How much pain? Vs how much pred?: I saw my GP this... - PMRGCAuk

PMRGCAuk

20,265 members37,916 posts

How much pain? Vs how much pred?

Peggles profile image
26 Replies

I saw my GP this week for the first time in about 8 months and obviously he was horrified that I was still taking 12mg pred/day 10months on.

But, I still can't get my arms up to, let alone above, shoulder height until lunchtime and wake as if my torso is in a vice. After tossing and turning thru the small hours.

Plus side is that my energy levels are pretty good, I've learnt to pace and probably achieve about 75% of my pre PMR activities.

Should I split my dose? Take more paracetamol, more hot showers? In the excellent book (Kate?), she talks about how much paracetamol she took, yet some of you wonderful aunties, recommend flushing out the inflammation with the pred.

I don't know what to do? (ESR and CRP both below 5)

Written by
Peggles profile image
Peggles
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
26 Replies
SheffieldJane profile image
SheffieldJane

I think I would horrify my GP a bit more by being tempted to up my dose until I achieved a better range of arm movement and a lessoning of pain. Although your energy is enviable, it doesn't sound to me like your inflammation has ever been properly controlled. My starting dose was 20 mgs and apart from a lifting of mood, the first symptom to relieve was the awful stiffness that prevented, amongst other symptoms, me lifting my arms up above my head. You shouldn't have been left to suffer so long.

As you probably know from these pages the CRP and ESR levels are not a reliable indicator of your symptoms.

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador

For most PMR pain paracetamol won't do a thing. Kate says she used it for withdrawal pain - I and many others prevent the withdrawal pain by using a slow and graded reduction patterm. Paracetamol is not an innocent drug either - very bad for livers.

Of course your ESR/CRP are normal - you are taking enough pred to (eventually) eliminate the inflammation so the acute phase response doesn't develop to raise the markers.

What time do you take your pred? Have you tried taking it before bed so it is already working by the morning? Have you tried splitting yet? Have you ever been more pain free? What did you start at and what was the result?

Is this a GP diagnosis? Have you been investigated for anything else? Ankylosing spondylitis, for example, can present very like PMR but the pain is worst earlier in the night (say, 2 or 3am) and is relieved by movement.

Sorry - more questions than potential answers, but I think something is being missed.

Peggles profile image
Peggles in reply to PMRpro

Many thanks - wondering if I should see a private rheumatologist?

Agree ref. blood markers.

Tried splitting the pred today but my legs have gone from under me!

Started at 20mgs last December with miraculous results but terrible fatigue, and dropped to 7mgs by beginning of summer, then 'flared' so went back up to 15 and have been dropping slowly and keeping a diary of activity to try and track the pred, activity and pain.

It is GP diagnosis, he also tested for Lymes and Lupus, but I think the miracle of pred made up both our minds.

And my liver function, chlorestrol level and thyroid function tests all came back within the normal range. I have low blood pressure anyway and presume my blood sugar was tested too.

I'm now 52 and obviously have the other autoimmune diseases - psoriasis, hypothyroidism, Reynauds....

And frighteningly, yesterday I walked the dogs first thing. Before taking pred, and the early morning stiffness was much less.

But am tempted by SheffieldJanes advice and to go back to 15mgs until this wretched pain is under control. My GP doesn't seem too bothered about seeing me and just leaves multiple retreat prescriptions for me.

Perhaps I'm just one of the worried well?

Soraya_PMR profile image
Soraya_PMR in reply to Peggles

Symmetric psoriatic arthritis???

I don’t know much about it, but I think the presenting symptoms can be similar to PMR. I know my rheumie questioned me about psoriasis, not just in me but my family as well.

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador in reply to Peggles

Soraya has already said what I thought straight away. Anyone with psoriasis must have PsA considered. It could account for night pain and the fact the walking the dogs helped...

I'm not sure about private - you still usually have to get a referral from a GP and even private may not get you far if you have a dud rheumy plus the imaging needed is very expensive.

Where are you? If you do go private you need a good rheumy to make it worth it - who will add you to their NHS list if they think it is needed.

But no, don't think you are one of the worried well - your GP is being self-satisfied. For a start I would go back to 15mg and see if you can get this pain more under control and when you reduce go just 1mg at a time and more slowly, 20 to 7 in 6 months is fast.

But you need an expert.

Mitziecat profile image
Mitziecat in reply to PMRpro

I was dignosed in June by my GP who referred me immediately to a Rheumatologist. The NHS wait time was long so I reseached a private Rheumatologist that specilised in pmr and paid for a private consultation. He confirmed the dignosis, advised the mediction schedule and agreed to add me to his NHS list. It is worth it for peace of mind.

Mitziecat profile image
Mitziecat in reply to Peggles

I would suggest that you see a Rheumatologist privately for a quicker appointment. Not good that you don’t see your GP regularly and only collect repeat prescriptions.

1Purplecrow profile image
1Purplecrow

Worried well? I dont think so!! Sounds like the time to take charge of your own situation. I would probably return to 15 mg pred for a few weeks...then if all seems under control, begin a verrrry slow taper.

My PMR journey is 4 years long, and I am now at 4.5 mg pred. Tapering each 1/2mg drop over a period of weeks. No rush to the end.

Kind regards, Jerri

Peggles profile image
Peggles

Thank you friends. It's hard to ignore a GP. I am confident of his diagnosis - I have to be, but he really sees the pred as a race to zero!

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador in reply to Peggles

It is only a race in tortoise mode...

GOOD_GRIEF profile image
GOOD_GRIEF in reply to Peggles

That's the wrong goal.

The actual goal is to control the inflammation so that you sustain the lowest amount of damage from the PMR until it burns itself out, while having the fewest and least severe flares (which only lengthen the course of the disease and result in a higher level of pred consumption in the long term).

Take your vitamins, eat the rainbow, avoid empty calories, exercise gently to maintain flexibility and slowly rebuild strength, get enough rest, and find moments of laughter and beauty and joy every day.

Hollyseden profile image
Hollyseden in reply to GOOD_GRIEF

Good Grief... Wise words and advice.

Peggles profile image
Peggles

Thank you all.

I've tried to remain on 12mg, splitting the dose but failing.

So I will now try going back up to 15mgs(and splitting the dose)

How long should I do this for?

Many thanks

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador in reply to Peggles

At least until the symptoms are back to stable and the same as you were on the starting dose - don't rush to just do the dusting until you have cleared out the mess!

Peggles profile image
Peggles in reply to PMRpro

Ok, went back up to 20mg for 4 days (which was recommended to someone else on here - split 15/5). Perfect.

Back to 15mg, split 10/5 but still in pain from, say, 2am onwards. So that's telling me I should take some of my dose before bed? But I take my thyroid medication on the middle of the night (can't remember why!)

Thoughts please? Or do I decide the drugs don't work anymore and I need to try one of the steroid sparing ones? Metroxate or something?

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador in reply to Peggles

No I don't think so - not yet! You have made too big a drop - bodies don't like it. You need to reduce in far smaller steps - 1mg at a time is quite enough.

But the 2am pain bothers me a bit - is your doctor sure it is PMR you have? Pain at that time of night is typical of another form of inflammatory arthritis which is sometimes misdiagnosed as PMR. PMR pain tends to be later and both would respond to enough pred.

Peggles2 profile image
Peggles2

Which other horrid cruel inflammatory arthritis are you thinking of?

PMR seems such a good fit with symptoms and reaction to steroids, but every time I try to reduce - BANG! Back with the pain.

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador in reply to Peggles2

Ankylosing spondylitis is one that a couple of friends with "PMR" eventually turned out to have. There are doctors who think it only happens in young men - no it doesn't. One eventually went to Prof Mackie in Leeds and happened to mention night-time pain - lightbulb moment for Sarah, she was sent for the right imaging and bingo, answer found. It responds better to NSAIDs strangely but they now use anti-TNF biologics for it - which do not work in GCA (and presumably PMR).

It might be worth discussing it with a rheumy.

Pmrmolly2018 profile image
Pmrmolly2018

What do you do if your GP doesn’t want to give you enough pred to control pain. I.e i had bad flare in February caused by severe virus. GP happily upped from 13.5 to 15 for 6 weeks. Now my new prescription has come in at 10mg! He is away and the pharmacy say it is not in their remit to change. Advice please? I have requested an appointment to see him. Probably will take weeks. Can I insist? I feel like a ‘drug addict’ asking for what I need to control the pain and fatigue.

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador in reply to Pmrmolly2018

You shouldn't/can't drop 5mg just like that - it will cause trouble! Insist on seeing another doctor immediately - or at least before you have run out of pred trying to reduce to 13.5mg (show willing at least ;) ) After all, it was the GP who upped it in the first place.

piglette profile image
piglette in reply to Pmrmolly2018

How long would your new prescription last if you took 15mg for example, presumably you were given a few weeks supply so have time to sort it out with another doctor? Can you make a phone call to your medical centre and ask to talk to another doctor while yours is away and explain the situation?

Pmrmolly2018 profile image
Pmrmolly2018 in reply to piglette

Thank you and prmpro for your replies. I have enough pred for several weeks and after the holiday will make contact with the Surgery. What I want to know is IF the doctor can insist you taper quicker than the pain allows. Ie only give you what THEY think you should have. PMR started last June...have not managed to get below 13.5 mg. When I dropped to 12.5...within a couple of days, I went down with a terrible virus that lasted 7 weeks. Only just recovering and still very tired all the time.

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador in reply to Pmrmolly2018

They can refuse to give you enough pred yes - they do hold the cards. But I would go to any and all other available doctors until I found one who treats the patient, not the text book.

piglette profile image
piglette in reply to Pmrmolly2018

Your GP sounds quite reasonable in that they offered you more pred when you got the virus. It is the doctors who force people to reduce or get off pred virtually immediately that are the frightening ones. Is there any reason to think that your doctor may put up a fight if you felt you needed more pred?

Pmrmolly2018 profile image
Pmrmolly2018 in reply to piglette

....he has been fine to date. But I was very surprised that my prescription had been reduced to 10mg. No mention of this reduction. I have sent a message and asked if he would like a face to face meeting. We have 2 monthly update by email and phone conversation when I was recently ill. I have not seen him since June last year.

in reply to Pmrmolly2018

I just wondered if your prescription notes say something like "15mg a day reducing by 1mg a month" . The computer or the person who looks after such things was reducing on that basis until i informed them i was staying for longer on each drop as per rheumy. I havent had any trouble since then.

You may also like...

How much to increase Pred.

very slowly from 15 down to 12.5 Prednisolone (for PMR) . In all honesty never totally pain free...

How much Pred to increase after flare up

March with PMR and have been enjoying reading everything on this site. I was happily reducing Preds...

How much pain is reasonable?

and have some pain? Might it be better to split the pred and take twice a day? Or increase it to...

How much pred?

I'm trying to get an idea of how much pred my dad should be taking as his dosage seems pretty low...

How much should I increase pred when having a flare

site. I was diagnosed with PMR 15 months ago and have managed to reduce pred to 11mg.  Over the...