speechless: yesterday i told my friend... - Asthma Community ...

Asthma Community Forum

21,722 members24,486 posts

speechless

5 Replies

yesterday i told my friend whom i have not known for very long, that I have asthma.

She replied ""i dont know much about asthma. i dont know what i would do if someone was having an attack- probably give them a paper bag to breathe in and call 999""

she is smart, intelligent and a medical student....

i didnt know what to say. i still dont. Im speechless.

Read more about...
5 Replies

oh dear!!

When I told my Mum I'd be diagnosed with asthma she said I couldn't have it as I didn't have any of the symptoms!! I'm 29 and don't live at home, how would she know?!

thats unbelievable!!

argh!!! i hate people not understanding/ knwing what it is, what we go thru, or even worse pretending.

i have even taught my 7-10 year old brownies how to help me in an asthma attack, and did a demo, so proud of them :)

what even gets my goat more, medics/nurses think they know what best for u, they dont listen to u!!

unfrtunately WE know, WE been there before!

yaf_user681_8101 profile image
yaf_user681_8101

I had a nurse tell me that, as an asthmatic, I should wheeze and should only worry if I was breathless. Last time I go to that walk in centre.

My sister can't understand why I won't go near her house. Usually, when things are controlled well, I can get away with loading myself with antihistamines and staying for just a short time. That won't work right now - I'd end up in casualty very quickly due to her dogs. She told me that I've always had asthma and its not a problem. She doesn't get the BTS guidelines theory. You guessed it, she's a nurse.

However, there are some nurses who do understand asthma, the one at my GPs is good.

i am a nurse myself and its frustrating as i get to see it from a persnal side as well as prof side!

my ex-asthma spec nurse was useless. she showed no compassion. told me - anxious as hardly no wheeze - in clinic?? and then on admissin on ward round and i got better TOO quickly!! go figure??

that was 18 mnths ago befre lungs worse + became brittle + of course i changed my care!! i now do wheeze but not always, take lnger to recover and more importantly get taken seriusly by new dr/nurse :)

well smetimes.... yes i admit there is a lil anxiety, but there obviusly wuld be when u struglgle to breathe!

anyne else feel same?!

i got asked to explain chest tightness- to me it's like being trapped inside a glass box u cant get out of. u banging on the glass wiv all ur might. passers walk by, they ignre u/ cant hear r c u. u collapse wiv exhaustion....

then the glass breaks and a passer by comes 2 help u and u can breathe again, talk again- but with brittle asthma, for how long exactly, who knw??

x

Hi s lizzie,

Just read your post and have to say

It would be hilarious, were it not so tragic

Hope youre well

Howie

You may also like...

What would you say to her?

This friend I have (a very new friend) watched me have a asthma attack not a big one, not a problem...

Query asthma- advice needed

the morning and night and she has been struggling to catch her breath. She has been needing the blue

Asthma, pneumonia A&E and admission

necessary. I have seen the hospital's asthma nurse. She changed my regime to Mart. She was very...

Consultant doesn't believe my diagnosis

defining me not having asthma, although I don't know what normal is. I requested my medical records...

Chest Infection and new Biologic

and both my gp and asthma clinic can see that my tests are all fine. I dont know if its because ive...