Magnesium, NOT Calcium, is the key to healthy b... - Thyroid UK

Thyroid UK

137,634 members161,410 posts

Magnesium, NOT Calcium, is the key to healthy bones

greygoose profile image
8 Replies

besthealthyguide.com/magnes...

More about magnesium, and why we shouldn't take calcium suppléments.

Written by
greygoose profile image
greygoose
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
8 Replies
win_4ever profile image
win_4ever

Thanks a lot gg for sharing that. I was taking calcium supps until about s week ago when I saw on this forum about the dangers of it and stopped! Oh such a lot of researchers on this forum who thankfully share there findings.

Like so many of us on this site we thank God we found it. A life and death sometimes.

Thank you all. And a happy Christmas.

greygoose profile image
greygoose in reply to win_4ever

And a very happy Christmas to you, too. :)

ValTay profile image
ValTay

Thank you for that link GG. I notice though that it's calcium carbonate that they say is harmful. I take sea calcium derived from algae for my osteoporosis, plus plenty of magnesium bisglycinate (oxide is pretty useless), boron, and other co-factors such as Vit D3 and K2 as MK7 to make sure that the calcium goes into the bones and not the arteries and muscles. I also eat a healthy organic (as far as poss) diet containing food sources of these items. It would be nice though to think I could stop taking the calcium supplements twice daily - I might then be able to split my NutriThyroid into 2-3 doses, which might be more effective. Might look into this further.

greygoose profile image
greygoose in reply to ValTay

Might be more effective. But then again, it might not. A lot of people find they're better off taking it all in one go at night.

Yes, he's talking anbout calcium carbonate, the cheap stuff that doctors usually prescribe because it's cheap.

Magnesium oxide is utterly useless, the body can't absorb it.

Do they test your calcium regularly? If you've been taking it for a while, you might not need it anymore. You Don't want too much.

T3 is also necessary for bones. How is yours?

ValTay profile image
ValTay in reply to greygoose

Hi GreyGoose,

Thanks for that info. I didn't know I should get my calcium checked regularly - I'll ask for that after Christmas. My T3 was quite high when checked in February, before I consulted Dr P and changed from levo to NutriThyroid.

greygoose profile image
greygoose in reply to ValTay

Well, that's one good thing, anyway!

You Don't want too much calcium, for lots of reasons. And if you've been supplementing for a long time, you could have gone over the limit.

ValTay profile image
ValTay in reply to greygoose

Thanks again for advice. I remembered after replying yesterday that I had a full blood count and checks that included calcium earlier this year and calcium was in range.

Best wishes for Christmas and the New Year.

greygoose profile image
greygoose in reply to ValTay

Thank you, you too, ValTay. :)

You may also like...

Calcium and magnesium shouldn’t be taken at the same time as thyroid meds?

should not take calcium and magnesium at the same time as your thyroid meds and secondly calcium...

Endo asking for calcium and magnesium blood tests

read that a good reason to take magnesium is that it keeps calcium in the bones instead of in the...

What You Need to Know About Vitamin D3, K2, Calcium and Magnesium

http://www.thehealthierlife.co.uk/natural-remedies/vitamins/vitamin-d3-magnesium-calcium-vitamin-k2/

Optimum Calcium and Magnesium Supplements with Vitamin D

osteopenic (as well as hypothyroid) so need calcium but I understand calcium replacement can have...

Magnesium...

Magnesium, NOT Calcium, is The Key to Healthy Bones http://www.healthy-holistic-living.com/magnesiu