Is it ok to have a slice of Cake: Hi All, Sorry... - Thyroid UK

Thyroid UK

137,613 members161,368 posts

Is it ok to have a slice of Cake

noteboo profile image
31 Replies

Hi All,

Sorry if this is a daft question.. It's a special day tomorrow. Is it ok to have a slice of Cake and few extra colories that are a complete no-no or restricted on thyriod diet.. You can tell i'm a newbie from my question( hope it made you laugh)

Thank you!

Written by
noteboo profile image
noteboo
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
31 Replies
Zazbag profile image
Zazbag

Most people with Hashimoto's should be gluten and dairy free.

Zephyrbear profile image
Zephyrbear in reply to Zazbag

I’m sorry but... why? Not everybody with Hashimoto’s needs to be gluten free.

If you wish to try it and you feel better for it, all well and good, but I don’t think it’s worth making yourself miserable over if it doesn’t make you feel any better.

I have Hashimoto’s (was finally diagnosed in 2004 after years of not being well) and was recommended to go GF. I tried for a long time but, sadly, the only thing it did was make me miserable which, in turn, had a knock-on effect on everybody else unfortunate enough to get in my way...

A GF diet may work for some people with Hashimoto’s, but to say ‘everyone’ with it should be GF is a very sweeping statement to make and not necessarily accurate!

KT77 profile image
KT77 in reply to Zephyrbear

I know right? Its not enough that we have this dreadful miserable disease. We have to follow miserable diet too. Meat and veg and avocado with nuts and seeds. Just gross. God forbid we would eat sugar that could give us energy and make us happy. Well sod it. Nothing is going to fix my thyroid so I might as well eat what I want.

Lalatoot profile image
Lalatoot

No to cake if you are on a gluten free regime and it has gluten.

Yes to cake if you are not gluten free. We all need a little to make us happy. We also need to eat enough calories. Calories are needed to convert t4 to t3.

Enjoy.

You go for it! Tuesday is another day.

NWA6 profile image
NWA6

Christ yes! Everyone needs cake! Lol Ofcourse if you’re gluten free then GF would be better but if it’s not don’t beat yourself up! Life’s too short. I think we could all do with being kinder to ourselves. 2 steps forward and all that! I should be GF, I’ve gone of the rails for 5wks now! I’ll get back on it, I have a lifetime to master this shit!! Lol

And what’s a restricted thyroid diet? You mean GF and DF? Are you sure is applicable to you?

turquoise13 profile image
turquoise13

Just had a slice of victoria sponge! Was GF but gradually fallen by the wayside lately. All things in moderation!

jimh111 profile image
jimh111

No problem at all. I have cake every week. A small percentage (7%?) of autoimmune patients seem to do a little better gluten free but the evidence is weak. Eat what you like unless there are clear problems with specific foods. There is concern that dietary restrictions are causing more problems for thyroid and other patients. Varied sensible diet is best.

pennyannie profile image
pennyannie

Well,

If it's coffee and walnut or date, walnut and ginger I'd go for it in a big way :

Enjoy the day, the people, the celebration and especially the cake :

BlackIsleGirl profile image
BlackIsleGirl

Eat the cake! In fact have a slice for me because I literally can't have wheat because of IBS and I miss cake!

The sun will still come up tomorrow and you can get back on the waggon then. Life is short - eat the cake!

madgewildfire profile image
madgewildfire in reply to BlackIsleGirl

I have IBS and I bake a flourless, sugarless cake which is gorgeous and easy to make if you have a food mixer. I can give you the recipe if you would like to give it a go. x

BlackIsleGirl profile image
BlackIsleGirl in reply to madgewildfire

That sounds fab, thank you I'd love the recipe

mandy-white profile image
mandy-white in reply to madgewildfire

Could I please have the recipe

penny profile image
penny in reply to BlackIsleGirl

express.co.uk/life-style/he.... I think that Dr Coimbra treats IBS successfully with vitamin D.

jimh111 profile image
jimh111 in reply to penny

Many years ago when I had IBS I found vit D helpful, up to around 2x RDA (can't remember what that was!). Later I found magneium citrate much better but I suspect the vit D was assisting Mg absorption and that's why it helped. There is some evidence that low vit D increases risk of COVID-19 infection. It's not solid evidence yet but it makes sense for many other reasons to make sure you are not vit D deficient.

Cooper27 profile image
Cooper27 in reply to jimh111

I've heard that one hospital found something like 94% of their patients who had died with Covid had vit D deficiency. I don't know how it impacts chances of catching it though.

jimh111 profile image
jimh111 in reply to Cooper27

It's difficult to interpret the reseach because the results can be biased by the life the patients (may have to) lead. A disproportionate number of patients have low vit D levels. This suggests it would be wise to avoid vit D deficiency. It's a cheap and safe option that could possibly save a large number of lives.

It raises the separate question of why so many vulnerable are people left vit D deficient. I feel this is disgraceful. We managed to address the problem after the war with free school milk, we should be able to keep our vulnerable population vit D replete.

helvella profile image
helvellaAdministratorThyroid UK in reply to jimh111

Some people are left vitamin D deficient because they cannot tolerate any supplementation.

I know that appropriate UV exposure can help. But an explanation, a proper understanding, would be a significant step forward. Even simple recognition that such people exist.

jimh111 profile image
jimh111 in reply to helvella

It's difficult for them. Prudent sun exposure whould help, more skin exposed the better but also perhaps more natural vitamin D such as cod liver oil, oily fish or meat, liver and eggs.

Cooper27 profile image
Cooper27 in reply to jimh111

Oh, I agree - it's a very simple/harmless way to reduce your risk of death. It's definitely something that needs more research.

BlackIsleGirl profile image
BlackIsleGirl in reply to penny

I've been taking Vit D for a while with no change in symptoms so unfortunately it might not work for everyone

penny profile image
penny in reply to BlackIsleGirl

How much are you taking, BlackIsleGirl and what are your current levels?

BlackIsleGirl profile image
BlackIsleGirl in reply to penny

All due respect Penny, you're not actually part of my medical care team so my levels etc aren't something I'm going to share with you. Or any Joe Blogs that's reading this.

The only thing that has made any difference to my IBS is not eating the foods that my body can no longer process. If Vit D works for other then I'm delighted for them.

Cooper27 profile image
Cooper27 in reply to BlackIsleGirl

No one is meaning to be rude by asking these things :) my doctor said my vitamin D levels weren't low enough to need treatment. Severe deficiency is <25, my level was 25.3. Doctors advice was to go sit in the sun more (this was in November). Most need to be around 75 to feel well. We see these stories a lot, which is the only reason people ask - just to make sure other people aren't getting poor advice like many of us have.

penny profile image
penny in reply to BlackIsleGirl

That is entirely up to you; no offence was intended. Most of us share details on here as we are not identifiable and look for suggestions and interpretation of results from others. And, yes, vitamin D does work for others. I wish you luck.

Benos123 profile image
Benos123

Just remember what Queen Marie-Antoinette of France said to all the HYPOS back in the day "LET THEM EAT CAKE" and by all accounts she wasn't that bad an Endo either!!

However about nine months later, and after her hubby King Louis dying, all the other Endo's got "to get her" and she lost De Head (Into a basket) for her cutting remarks.

On reflection I guess the Endo's didn't like her cutting remark!

penny profile image
penny in reply to Benos123

Hoho.

serenfach profile image
serenfach

No, it is not OK to eat one slice of cake. At least two slices are compulsory! :)

Zephyrbear profile image
Zephyrbear in reply to serenfach

Just about to tuck into some farmhouse fruitcake... 🤣

StitchFairy profile image
StitchFairy in reply to serenfach

Does home made Bara Brith with lashings of butter count as cake? If yes, I definitely recommend two slices :D

noteboo profile image
noteboo

Thank you all!! your comments encouraged me to enjoy cake + carbs 👍🏼

Back to norm now 😕

You may also like...

have thyroid blood draw at 11 am, will that be ok?

Sorry another question. Got a blood draw at 11am on Wednesday. Will that time be ok? I've been...

Healthy fruit and nut cake

tablespoons raw honey ( depending on how sweet you like your cakes ) Tablespoon probiotic natural...

is this ok

low on T3 considering how much I take….. what do you think?

First results for T4. Are they OK?

discuss, so I'm just trying to understand where I should be so that I can ask the right questions...

Is it ok to have a cup if tea straight after thyroid meds?

I'm new to this so have been taking my levothyroxine every morning when I wake at 6 , I have a cup...