Push for Thyroid screening by experts in UK cou... - Thyroid UK

Thyroid UK

137,135 members160,810 posts

Push for Thyroid screening by experts in UK could treat 100,000 cases as a result.

tegz profile image
tegz
5 Replies

This article found whilst looking at the recent 'Pulse' post about over diagnosing UAT- so it's rather apposite to post it now, to cheer you all up.

Chances of anything happening- who knows? - but in the right direction, for a change.

pulsetoday.co.uk/screening-...

Written by
tegz profile image
tegz
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
5 Replies
lynx profile image
lynx

pulse-learning.co.uk/clinic...

This might be worth looking at as well.

tegz profile image
tegz

Looks good- but I don't want to sign up :)

rosetrees profile image
rosetrees

I signed up a few weeks ago. So I've completed my CPD model on hypothyroidism. Clearly, if the GMC ever catch up with me my licence to practice as a GP will be revoked and I'll be struck off. (In case of doubt, I have no medical training of any kind).

That module includes these two conflicting statements on the SAME PAGE (aplogies for shouting)

1) "The only validated test for thyroid function is the measurement of serum thyroid stimulating hormone (TSH) and free thyroxine (T4) and hypothyroidism is confirmed by an increase in serum TSH above the upper limit of the normal reference range.

Many labs routinely only report serum TSH but if it is abnormal, they will usually also give FT4 levels"

2) "Diagnosis of hypothyroidism

Overt hypothyroidism

TSH over 10 mU/l

FT4 below reference range

Subclinical hypothyroidism or mild thyroid failure

TSH 5 to 10 mU/l

FT4 normal

Secondary hypothyroidism

TSH low/low-normal

FT4 low"

Give the statements in 1) it seems clear that secondary hypothyroidism will never be diagnosed, yet they acknowledge its existence.

Explanations on a postcard, please.

rosetrees profile image
rosetrees

I will almost certainly be struck off now. I have just sent this email to Pulse. I couldn't resist. Sorry.

"Reference pulse-learning.co.uk/clinic...

On this page you explain that: "The only validated test for thyroid function is the measurement of serum thyroid stimulating hormone (TSH) and free thyroxine (T4) and hypothyroidism is confirmed by an increase in serum TSH above the upper limit of the normal reference range. Many labs routinely only report serum TSH but if it is abnormal, they will usually also give FT4 levels"

Further down, under Diagnosis Of Hypothyroidism you state: "Secondary hypothyroidism,TSH low/low-normal,FT4 low"

Given the previous statement on TFT, could you please explain how a diagnosis of Secondary hypothyroidism should be made?"

tegz profile image
tegz in reply to rosetrees

Fair enough point- it's called logic. Maybe they'll get to try it one day ...

You may also like...

Test results for coeliac and thyroid screen

bit concerned with the antibody level on the thyroid test - it seems very high?! How can I lower

Doc says low thyroid function results are normal and not to be treated.

supplements. But low thyroid function can cause low phosphate. Surely even if my thyroid...

Thyroid results and B12 improvement, but could I still have anaemia?

I’m hoping that someone wouldn’t mind looking at my latest thyroid and vitamin results and advise....

Could someone take a look at my mums thyroid results?

Hi Everyone... Posting here for my Mum (71) who has had high TSH for quite some time (GPs have been...

Could under treated Thyroid cause acute pain all over the body?