Should people with heart disease cons... - British Heart Fou...

British Heart Foundation

54,711 membersβ€’34,242 posts

Should people with heart disease consume milk?

fergusthegreat profile image
β€’40 Replies

Milk has a low GI but a very high insulin resistance. In a study done on 8 year old boys, increased milk consumption induced insulin resistance in a couple of weeks.

With insulin resistance, diabetes and metabolic syndrome being a big part of heart disease risk, should people with heart disease be drinking milk.

Thoughts please, but I'd be interested to know if anyone on here who has developed heart disease, especially in their 40's and 50's consumed a lot of dairy?

Written by
fergusthegreat profile image
fergusthegreat
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
40 Replies
β€’
Red18 profile image
Red18

Hi fergusthegreat. I was diagnosed with heart disease at the age of 53. Was it a shock? Oh yes! Have I changed? Oh yes! My diet was dire. When I look back I never consumed a lot of diary. I never ate cheese or butter. Milk only a little in tea and cereal now and again. Same really with yoghurt and eggs . Now when I reflect I ate a whole lot of sugar. Simple carbs. White everything. Cakes, biscuits, pop etc. My heart disease I think was contributed by lots of sugar intake and family history. My opinion is healthy fats are ok but watch the sugar. Have a great day

fergusthegreat profile image
fergusthegreatβ€’ in reply toRed18

Hi Red,

Thanks for the reply. I'm pretty much the same, although I have always done a lot of exercise but my diet was crap.

Have a look at the link below, it shows that milk consumption, although it has a low glycemic index it has the same effect on insulin as the white bread, rice etc that you were eating.

Heythrop51 profile image
Heythrop51

Please can you give the reference for this rather bizarre sounding claim?

Kids in the 50s/60s/70s all had free school milk and probably ate more cheese than the current situation. From my own observations a high percentage that developed heart disease first became overweight/obese, did little exercise and ate to many cooked breakfasts and to much junk food like burgers and fried chicken.

fergusthegreat profile image
fergusthegreatβ€’ in reply toHeythrop51

Hi, yes I have the study downloaded in pdf form but will try to add a link.

Milkfairy profile image
MilkfairyHeart Starβ€’ in reply tofergusthegreat

Another consideration

Breastfeeding is beneficial to the health of both the mother and her baby.

The boys in the study may have been formula fed which is associated with greater weight gain in infants and obesity in childhood

link.springer.com/article/1...

In answer to your question

' should people with heart disease be drinking milk?'

You could be asking why are so few babies in some parts of the world not breastfed?

ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articl...

fergusthegreat profile image
fergusthegreatβ€’ in reply toMilkfairy

Hi, please see my reply to Michael

MichaelJH profile image
MichaelJHHeart Starβ€’ in reply toHeythrop51

Tend to agree...

fergusthegreat profile image
fergusthegreatβ€’ in reply toMichaelJH

Sorry Michael, but I think you and Milk fairy have misunderstood my question.

I'm not talking about human breast milk, I'm talking about cows milk.

Have a look at the link I provided, it shows that 8 year old boys developed insulin resistance when increasing their protein intake from milk.

Milkfairy profile image
MilkfairyHeart Starβ€’ in reply tofergusthegreat

Thanks for the link

It was a very small study only 24 boys. Why only boys?

There are many variables

What is required is a much more detailed study with larger numbers of participants

Today is International Clinical Trials day

It celebrates the first randomised trial by James Lind who found that scurvy could be cured by sailors eating limes.

ukcrc.org/international-cli...

Here in the UK the National Institute of Health Research NIHR is celebrating by asking their Research Champions to get involved and say why research is important

nihr.ac.uk/news/add-your-vo...

MichaelJH profile image
MichaelJHHeart Starβ€’ in reply tofergusthegreat

As Milkfairy has said it is a very small study. Also taking in all the extra protein as milk is questionable as it equates to 1.5 to 2 litres of extra milk per day. I think it might be more relevant as mixed dairy so cheese, yogurt and other products are included.

It was 16 years ago so one wonders why no further research was undertaken?

BTW I had assumed cows' milk.

fergusthegreat profile image
fergusthegreatβ€’ in reply toMichaelJH

Well I don't want to get into conspiracy theories but I know in the USA the dairy industry is a major sponsor of the American Heart Foundation.

I don't think that they would want negative health impacts associated with milk, yoghurt etc.

Anyway my post is purely for my own interest.

After getting a stent I did a lot of research into heart disease and have tried to minimise all the risk factors that I could in the hope that I could save the health services some money and avoid needing more treatment.

I changed a lot in my diet but have probably increased my dairy intake in the belief that it was healthy.

After reading this and several other studies I'm beginning to question my judgment.

Milkfairy profile image
MilkfairyHeart Starβ€’ in reply tofergusthegreat

I agree there is an issue about how the vested interests of some industries could potentially override public health.

The BHF is supported by donations from the public. They take no money from the pharmaceutical industry or the government.

It can therefore hopefully be an independent voice for all heart patients.

The BHF has alot of useful evidence based information about a healthy heart diet

bhf.org.uk/informationsuppo...

fergusthegreat profile image
fergusthegreatβ€’ in reply toMilkfairy

Thanks for the link πŸ‘

fergusthegreat profile image
fergusthegreatβ€’ in reply toHeythrop51

Hi Heythrop 51,

Here is the link. The article appeared in nature. com and shows that when children increased their protein intake, after one week the ones on a milk diet developed insulin resistance.

The ones on a meat diet didn't.

google.com/url?sa=t&source=...

MichaelJH profile image
MichaelJHHeart Star

The lower fat options of dairy are a good source of both protein and calcium.

fergusthegreat profile image
fergusthegreatβ€’ in reply toMichaelJH

Yes true but it still causes a large spike in insulin possibly leading to insulin resistance much like the much maligned white bread, rice, chips etc.

Heythrop51 profile image
Heythrop51β€’ in reply tofergusthegreat

Are you saying cheese which is virtually carb free causes an insulin spike? It doesn't make sense to me.

fergusthegreat profile image
fergusthegreatβ€’ in reply toHeythrop51

Hi Heythrop, my interest stems from trying to eat as heart healthily as I can to try and avoid a trip back to the cath lab.

Trouble is there is a lot of mixed messages surrounding some so called healthy foods.

I have a copy of a study which fed university students a variety of single foods and meals to measure the glycemic and insulin responses.

I don't want to be reported for giving medical advice but if you are concerned about insulin spikes and the subsequent inflammation and damage to the arteries it would seem better to consume full fat dairy.

Whole milk and cheddar cheese caused almost half the insulin spike that skimmed milk did.

Saturated fat content on the other hand is a different view point.

Jack2019 profile image
Jack2019β€’ in reply toMichaelJH

and milk sugar, the lower the fat content the higher the milk sugar lactose. Generations of Europeans were/are raised on real cheese ,yogurts, dairy consumption on a daily basis. Use real cheese and real cream. Read labels, many dairy products contain added sugar.

Red18 profile image
Red18

Very interesting indeed...

Red18 profile image
Red18

Fergusthegreat have a look at all SOS007 posts. He is a very informative guy. He has truly helped me try and walk through this thick treacle of heart do's and don'ts. All I know is I do not eat at all the way I do now and hoping and praying it will pay dividends and stop my heart disease from getting worse. Take care and keep well

Heythrop51 profile image
Heythrop51β€’ in reply toRed18

Think you have the name wrong. The Member search says he doesn't exist!

MichaelJH profile image
MichaelJHHeart Starβ€’ in reply toHeythrop51

I remember him but as you say he is no longer listed.

fergusthegreat profile image
fergusthegreat

Thanks for the info. I don't suppose you know what the insulin index is for Natural Greek yogurt do you as I can't find it.

Thanks 😁

RoyM profile image
RoyM

The old saying....everything in moderation, a balanced diet and exercise. Not really rocket science is it.

fergusthegreat profile image
fergusthegreatβ€’ in reply toRoyM

Unfortunately Roy if you forget about the rockets and look at the food science it is not so simple.

For instance eggs and milk are marketed as healthy but eggs have been shown to increase the risk of metastatic prostate cancer and in women who have had breast cancer, high milk consumption is linked to a high risk of the cancer returning.

Milkfairy profile image
MilkfairyHeart Starβ€’ in reply tofergusthegreat

That's very interesting

Have you got the research articles about eggs and milk having this effect?

Some people once a risk is quantified are comfortable with the extra small risk especially when it means a better quality of life.

Hence the phrase 'all things in moderation ' is a useful rule of thumb for many people.

MichaelJH profile image
MichaelJHHeart Starβ€’ in reply tofergusthegreat

My view is follow a Mediterranean diet with nothing in excess. Living carries risks and nobody gets out alive...

RoyM profile image
RoyMβ€’ in reply tofergusthegreat

How on earth did I manage to get to my ripe old age without all this scientific knowledge. Pass the egg sandwich dear. lol

Keep safe Roy

Red18 profile image
Red18

sos007

Red18 profile image
Red18

Look under chlosterol posts. He's excellent! Have a great day

Helen_BHF profile image
Helen_BHF

Hi all,

We have some Heart Matters articles on the subject which might be of interest

bhf.org.uk/informationsuppo...

bhf.org.uk/informationsuppo...

bhf.org.uk/informationsuppo...

Hope this helps!

fergusthegreat profile image
fergusthegreatβ€’ in reply toHelen_BHF

Hi Helen, thanks for the info

fergusthegreat profile image
fergusthegreatβ€’ in reply toHelen_BHF

Hi Helen,

Since developing heart disease I have tried to reduce my modifiable risk factors as much as possible and eat a very healthy diet.

It is my belief that inflammation is the main cause of ischmaetic heart disease and that insulin resistance is one of the causes of this. Hence, I try restrict foods that cause large insulin spikes.

Despite the point of this post being to illustrate the fact that reduced fat dairy products cause a far higher insulin spike than full fat versions and I think based on the evidence should be avoided in favour of the full fat versions you have posted a link to a bhf information leaflet supporting the consumption of low fat dairy.

I have to confess to being very frustrated with the conflicting information when all I and a lot of people are trying to do is eat healthily.

Jack2019 profile image
Jack2019

My whole family, and there are a lot of us, were and still do consume a lot of cheese and yogurt. I am the only one that developed a blocked artery and that happened to me at the age of 59. I received two stents and was told the rest of the coronary tree has mild disease, as one would expect for someone my age.

fergusthegreat profile image
fergusthegreat

Thanks very much πŸ‘

fergusthegreat profile image
fergusthegreat

True, but it is difficult to know what to believe with so many conflicting views.

I just skim read the PhD thesis in the link above.

Purely from an insulin index point of view, a snickers bar is healthier than a banana 😭😭

Bugger it, I'm off to the pub for a pint and a pizza, stay safe πŸ‘

Bergson profile image
Bergsonβ€’ in reply tofergusthegreat

If you are interested in the pathogenesis of CVD check out Vladimir Subbotin's paper published in 2016, it is a bit lengthy but he also posted a shorter summary in video form on youtube last year which is very informative and also highlights a strange anomaly of the structure of coronary arteries beimng falsely portrayed on some reputable websites. Also diets are confusing, apart from the only reliable one which is the Predimed trial - Mediterranean diet, Tim Spector's excellent book 'The Diet Myth' gives you the science behind or not behind all diets backed up by his own research with the twins project at Kings College London which he has been involved with for many years.

Misstibbs profile image
Misstibbs

I now take the simple view a little of what you fancy will do you no harm! Rely on the statins, and remember you won’t change your hereditary. Best Wishes πŸ‘

seasider18 profile image
seasider18

Strange I had just posted this before seeing your contribution

medicalnewstoday.com/articl...

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Congenital Heart Disease

Hello This is mainly aimed at Females who have congenital heart disease. I have recently had my...
AH31 profile image
β€’

Veins and heart disease

Is there any link between enlarged veins ( almost varicose but not ) and heart disease. The veins...
Caitlyn6 profile image
β€’

Dr. FORD Brewer

So, the above mentioned doctor is an American cardiologist who has now for many years specialised...
fergusthegreat profile image
β€’

Flying with heat disease

My mum was diagnosed with heart disease 3 weeks ago and has been on all the relevant medication my...
Kimberley0611 profile image
β€’

Viral infection and heart disease

Hi all - I have had a recent diagnosis of heart disease (from genetic FH), and have an appointment...
β€’

Moderation team

See all
HUModerator profile image
HUModeratorAdministrator
Luke_BHF profile image
Luke_BHFPartner
Amy-BHF profile image
Amy-BHFPartner

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.