Low carb Halva / Erythritol? - Low-Carb High-Fat...

Low-Carb High-Fat (LCHF)

2,837 membersβ€’1,341 posts

Low carb Halva / Erythritol?

Professor-Yaffle profile image
β€’33 Replies

Morning all

I've been eating LCHF for a few years. Although I don't get sugar cravings I do really love Halva and would like to be able to eat it more often, rather than just for a special treat. For those who aren't familiar, it's a middle eastern sesame snack made predominantly from pulped sesame seeds. So would be LCHF naturally, except it always contains sugar or honey as the second ingredient, I think this adds to to texture and setting process as well as the taste... I'm not to bothered about Halva being really sweet, I prefer Halva taste-wise when it has lower levels of sugar but I think a little sweetness is necessary and I don't think the halva would be the right texture without the sugar/honey.

Can anyone recommend a good low carb/sugar halva that's not full of crap?

I'm a keen cook. I have looked at some recipes for Keto Halva but they all contain Erythritol - I'm sceptical as I think this is a sugar substitute/sweetner and I tend to always cook from real, whole ingredients. I'm not well informed at all about synthetic/processed "substitute" foods. I'm sure there is someone on this forum who has done all the research about Erythritol and the like? Any advise would be appreciated. Or can anyone think of a different ingredient I can replace the sugar with?

Thank-you

Written by
Professor-Yaffle profile image
Professor-Yaffle
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
33 Replies
β€’
TheAwfulToad profile image
TheAwfulToadAmbassador

Honestly, if you've been doing this for a few years, the occasional dose of sugar probably isn't going to do you any harm as long as it doesn't turn into a slippery slope. Bu if you're at risk of going back to a mindset where every meal has to have a dessert, it's possible you're not eating proper meals that aren't filling you up, or not getting adequate dietary fat.

If it's more the sesame flavour you like, how about just making some hummus and keeping that in the fridge to snack on? It's not exactly low-carb, but it's probably a better choice than sweetened sesame paste.

No idea about Erythritol, I'm afraid. Hopefully someone else can chime in!

Professor-Yaffle profile image
Professor-Yaffleβ€’ in reply toTheAwfulToad

Thanks for your response AwfulToad.

I don't think I'm ever at risk of thinking I could get away with eating dessert after every meal, I'd be the size of a house πŸ˜‚. I do have occasional sugary treats - mostly halva or very high dark chocolate (i'm a bit of a food snob I'm afraid) but overall I'd much rather eat salty than sweet food and I feel quite satisfied without sugar or anything high carb.

I do like hummus but it won't quite compare to halva - there's something magic about the texture of halva that I really like, sort of a crystallised flakiness. Yes, it's also intense sesame flavour, nothing quite like it for me..... I have been using sesame oil quite a bit for vegetables but it just doesn't cut the mustard.

Halva is so close to being quite a useful dietary staple (in small amounts- I can't eat loads as it's really filling and a little cloying, like eating tahini from the jar) but I can't quite get there without finding a solution for the sugar/crystallisation problem....

Thank you 🐸

Fruitcake100 profile image
Fruitcake100β€’ in reply toProfessor-Yaffle

What about Stevia , would that work.

Professor-Yaffle profile image
Professor-Yaffleβ€’ in reply toFruitcake100

HI Fruitcake

I have been looking into Stevia recently. There are so many types available.... Do you have a particular Stevia you use?

I updated this thread recently (see below). In an amazing turn of events an actual Halva shop opened near my house. One pre-made halva I found in the shop claimed to be Stevia sweetened but then it actually turner out to be mostly Maltitol when I was able to obtain the actual ingredients 😭

Subtle_badger profile image
Subtle_badgerβ€’ in reply toProfessor-Yaffle

If you aren't aware, stevia is extremely sweet. If it's pure, you will just add drops. So, it will add no texture at all. Truvia (stevia and erythritol) is probably a good choice.

I just made a ganache with erythritol. Not bad, but a little crunchy - which is what you want, I think.

Professor-Yaffle profile image
Professor-Yaffleβ€’ in reply toSubtle_badger

And Stevia is usually liquid in its "natural" state? Does it cause bowl troubles?

Yeah, I do think the erythritol is probably the ideal Halva sweetener. I guess the reason my new local halva shop don't use it is to with the cost.

Subtle_badger profile image
Subtle_badgerβ€’ in reply toProfessor-Yaffle

A teaspoon of stevia equivalent to a cup of sugar, so a single serving is literally a couple of drops. If that little caused gastric distress, I think that would make it a poison. ☠

(which would be quite amusing for fans of Breaking Bad)

If you get stevia in granulated form, it will list a bulking agent which will account for nearly the entire contents.

Professor-Yaffle profile image
Professor-Yaffleβ€’ in reply toSubtle_badger

So in my new local halva shop I guess they used a little Stevia so they could say it was Stevia sweetened (which is what they proclaimed in the shop and I presume related to the Steviol glycosides) and then a lot of Maltitol for texture. A bit cheeky to call it Stevia sweetened and not have the actual ingredients readily available. It also has palm oil. I had to email to get this;

one of the sugar free Halva at my local shop
Subtle_badger profile image
Subtle_badgerβ€’ in reply toProfessor-Yaffle

I wouldn't say cheeky, exactly. Products labelled stevia have always had bulking agents, eg singleportions.co.uk/stevia...

Honestly, it's likely the company didn't even think about it, they just purchases something called stevia.

And this is why I won't use stevia. Worried it might get tampered with by a drug lord.

youtu.be/NP7Nszp4Iwg?t=55

Professor-Yaffle profile image
Professor-Yaffleβ€’ in reply toSubtle_badger

πŸ˜‚

Professor-Yaffle profile image
Professor-Yaffleβ€’ in reply toProfessor-Yaffle

I'd forgotten all about this....

Professor-Yaffle profile image
Professor-Yaffle

I think it's a good option to make your own, I don't see it much in the shops in the UK, just in health food shops or Mediterranean or middle eastern speciality shops.

I have some fond childhood memories of eating halva. I also associate it with holidays because I tend to treat myself to Halva in Greece or Turkey.

If you get round to making it Happyman please let me know how it goes and what receipe you follow.

sunny369 profile image
sunny369

I must admit if I was settled on a lchf lifestyle and not at risk of a sugar binge which from what you've said your aren't (I am a reformed sugar addict and when I slip I can slip up badly :) ) I would just enjoy my Halva as a rare treat.I don't know anything about Erythritol because I am wary of cooking things that taste sweet because a sweet taste can be a slippery slope for me, but why not just experiment with it?

I agree ,I tend to believe in eating the least ultra-processed version of things, if it has to be created in a factory is it really safe and good for us? This is the ideal though, I don't always live up to it :) Presumably you aren't going to eat buckets loads of it anyway so maybe it wouldn't really present a huge safety/health issue.

Or maybe you could experiment to see how much you could get away with reducing the honey/sugar content and let us know :)

Plus, if it doesn't set you will have a sauce :)

Professor-Yaffle profile image
Professor-Yaffleβ€’ in reply tosunny369

"Or maybe you could experiment to see how much you could get away with reducing the honey/sugar content and let us know "

I think this is a good idea, Thank-you Sunny.

Professor-Yaffle profile image
Professor-Yaffleβ€’ in reply toProfessor-Yaffle

Also, I think you and AwfulToad are right that it's ok to just eat regular Halva on an irregular basis ..... but my dream is a world where I can eat Halva more often πŸ’­ as the main ingredient is very nutritious and really agrees with me.

Best wishes with your continued efforts to change your diet sounds like your making good progress already. Thanks for your thoughts on my Halva conundrum.

sunny369 profile image
sunny369β€’ in reply toProfessor-Yaffle

how many carbs are in a modest portion of Halva?

Professor-Yaffle profile image
Professor-Yaffleβ€’ in reply tosunny369

I think some of them are very sugary and some less so.... My current Halva which is a 500g tin (in the picture) I have had since Christmas, is a very sugary one! 47g carb 38g of which is sugars per 100g. You can buy lower sugar pre-made ones though. The one was a gift from someone who knows I'm a tin enthusiaste. 😊

If I make some I think I can get away with a much lower sugar content.

sunny369 profile image
sunny369β€’ in reply toProfessor-Yaffle

It is super sugary :) but you have had it since Christmas, so if you can eat a 100 g portion over three months 47g of carbs seems fair to me :) :) :) The tin is adorable by the way :)

Let us know how the home made lower sugar attempts turn out.....

Professor-Yaffle profile image
Professor-Yaffleβ€’ in reply tosunny369

Yep, It's a classic Greek one. In Greece they always seem quite liberal with sugar to me. I'm going to plant something in the tin when I've got through the Halva. 🌱

Subtle_badger profile image
Subtle_badger

Erythritol is a sugar alcohol/polyol. It's regarded as a natural sweetener as it occurs in nature in small amounts and it's produced by growing it using bacteria, rather than chemical reactions in a laboratory. It's regarded as the best if the sugar alcohols, producing no insulin or blood glucose rise. It's also the least likely to cause gastric distress (I could use sorbitol for colonoscopy prep 🀭). It tastes quite pleasant but has a cooling effect on the tongue. I wouldn't mistake it for sugar. One of the "faults" is that it can recrystallise as it cools, but that may be useful in making halva.

It's readily available in crystalline form in UK supermarkets, either pure or with stevia (eg Truvia). The powder version could be made with a coffee grinder, or purchased online.

I bought a packet, tasted it and thought it was *fine*. I haven't actually used it yet.

Professor-Yaffle profile image
Professor-Yaffle

Lovely halva related memories Happyman. It's not considered a classic "comfort food" in UK culture but I do find it very comforting.Well I have never tried to make halva but I'm encouraged that you have an it's relatively easy so I'll definitely give it a go. 😊

Professor-Yaffle profile image
Professor-Yaffle

Thank-you for this very informed and useful response Subtle Badger. I feel a bit like we are talking about illicit drugs πŸ˜‚ rather than sugar substitutes.

I think the crystallisation might be useful yes. I'm now very intrigued and might try some.

Enjoy the week ahead 🦑

Professor-Yaffle profile image
Professor-Yaffle

I just saw your Holy Basil cooking. Tulsi is my favourite tea! Maybe you can grow your own in Thailand? Blimey, maybe you can grow it here, never occurred to me to try. πŸƒ

Professor-Yaffle profile image
Professor-Yaffle

Bit envious of your lifestyle right now Happyman - the user name makes sense🍡😍

Professor-Yaffle profile image
Professor-Yaffle

Great news Happyman. Did you use sugar or honey or something else? Hope you enjoy it.

Professor-Yaffle profile image
Professor-Yaffle

Brilliant.

If these threads usually stay open (i'm new here, don't really understand how it works) then I'll post when I have made some....

Enjoy.

TheJazzSinger profile image
TheJazzSinger

Hi, I’ve used erythritol frequently for lchf baking muffins, cakes, pancakes, biscuits, and even desserts, etc. and used it to sweeten rhubarb (but it did crystalise the fruit when cold) and it works fine. I use almond or coconut flour for baking and get some of my recipes from Sugarfreelondoner. I buy mine from NKD Living. All of these sweeteners are ok to use occasionally. Too much, too often can have a laxative effect! Erythritol is fairly well tolerated though. I try to stay away from sweet things too often as I find sugar quite addictive and try to stick to fruit for my fix and a bit of 85% black chocolate now and again. Happy halva making 😊

Professor-Yaffle profile image
Professor-Yaffleβ€’ in reply toTheJazzSinger

Thanks JazzSinger. That's really useful info. I'm going too try a couple of recipes I think, one with very low sugar and one with erythritol.I'm with you on the black chocolate, It's really satisfying I find. I'm a real chocolate snob! 😊

Professor-Yaffle profile image
Professor-Yaffle

A little update on my Halva quest;

Yesterday I discovered on my walk that during the lockdown/s a new shop opened somewhere near my house. You won't believe it but it's a halva shop, it only sells Halva, tahini and sesame spreads! Naturally I couldn't believe my luck or that such a strange co-incidence could happen.

Anyway they have two types of sugar free halva in many flavours. One is sweetened with Maltitol - which I sort of understand is not a great sweetener for a low carb diet so I passed over that one.

The other said it was sweetened with Stevia - but the ingredients list was not available. Unfortunately a few emails later I discovered it does have some stevia but also has about the same amount of Maltitol

😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭

The quest continues.....

One day I will get my arse in gear and make some.

Loraine518 profile image
Loraine518

I use erythritol in baking and have recently started to make low carb marzipan, which I love but had resigned myself to never having again. I find it works really well in baking, I tend to use a bit less than most recipes call for as I don't like things really sweet, the marzipan is just like the real thing.

Professor-Yaffle profile image
Professor-Yaffleβ€’ in reply toLoraine518

Why never again Loraine518? Too "addictive"? It does sound nice.

I've been experimenting a bit with erythritol too, mainly because I have some in the house. It seems like you can replace sugar with erythritol in most receipts without compromising the texture - although Subtle_badger did end up with a slightly crunchy ganache (see above).

Loraine518 profile image
Loraine518β€’ in reply toProfessor-Yaffle

Yes I'm afraid I was very addicted to marzipan and didn't want to risk. The first time I made it I ended up eating the whole lot in 2 days, but now I make it and freeze it and have a small piece a couple of times a week, which is perfect. I have just made some into little balls and covered them in homemade dark chocolate, so look forward to having them as occasional treats too.

HM keto chocolate covered marzipan
Professor-Yaffle profile image
Professor-Yaffleβ€’ in reply toLoraine518

Low carb marzipan eaters anonymous πŸ˜‚

I also freeze stuff I want to savour over a long period of time. They are nice little portions - a good idea for an occasional sweet snack.

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Low-carb induction

Starting LCHF can be scary. The low-carb bit is easy enough: you just stop eating carbs. The...
TheAwfulToad profile image
Ambassadorβ€’

low carb ?

Can I ask for your views and experience if possible,I was a follower of LCHF from march 2021 to...
mudgiebananas profile image
β€’

Low-carb (almost) Christmas

LCHF has a reputation for being as po-faced and limited as the traditional "healthy eating"...
TheAwfulToad profile image
Ambassadorβ€’

Staying low carb in a high carb world

I have had great success with going low carb, and sad to say I think my greatest ally in this has...
Subtle_badger profile image
β€’

Low Carb or Calories

I would like to ask a question in the hope that someone has a scientific answer. The questIon is...
TheJazzSinger profile image
β€’

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.