Exercise makes my AF worse: Everything... - Atrial Fibrillati...

Atrial Fibrillation Support

31,322 members36,990 posts

Exercise makes my AF worse

Barny12 profile image
44 Replies

Everything we read about AF and exercise seems to say reasonably moderate or gentle exercise is a good thing and strengthens the heart. So I can't really understand why even a gentle stroll is leaving me feeling as though it's straining my heart.

Five years ago just prior to being diagnosed, I was fell running. Last year I couldn't run but I could cycle 20 miles no problem. Today I dread taking the stairs.

I really don't think this is a natural afib progression - my heart just seems to hate movement. Hormones/adrenaline/cortisol maybe or a structural issue, perhaps?

Written by
Barny12 profile image
Barny12
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
44 Replies
BobD profile image
BobDVolunteer

Dpeds a lot on medication which you haven't mentioned.

Barny12 profile image
Barny12 in reply to BobD

Just been on Bisoprolol 1.25mg for the last year. It's never made me feel tired as it does with some people - it's not that exercise is more tiring for me, it's that it often seems to put a strain on my heart, which in turn kicks off my afib.

kitenski profile image
kitenski in reply to Barny12

just bisoprolol? That doesn't sound usual to me, are you going into AFib or something else when you get an episode? Have your consultant/Dr diagnosed Afib? Did they discuss any other drugs as options, PIPs etc?

Barny12 profile image
Barny12 in reply to kitenski

Yep, diagnosed afib 2018. Flecainide as PIP. I'm not going into afib during exercise, but seem to get a lot of ectopics whilst moving/walking. It's the exercise that is causing the straining heart. Currently getting afib every night at bed time (relieved by PIP) after doing a gentle bike ride a couple of months ago where I got a heart twinge/straining feeling.

Singwell profile image
Singwell in reply to Barny12

You need to get checked out. This doesn't sound right. Possibly something else is going on with your heart, or arteries. After 2 months I wouldn't be leaving this. Ask to be put on for a stress test at least.

Aegean56 profile image
Aegean56 in reply to Singwell

Yes perhaps a stress test to examine what is actually happening when you are exercising. Also a home monitoring device would shed some light as well. Hope all goes well.

mary70 profile image
mary70 in reply to Barny12

Basically, Bisoprolol does not suit you very well - the affects are negative for your lifestyle! Much more advisable is to arrange an appointment with a) your doctors to explain that you are enduring over-tiredness unreasonable so, and b) then go back to see your cardiologist and ask what steps to improve your health range more effectively.

jeanjeannie50 profile image
jeanjeannie50

Have you had an echocardiogram to check if your heart is functioning ok? I think you need to speak to your GP and say how you're feeling.

Jean

Barny12 profile image
Barny12 in reply to jeanjeannie50

Yep, had an echo 4 years ago. Discussed exercise several times with EP who just says keep exercising as it's good for the heart!

jeanjeannie50 profile image
jeanjeannie50 in reply to Barny12

Something is not right though isn't it. You can't exercise if you're feeling as you are and putting a strain on your heart can't be good. Have you had a blood test to check your thyroid function? I was feeling worn out like you a few years ago and mine was found to be underactive. Pills to rectify that gave me my life back, I thought it was all part of AF.

Barny12 profile image
Barny12 in reply to jeanjeannie50

I agree - something doesn't seem right. Had thyroid bloods done in May and all within guidelines.

Currently waiting for a 48hr Holter on the 17th, but not holding my breath that it's going to reveal much.

jeanjeannie50 profile image
jeanjeannie50 in reply to Barny12

It should do if there's something wrong. I think you may need a cardio-angiogram, look it up online. I had one right before my first ablation.

CDreamer profile image
CDreamer in reply to Barny12

I would be pushing for echocardiogram, a lot could have changed in 4 years. When were your last FBC? Full blood test? I agree with Jean - full work up is required.

Nightmare2 profile image
Nightmare2 in reply to Barny12

48 hour monitor for AF is next to useless, i had a 14 day one, and it was only on the very last day that it proved useful and recorded an event i had.

Sally_Scott profile image
Sally_Scott in reply to Barny12

I had OHS in January and now I’m doing 8 weeks of cardiac rehabilitation. Jeez I’ve never worked so hard in my life. So they do want you to do exercise. Think you need to go back to your cardiologist because something doesn’t right.

Moongold7 profile image
Moongold7 in reply to Barny12

I'd trust what your body is indicating to you and see your specialist or trusted doctor.

pusillanimous profile image
pusillanimous in reply to Barny12

Shouldn't you have an echocardiogram with doppler annually, that's what I was told to have !

2learn profile image
2learn in reply to Barny12

From what you say the problem is more recent, so perhaps as people are saying you need some more tests. An echo 4 years ago may need updating. I was told when first diagnosed with AFib that exercise, particularly strenuous exercise would not help and could make things worse.

KootenayTrails profile image
KootenayTrails

Can’t tell from your post if you’ve been checked for blockages ie have had an angiogram to rule out chest pain from blockages? Or one or more ablations? As Avery active person myself, when my AF progressed to daily, I was completely unable to exercise or even do mild walks. As you describe, I would get a chest pressure, kind of breathless, and either get ectopics or go into AF right away or later that day. An ablation May 31st has taken all of the above completely away. Hope your EP can reassess you soon!

Bramley01 profile image
Bramley01

I think you could do with an echo and checking your heart function, try and speak to your GP

Spiritji profile image
Spiritji

Try Swimming

Jetcat profile image
Jetcat in reply to Spiritji

I’d say swimming is even more strenuous.?

TracyAdmin profile image
TracyAdminPartner

I am sorry to hear you are experiencing difficulty, it is hard to tell if the source of this is related to the AF or prescribed medications. If you are unable to go about your usual daily activities or experience shortness of breath, please speak to your doctor for further advice.

secondtry profile image
secondtry

I think you have had lots of sound advice above.

I think a private cardiologist appointment, possible Flecainide daily (either 100 or 200mgs).

I have concluded (in my case anyway) the heart improves by constant moderation in all things - exercise, daily pills rather than PIP and level stress/emotions (eg no late night crime dramas 😱)

Keep a diary to discuss events with the cardio.

All that said, in my early days of AF diagnosis, I could hardly walk any distance and any incline seemed to threaten to trigger AF. After a period of stability including supplements and many improved lifestyle choices, I have a pretty normal active life but without the excesses.

Mugsy15 profile image
Mugsy15

Some sound advice here, and I agree with those who suggest pushing for further investigations. I'm not on Bisoprolol and never have been, but I've read this forum enough to know that it can cause various symptoms of tiredness, lethargy and cardiac disruption in some people. I know you say you don't feel tired as such, but the symptoms you describe may, at least in part, be your own individual reaction to that drug. We all react in different ways.

Certainly worth taking into account during your discussions with your GP, Cardio nurse or consultant.

GrannyE profile image
GrannyE

You sound just like I was. Are you anaemic? Ask to be checked for that.

ChadL profile image
ChadL in reply to GrannyE

goodness yes, my iron was very very low a few months ago and it triggered some crazy symptoms(tired feeling in my chest, headaches, shortness of breath) and heart palpitations.. I would take a few steps and HR would increase drastically. Started taking supplements and now slowly building back up my walking..back up to a mile without any crazy heart rate readings!

Barny12 profile image
Barny12

Sheesh, had a bad night. AF kicked off around 1am as usual so had the Flec PIP, fell asleep and woke up with tachycardia and cold sweats at 5am. Calmed down after about 30 mins but quite scary.

Just left a message with the arrhythmia nurse to call me back. I'll keep you posted.

Thanks all.

Nightmare2 profile image
Nightmare2 in reply to Barny12

The beta blocker you take should have the opposite effect i.e. more slow heart rate and not fast with cold sweats. Ask too why you are not on anti coagulants if indeed you have AF.

Buffafly profile image
Buffafly in reply to Barny12

Cold sweats bad! You definitely need a prompt investigation.

Nightmare2 profile image
Nightmare2

With afib diagnosis, we are usually put onto Apixaban or other anti coagulants as well as beta blockers (bisoprolol or the like), are you sure you have afib as none of this sounds the norm to me.

Scotheart profile image
Scotheart

It affects us in different ways. Before diagnosis I was a keen hiker and an still able to walk ten-plus miles at a reasonably-brisk pace albeit only on the flat with only short, modest inclines do-able. I'm on a fairly high dose of Bisoprolol plus Forxiga and Apixaban.

RoyMacDonald profile image
RoyMacDonald

Exercise is vital, if you want to live a healthy life. I never stop unless I'm very stressed. I have SVT and my heart rate can hit 190 bpm during exercise but as soon as I stop it drops back to about 70 bpm with a Blood Pressure of 102/67.

Have you tried supplements that the body likes? I take Q10, Taurine, Creatine, D3, K2, Kelp. Also B12 as I'm Vegan. Don't forget to eat onions every day as the latest research from Japan said that made a huge difference to health. The only medication I take is Apixaban.

All the best.

Roy

JOY2THEWORLD49 profile image
JOY2THEWORLD49 in reply to RoyMacDonald

Hi

We had an Irish friend who lived in his van and ate raw onions!!!!!!

Its normal to hit high levels but what H/Specialist want to see is dropping down to normal fairly quickly after.

AFs don't.

Meds like Metoprolol left me breathless and fatigued with no energy. 186 avge Day H/R. Uncontrolled of my rapid persistent AF.

Bisoprolol again left me uncontrolled at 156avge Day H/R.

A private H/Specialist rescued me. Tried CCB in 2 hours H/R dropped 105H/R Day.

Too high dosage of 180mg Diltiazem so within days reduced.

I take 120mg AM Diltiazem for H/R (lasts 12 hours

I take 2.5mg PM Bisoprolol for BP

120-124/69. was 88-96 until last November when I dropped to 60s. Not sure

whether it was because of drop of 5kg???

So you do need to keep an eye on H/R 4 x monthly and BP.

We AFs need to be very careful of supplements so tests first to show low on this and that otherwise there are bad risks. All my levels are great.

My energy returned when my BP and H/R controlled. Not as a young chicken but in moderation.

chers JOY. 74. (NZ)

RoyMacDonald profile image
RoyMacDonald in reply to JOY2THEWORLD49

Hi Joy My AF goes back to normal by the time I've taken off my cycling kit and had a shower. Guess we are all a bit different. I take my BP and HR every day for my app. I'm something of an obsessive by nature. My stroke only made me more so.

I don't remember the Japanese report saying the onions had to be raw though. I do remember it saying that all types of onions counted, so garlic, spring, etc.

All the best

Roy

JOY2THEWORLD49 profile image
JOY2THEWORLD49 in reply to RoyMacDonald

Hi

But if your high HR and AF return to normal within that time you are normal and would pass the stress test.

Heck if my HR returned normally I wouldn't be monitoring it.

But as you have some AF irregularity I would file it in my brain, moderate my exercise and enjoy life.

I did have a stress test back in 2008 when I had hypertension, and I returned to normal. Now they won't do another as they think it is irrelevant.

cheers JOY. 74. (NZ)

RoyMacDonald profile image
RoyMacDonald in reply to JOY2THEWORLD49

I like the exercise though. It is my life. The only other things I like are talking about bikes, computer games, reading, and films. And the only reason for those is that I need some recovery time to avoid stressing my legs too much as that can lead to injury of muscles and tendons. I'm an avid member of the British Human Power Club. and on their forum and Strava a lot. I do my own stress testing.🤣

Takes all types I guess.

All the best.

Roy

GranmaWendy profile image
GranmaWendy

sounds to me like you need a long chat with your cardiologist, I think we all get days like that, but it shouldnt be all the time

Barny12 profile image
Barny12

Went down to A & E this morning as very shaky after last night's shenanigans - had full blood count, ecg and x-ray. Doc also checked for HF. All came back clear, although the x-ray showed heart slightly larger than previous x-ray 2 years earlier. He didn't seem concerned. Said there didn't seem to be any sign of angina.

Doc didn't want to tweak my meds - he said my consultant could do that after I've had the 48hr Holter I'm due for next week and an echocardiogram he's booking me in for. Fingers crossed we may know more then.

Thanks for all the replies everyone 👍

whats profile image
whats

Intense exercise also sets off my afib. Activites I've identified as triggers also make me worry, sometimes without being fully aware of it, as you mentioned, so it can be a self fulfilling trigger. Deep relaxation including generating some happy feelings is good prevention or even brings me out of afib sometimes. I'd suggest a slow resumption of exercise with deep relaxation and enjoyment mixed in during and/or after. Anyway, it helps me.

JOY2THEWORLD49 profile image
JOY2THEWORLD49

Hi

What meds are you taking?

What is your now BP.

What is your H/R.

Best by 24-hr monitor

cheers JOY. 74. (NZ)

Sailndive profile image
Sailndive

Could it be aggravated by adrenaline? Speak with your cardiologist, maybe beta blocker like Metoprolol might be something to consider.

JOY2THEWORLD49 profile image
JOY2THEWORLD49 in reply to Sailndive

Hi

Oh no... Bisoprolol is stated as the more appropriate beta blocker today. It is less likely to interfere with breathing and 02. Joy

PleasantPink2 profile image
PleasantPink2

Yes, I can relate to part of your pattern. I too find even casual walking over 20 mins can trigger an increase in ectopics for me. When I start to see an increase in the frequency I either skip my walks the next few days or reduce the time to 10-15 mins. I have discussed this with my med cardio a few times, she seems to think it's a hydration issue. She always advises hydrating before the walks. I am well hydrated , easily 60-70 oz water a day, so I don't agree with her.

I think you may be onto something about the adrenaline as a factor. When I was weaned off Bisoprolol at my request due to the side effects I had a terrible period of hypertension which was totally out of character for me. I learned on this site that coming off the beta blocker too quickly was most likely the cause. It took almost two months for my BP to return to my norm. The beta blockers do exactly that, block your adrenaline. So I suppose stopping suddenly was like a rubber band effect. Anyway, I digress. All that to say I agree with you, anything that seems to raise my adrenaline does trigger my ectopics.

Hoping you get to the root of your issues soon. You are taking all the right steps, it's just sometimes takes awhile to put the whole puzzle together.

You may also like...

Exercise makes my AF worse (part 2)

how I felt worse after exercise - felt like the slightest stroll strained my heart. Well it got...

Can ablation make AF worse in the long run?

should probably cancel the ablation because it seems the meds are working. My questions are: Has...

Can an Ablation make my Paroxysmal AFib worse

procedure nurse interview. I have paroxysmal AFib -usually twice a year -lasting about 8-9 hours...

Is my AF getting worse if my RVR is lasting longer?

My rapid beats seem to be lasting longer these days. I'm just wondering what people's experience is.

Will my AF get worse if I don’t take medication.

I had a pacemaker fitted because I kept having heart pauses in my sleep. I’ve been told I have AF...