Interesting article in today's Sunday Times ... - Thyroid UK

Thyroid UK

137,731 members161,517 posts

Interesting article in today's Sunday Times ...

20 Replies

An Elite British athlete claims her health was damaged by large doses of Thyroxine, she was born without a thyroid gland. It goes on to say about several British athletes' widespread fear that Thyroxine is being used by rivals to gain an unfair advantage.

Mention is made of several Professors of Endocronology, including Mark Vanderpump,, who claim that her results suggest she was taking too much. Well they would say that wouldn't they.

Almost a half page article on this 'turbocharger' medication.

Read more about...
20 Replies
Pinkpeony profile image
Pinkpeony

Certainly doesn't turbocharge me c g.

In fact quite the reverse lol.

Pp

in reply to Pinkpeony

Know what you mean Pinkpeony!

wightmouse profile image
wightmouse

Here is the link to the study, Clinical investigation of athletes with persistent fatigue and/or recurrent infections

bjsm.bmj.com/content/38/1/4...

Excerpt: - Thyroid dysfunction was noted in one female athlete, and this was not associated with amenorrhoea, which is a common cause of thyroid disorders in female athletes. The thyroid dysfunction consisted of slightly raised thyroid stimulating hormone and low thyroxine with high to normal tri-iodothyronine, in conjunction with a family history of thyroid disease.

No mention of Athlete taking thyroid hormone?

in reply to wightmouse

wightmouse - she was born without a thyroid gland

wightmouse profile image
wightmouse in reply to

Hi cinnamon_girl

Have not seen Sunday times article was just taking the info from the research article that maybe sparked the article.

in reply to wightmouse

Ah, sorry wightmouse. Was confused!

shaws profile image
shawsAdministrator

I think if athletes who are not hypothyroid would probably take T3 rather than T4. Some do to increase muscle mass. I certainly wouldn't if I didn't have a thyroid dysfunction.

in reply to shaws

shaws - as she was born without a thyroid gland then she had no choice but to take Thyroxine. However, it obviously doesn't state in the article what dose she was taking so the comments made by Vanderpump et al are rubbish, again.

shaws profile image
shawsAdministrator in reply to

For people who have a dysfunction of the thyroid gland, the have no alternative to take thyroid hormones. It's a pity it's only levo they probably get prescribed, especially being an athlete where they will use a lot of T3.

For some pronouncements we have to take them with a 'pinch of salt', as many don't make sense. We only realise this when we cannot get well with the 'routine' medication.

greygoose profile image
greygoose in reply to shaws

I think a lot of amateurs do take T3 - and some T2 - but Don't know about professionals. You can find T3 on body-building sites, but grossly over-priced!

Marz profile image
Marz

Think the Sunday Times we have here in Crete must be different - can't find the article. Which section was it in ?

Thank you... :-)

Clutter profile image
Clutter in reply to Marz

Marz, thesundaytimes.co.uk/sto/ne...

helvella profile image
helvellaAdministratorThyroid UK in reply to Clutter

And a bit more:

stokesentinel.co.uk/Athleti...

Marz profile image
Marz in reply to Clutter

Ta :-)

in reply to Marz

Marz - the main section, page 15.

Marz profile image
Marz in reply to

Thank you :-) I'll have a look .... Have heard that T3 has been mis-used in Sport but not T4....interesting.

Clutter profile image
Clutter

C-G, I can believe a dumb sports coach/doctor might think there could be some advantage in overmedicating her but I would have thought overmedication would cause pain and other adverse symptoms within a few weeks and would make her underperform.

Does the print article say how much she was taking?

in reply to Clutter

Clutter - I would say that when performing at Elite level together with its pressures, it would be easy to ignore symptoms and just tough it out. This does throw up all sorts of questions though regarding the medical advice she was given by UK Athletics when the condition is normally monitored by a GP. No mention made of her dosage.

Surely there's potentially huge implications for sport generally and hope to hear more about this. It's a shame that the Sunday Times is behind a paywall.

Clutter profile image
Clutter in reply to

C-G, there was discussion about thyroid replacement and sports athletes in a post a while back. I think it was Helvella who found that Levothyroxine is not on the list of substances banned for athletes. I'd have a look for it but until HU fix the Search Function I'm not using it.

BeansMummy profile image
BeansMummy

Well, I think I had just better get fitter then, I will obviously be ready in time for the next Olympics.

You may also like...

Dr Malcolm Kendrick writes in today's Sunday Times

Haven't yet had a proper read but it's a whole page article in the Review section.

Interesting article about Ferritin

Interesting article by Max Pemberton

This article in The Telegraph goes some way to highlighting why we all have so many problems with...

Very interesting article

https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/the-depression-epidemic-and-why-the-medical-profession-is-failin

A (somewhat) lighthearted article for Sunday afternoon

This article shows that hypothyroid women have more sexual arousal on T4/T3 combined therapy than on