DCIS, a real dilemma: About 25% of all... - SHARE Breast Canc...

SHARE Breast Cancer Support

2,368 members853 posts

DCIS, a real dilemma

Well1501 profile image
Well1501Moderator
4 Replies

About 25% of all newly diagnosed breast cancer is DCIS (Ductal Carcinoma In Situ). It's frequently called Stage 0 breast cancer. Controversy surrounds DCIS. Should it be called a cancer? Is it over diagnosed? Is it over treated? Current clinical trial research is trying to find the answers to some or all of these questions.

Here is a link to an article that talks about the ongoing research that hopes to answer these and other issues surrounding DCIS. These trials include COMET, LORD and LORIS.

ascopost.com/issues/march-2...

What are your thoughts?

Written by
Well1501 profile image
Well1501
Moderator
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
4 Replies
Nicu697 profile image
Nicu697

I had DCIS two areas in left breast with mastectomy and five be yrs Tamoxifen after. I would not opt to not treat as I have read breast cancer returned in some cases.

urthmothr profile image
urthmothr

How often does DCIS become invasive? or to put it another way, how often does invasive breast cancer start with DCIS? Since it was scattered throughout my breast, i allowed the oncologist to remove the whole breast for my peace of mind. Margins and lymph nodes were clear, so no chemo or radiation treatment, just close monitoring of the other breast.

Well1501 profile image
Well1501Moderator in reply to urthmothr

Studies have shown 70-80% of DCIS may never become invasive breast cancer even when DCIS is left untreated. But since it is not known which DCIS will become invasive, all DCIS is treated similarly. Frequently when DCIS is multi-focal, mastectomy is the standard of care.

There is a clinical trial is that currently taking place to help better understand DCIS. It is the COMET Study. The COMET Study will provide information to better understand low-risk DCIS. In particular, it will provide information on the trade-offs between immediate standard treatment (surgery and possibly radiation) and active surveillance. This will help determine if more patients are able to avoid aggressive ‘cancer’ treatments and their potential side effects. It will also help to personalize treatment choices. These choices may better reflect individual values and preferences. Currently, all women diagnosed with DCIS are treated as if they have invasive breast cancer. The hope is that the COMET Study will show that active surveillance is equally as safe and effective as surgery for women with low-risk DCIS.

urthmothr profile image
urthmothr in reply to Well1501

Since I had several focal points in one breast, I feel safer getting rid of it!

You may also like...

DCIS Diagnosis in 2023

wait, I was called to the breast unit for the results on the day of the phone call. It was DCIS...

Stage 0 DCIS Double Mastectomy

Told aromatase inhibitor is not working?

been diagnosed with a new cancer in the other breast. I talked to the oncologist briefly over the...

\"Ask Me Anything\" with Dr. Susan Love. Join Now!

Ask a breast cancer expert anything! Post your questions here to have them answered by Dr. Susan...

Student Looking to learn about Breast Cancer

on breast cancer. I want to learn about and understand what it is like living with breast cancer. I...