piko vs mini wright peak flow readers - Asthma Community ...

Asthma Community Forum

21,722 members24,486 posts

piko vs mini wright peak flow readers

3 Replies

Hi all

I have both a piko and manual peak flow meter (EU scale). I have not used the piko recently as batteries were low and I was getting different readings from both meters. Bought new batteries yesterday but am still getting different readings - 146 v 210 !! Don't know which is correct so don't know what action to take.

Any advice greatly received.

Nikki

Read more about...
3 Replies

I have used both and tend to get diff readings like you. tend to work on basis that piko 1 is more accurate but don't know really.

The first Piko-1 I had gave very different readings to the Wright monitors I'd used and, having done a comparison, I got in touch with the manufacturer. They said they hadn't heard of many people noticing discrepancies in readings, but were interested to hear of my experience and said I should return the monitor to the pharmacy and ask for a replacement, which I did. The replacement was much more 'in line' with the readings from the Wright and I've been happily using this replacement for 9 or so months now. It might be worthwhile your contacting Ferraris (details at ferrarisrespiratory.com/usa... to see what they suggest.

i also have a piko 1 meter and mine also gives very different readings to my peak flow. the piko can be at least twice the result of my peak flow sometimes so ive given up on the piko and trust the peak flow more as well i just find it more belivable than the piko lol! ive hardly ever got the results the piko says i have, i let a couple of my friends have a go (i know i shouldnt do this!) and then made them do a peak flow and there readings where also very different. now im thinking from reading the reply below it maybe faulty!

You may also like...

Confused re peak flow

What is a normal peak flow reading?Used it first time and max.170 is this good or bad?Looked up...

peak flow

just interested to know what other asthmatics out there normal average peak flow is , mine used to...

peak flow best of 3 today ws 400

fed up just now as back in bed! Peak Flow is your best peak flow the best of three times blowing...

Peak flow higher in the evening

ventolin after doing the peak flow then re check 20 mins later and the reading go up by 10-20....

Variable peak flow daily

could be 380. Does anyone know why my peak flow is so variable, keeping peak flow diary, as per...