Multinodular goitre: Hi, I developed a toxic... - Thyroid UK

Thyroid UK

137,716 members161,494 posts

Multinodular goitre

Newcastle2013 profile image
12 Replies

Hi, I developed a toxic multi nodular goitre after having a 50% thyroidectmy, and I'm a little worried as im currently working overseas.

I visited my specialist in the UK last year and have recently visited a doctor here......the two pieces of advice are conflicting and wondered if any of you have or have had this condition and are willing to discuss it with me.

As I'm currently not sure what to do or whom to believe.

Many thanks in advance 😊 x

Written by
Newcastle2013 profile image
Newcastle2013
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
12 Replies
Clutter profile image
Clutter

Newcastle2013, it's generally assumed that MNG carries very low risk of being malignant but the last link suggests the incidence is higher than previously supposed. I would request a fine needle aspiration biopsy if you haven't already had one done.

mythyroid.com/toxicmultinod...

yourhormones.info/endocrine...

thyroid.org/patient-thyroid...

Newcastle2013 profile image
Newcastle2013 in reply to Clutter

Thanks for the info, its interesting to read of the change in opinion.

I had a fna about 5yrar ago and was ok.

My problem is the difference in medical systems between countries....my one remaining gland is 4times the size of an average gland and my uk doctor was happy to leave it my German doctor wanted to send me straight to a surgeon and said I should have been on meds for 20years my uk Drs said i didn't need any...so I'm confused. Who do u believe x

Clutter profile image
Clutter in reply to Newcastle2013

Newcastle, I think you need an FNA now to determine whether there have been any cell changes. If the FNA is benign and the goiter isn't impacting on other nearby organs or cosmetically upsetting you there seems no need for surgery.

UK don't treat hypothyroidism until TSH is >5, sometimes >10. If your German doctor thinks you should have been on hormone replacement for 20 years it's either because he thinks replacement may have shrunk the goiter and/or their TSH requirement is lower for commencing treatment. I would be happy with the German protocols on either.

It's just occurred to me that we get members from all over the world but I don't recall any German thyroid patients asking for help. Perhaps Germany treats thyroid better than the UK does?

Clutter profile image
Clutter in reply to Newcastle2013

Newcastle, what meds would the German doctor have had you on? I replied assuming you were hypothyroid after your partial thyroidectomy but doesn't a toxic nodule make you hyper?

Newcastle2013 profile image
Newcastle2013 in reply to Clutter

My levels are just above normal. He didn't say which meds just thyroid hormone replacement drugs (although I'm not Fluent so he may have)

Clutter profile image
Clutter in reply to Newcastle2013

Newcastle2013, replacement is for hypothyroidism so you aren't hyperthyroid then.

Clutter profile image
Clutter in reply to Newcastle2013

Newcastle2013, replacement is for hypothyroidism so you aren't hyperthyroid then.

Newcastle2013 profile image
Newcastle2013 in reply to Clutter

I got my results today I have a tsh of 0.02, t3 3.6 pgml and t4 1.2 pgml (both free).....he Said meds were no good, today and mentioned surgery or radio iodine therapy as an option but would monitor every 3months. Is the above standard or over cautious ? Thanks x

Clutter profile image
Clutter in reply to Newcastle2013

Newcastle, do you have the lab ref ranges for FT4 and FT3 (the figures in brackets after your results)?

Newcastle2013 profile image
Newcastle2013 in reply to Clutter

The only other figures are a guess research range (?) ft3 2.3-4.2 and ft4 0.9-1.8

Clutter profile image
Clutter in reply to Newcastle2013

Newcastle, If the ranges are right you are neither hypo nor hyper despite the suppressed TSH.

I don't think your doctor is being over cautious. His recommendation is surgery or RAI to ablate the thyroid and goiter. If you don't want to do either he wants to monitor you every 3 months.

Newcastle2013 profile image
Newcastle2013

Neither, my levels were within range last year. He said thyroid meds would have prevented the goitre developing and will slow its progress....like I said I'm confused as it contradicts the info I've. Already received.

You may also like...

Checkup of multinodular goitre at ENT

I have a checkup of my multinodular goitre at the end of Feb 2023 and I would like some advice...

Multinodular goitre

so not sure what’s what at the moment) I do have PoTS, so can be tachycardic at times but have...

Multinodular goitre/thyroid antibodies

my first post and I'm in need of help/advice. Judging by what I have read, I believe you guys know...

Multinodular Goitre benign

TSH 2.25 apparently I'm not pre diabetic which is good. I'm now looking for advice on how to deal...

RFA treatment for toxic multinodular goitre

necessary as they would have accepted a referral from my GP . My GP didn't believe me when I told...