples, I could crunch the numbers for you. Yet, I can tell you that the confidence level of such a projection into the future will be +/- some years, if that finally serves any purpose for you.

kreg001 profile image
kreg001

You may find this interesting. I’d suggest looking for papers that cite it as well.

ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articl...

Chugach profile image
Chugach in reply tokreg001

this is great- thanks!

it’s never linear and no one can predict. This disease has a mind of its own.

MateoBeach profile image
MateoBeach

An inflection to steeper rising will alert you that resistance to the current regimen, including Keytruda, is emerging and it’s time to reevaluate (scans, liquid biopsy, and ?). There are more arrows in the quiver than just one. BAT combined with Olaparib for one example. Look through available trials and emerging research. That is what we do here. We try to stay a step or two ahead.

Chugach profile image
Chugach in reply toMateoBeach

thanks Mateo!! I’ve been through a lot (including a highT clinical trial) and all the normal SOC, but I appreciate the reminder to never quit looking for arrows!

Stoneartist profile image
Stoneartist

I use a simple PSA vs time plot with the PSA plotted on a log scale in excel (see my profile). It works for me and I have been predicting my next value with great success - except for one outburst of Castrate resistance which showed up like a beacon on the curve. Next PSA test in 10 days - expecting around 0.07 - but there will be a error range due to that I am getting near the sensitivity of the test

NecessarilySo profile image
NecessarilySo

When a cell divides, it doubles. The number of cells, x, equals 2n, where n is the number of divisions.: X=2n. that is not linear, but charts to a curve, parabolic. 1, 2, 4, 8, 16, 32, 64, ...etc. Cancer beats us because it forgets how to die like normal cells. It can be slowed down, and it can be killed selectively.

TomMaloney profile image
TomMaloney

No model possible.PSA goes down, until it goes up.

Boywonder56 profile image
Boywonder56 in reply toTomMaloney

"See jr. he thinks of the simple things first".........name that movie..

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Psa

Good morning!!! Well my husband has tried quite a few treatments thus far. He is castrate resistant...
Fight11 profile image

PSA Still Climbing - Scans Almost Stable

Good Morning all you Warriors: I have been battling the Beast for 20 years now. The Lord has...

PSA question

I was diagnosed Stage 4 in February 2019 with PSA of 368. Started Lupron in March and Zytiga in...
Kentucky1 profile image

Question - residual PSA after treatment

Hello - new to the site. Had RP, then salvage RT with 1 yr of ADT ( Lupron ) fall 2017 - IMRT at...
ken12491 profile image

Keytruda failing, feeling desperate, advice needed quickly

Quick update: 58 yr old brother, mmr mutations high tumor burden started Keytruda 8 months ago....
Faith1111 profile image

Moderation team

Bethishere profile image
BethishereAdministrator
Number6 profile image
Number6Administrator
Darryl profile image
DarrylPartner

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.