Is there any difference between genom... - Advanced Prostate...

Advanced Prostate Cancer

22,373 members28,135 posts

Is there any difference between genomic testing from prostate tissue vs. blood sample?

sixmongoos profile image
16 Replies

Hi all,

My dad just had his RALP and I have heard genomic testing is useful for someone with very high-risk PCa. That being said, is there any difference between doing genomic testing now (using the post-operative prostate tissue), vs. doing it through blood sample in the future, when needed?

The urologist doesn't seem to care too much about the testing, so I think dad is being hesitant spending $$$ right now, especially after the cash outflow from the RALP. I'm just afraid that we may miss this window of opportunity, as there will be no prostate tissue to do the genomic testing in the future.

Thanks.

Written by
sixmongoos profile image
sixmongoos
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
16 Replies
Tall_Allen profile image
Tall_Allen

No reason to do genomic testing now. They keep prostate tissue samples for 5 years.

in reply toTall_Allen

Would somatic testing be better for him? Guardant 360 or others.

Tall_Allen profile image
Tall_Allen in reply to

No reason to do it now.

in reply toTall_Allen

No. While both have merit I was wondering if heritable testing or somatic testing would be better when he got to the point of checking genetic makeup.

Tall_Allen profile image
Tall_Allen in reply to

It would depend on why he'd be doing it. Patients are always better off focusing on the present.

sixmongoos profile image
sixmongoos in reply toTall_Allen

Understood. Thanks TA!

tango65 profile image
tango65

The Decipher test is done with prostate tissue. It may help to guide therapy post RP

urotoday.com/conference-hig...

sixmongoos profile image
sixmongoos in reply totango65

I read that the Decipher test is a prostate genomic test. Is there any difference between this vs. the Color genomic test? There seems to be multiple companies doing this and was wondering if they test different things.

tango65 profile image
tango65 in reply tosixmongoos

The color test is a study of the genome of the patient (germline genome). The decipher test studies the genome of the cancer (somatic genome).

The cancers and the patients usually have different genomes. For example the cancer may be BRCA positive and the patient may not have mutations in the BRCA gene.

The cancer is mutating all the time and there are mutations which are associated with rapid progression of the cancer. To decide specific treatments and to make prognosis it is necessary to study the genome of the cancer.

timotur profile image
timotur

He could get a Color genomic test free as part of the Promise trial if he qualifies (confirmed prostate cancer diagnosis via tissue biopsy, prostate specific antigen (PSA) greater than 100 ng/dL and/or radiographic evidence of the disease)... or just order it and pay out of pocket (about $200).

color.com/clinicians-how-or...

urologytimes.com/view/promi...

in reply totimotur

I got the free one. Seemed pretty easy to get.

I just pointed them to the hospital that did my biopsy. My PSA never went over 13. No radiographic evidence of disease (I had RP).

I'm not sure what the follow-up is. I had my Color test done over 8 months ago and there hasn't been a follow-up that I recall.

sixmongoos profile image
sixmongoos in reply to

$200 seems like a good price. Do you know if we can order in Canada as well?

in reply tosixmongoos

It is supposedly available in Canada.

Free if you are accepted for the PROMIS RCT. (I was and I think that they accept anyone with cancer - even my brother with a Gleason 6).

Prostate Cancer Promise – In The Fight Against Prostate Cancer, Your DNA May Be The Most Powerful Tool

prostatecancerpromise.org/?...

sixmongoos profile image
sixmongoos in reply to

Thank you! We'll definitely consider it when we're back in town (out of the country atm).

I notice this test is completed through a saliva sample. Just going back to my original question - is there any difference between genomic tests using prostate tissue sample, blood sample, or saliva? Are the tests designed to serve different purposes?

in reply tosixmongoos

The main distinction is somatic or germline. Always know which one you're getting.

Germline is excellent to have at some time. I got mine days after my RP. I wanted to let my blood relatives know the risks, and I did NOT want to wait. I imagined a situation where I had an inherited genetic mutation and did not tell them as soon as I could, and they later found out they had PCa. I'm the type who would slather myself with blame. Weird because I never blame anyone or myself for my own personal issues.

Somatic can change over time. I am having somatic tests done every 3 or so months to watch for things that might be actionable. This was on advice from my MO (she likes the guardant 360).

This article might help explain it:

Germline and Somatic Mutations: What Is the Difference? | ONS Voice

voice.ons.org/news-and-view...

Let me know what you think of that article. I've looked at many and I thought that this one was one of the clearest ones.

SteveTheJ profile image
SteveTheJ

I had the spit-in-the-test tube testing and it showed nothing. It could have been useful to my brothers had my test shown anything.

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Genomic Prostate tracking ID blood test?

Anybody know of Genomic Prostate blood or tissue testing methods? It’s new or newer type testing of...
depotdoug profile image

Is there a difference between advanced prostate cancer vs aggressive prostate cancer?

65 year old father had bone scan and CT scan early September that ruled out bone spread and organ...
FormulaRob profile image

Is there any benefit to postponing chemo treatments?

Hey all, My Dad is currently on Bicalutamide and gets his first Lupron shot next week. These were...
Here4Dad profile image

Immediate vs Deferred Treatment of BCR after primary and adjuvant therapies. ADT, now or later?

Hi all, A few of us are in the BCR situation so here is a helpful (but hard to read) paper on the...
PGDuan profile image

Thoughts and experiences with Guardant 360 somatic testing

Happy summer, folks. This is a posting inspired by smurtaw's recent post on Guardant 360...
SeosamhM profile image