Apple Watch v wearing heart holster 2... - Atrial Fibrillati...

Atrial Fibrillation Support

32,311 members38,582 posts

Apple Watch v wearing heart holster 24 hours

Jackiesmith7777 profile image

just curious if anyone’s Apple Watch heart rate has been different to the monitor. On my husband Apple Watch his heart rate went from 42 up to 130 in the same 24 hour period When I phoned the heart function nurse for results on his 24 hour monitor he wore she read out thst his lowest was 70 and highest 117 . Just curious if anyone had experienced the same difference . Thanks

Jackie

Written by
Jackiesmith7777 profile image
Jackiesmith7777
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
12 Replies
Buzby62 profile image
Buzby62

Hi, assuming he is in AF for all those readings it could be down to the inaccuracy of the Green Light technology using the optical sensor on the watch. I think you said previously you also seen a difference between the optical and the electrical readings using the finger on the wheel. The Holter will be electrical measurements and be accurate. You can’t take a continuous electrical reading with the watch so I guess the watch is just an indicator rather than an accurate monitor in his case.

I find the optical measurements from the watch can be inaccurate when I’m in AF.

Also, I’ve read that some people can’t get an accurate radial pulse at their wrist and have to take their pulse from their neck.

Hope this helps

Jackiesmith7777 profile image
Jackiesmith7777 in reply toBuzby62

Thank you yes , I’m so glad I found this site it has been a real help and support for my husband and myself , as he can’t read at this time because of his stroke I read some of them out to him . X

mjames1 profile image
mjames1

Really not a significant difference between "130" and "117" when you're in afib, as the heart rate bounces around anyway. I find the Watch to be pretty accurate, but you have to understand the limitations when it comes to 24 hour monitoring, because unlike a Holter, Apple Watch does not monitor 24/7, just periodically.

Jim

Jackiesmith7777 profile image
Jackiesmith7777 in reply tomjames1

Yes true .

Rainfern profile image
Rainfern

I think my iwatch is consistent even if it doesn’t measure quite the same as more sophisticated medical equipment. So for me I know I’m in trouble if resting HR is above a certain number and I know if I could walk a bit faster on a walk without straining and it’s like having a close friend who may not be a fully qualified medic, but they know me!

Buzby62 profile image
Buzby62 in reply toRainfern

Totally agree, I use mine the same as an indicator but it’s good to be aware of the limitations around the accuracy of the numbers while in AF. When my HR appears higher than expected I hold my finger on the wheel to switch over from the optical sensor to the electrical sensors for more accuracy. If you are in AF you will see the HR jumping about every second instead of every 5 seconds or so on the optical sensor.

A couple of links to Apple support

support.apple.com/en-us/HT2...

support.apple.com/en-gb/HT2...

Hope this is helpful to all.

Jackiesmith7777 profile image
Jackiesmith7777 in reply toBuzby62

Thank you yes he s in permanent AF

Buzby62 profile image
Buzby62 in reply toJackiesmith7777

I think in that case as you’ve proven the optical sensor on the wrist to be inaccurate for his AF heart rate then you have to assume that the HR readings without using the finger on the wheel are permanently unreliable for him. As on the apple support page, some cannot get accurate readings and have to think about another device, I’m not sure that would be helpful in his case but it’s an option. Hoping he improves and soon, best wishes.

Jackiesmith7777 profile image
Jackiesmith7777 in reply toRainfern

Yes . My confusion is thst my husbands heart rate today was averaging 60s 80s but the ecg seems to be a lot higher . If we didn’t have the ecg component on his watch I would be thinking ooh great, heart rate is ok.

dmac4646 profile image
dmac4646

you cant rely on the Apple Watch for accurate pulse readings

Tuut19 profile image
Tuut19

I have PAF for a long time and wear day and night an Apple Iwatch (8 and recently the new 9) on my left wrist AND a FitBit Charge 5 on my right wrist. In my experience both wearables measure my heartrate, heart rate variability and the hear beat irregularities alarms comparable and reliable. I also use the heart and health apps on my Iphone 12, which shows me averages and trends daily, weekly, monthly and annually.

Jackiesmith7777 profile image
Jackiesmith7777 in reply toTuut19

Thank you , yes my husband has the Apple Watch 8 series and wears it day and night

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Apple Watch SE ECG App

Apple Watch ECG apps? I have just bought an Apple Watch for the purpose of monitoring my heart and...
Japaholic profile image

Apple Watch

Curious to hear from anyone using an Apple Watch ECG app to monitor afib. On mine I can get a...
Xian1 profile image

Heart Rate Monitor Watch

Hi all I recently purchased an Apple Watch for the heart rate monitor as I previously had a Garmin...

ecg on Apple Watch different to the red heart section

Hi myself and my husband are a bit confused as his Apple Watch on the ecg says average 110/120...

KardiaMobile and Apple Watch

I recently wore a heart monitor for two weeks. While on the monitor both my CardioMobile and my...
Debjimmay profile image

Moderation team

See all
Emily-Admin profile image
Emily-AdminAdministrator
Kelley-Admin profile image
Kelley-AdminAdministrator
jess-admin profile image
jess-adminAdministrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.