Intermittent Fasting Seems To Work - Cure Parkinson's

Cure Parkinson's

25,482 members26,803 posts

Intermittent Fasting Seems To Work

jimcaster profile image
75 Replies

I have been experimenting with intermittent fasting. I eat no earlier than 2:00 p.m. and no later than 8:00 p.m. Some days, I don't eat until 5:00 p.m. Especially when I wait until 5:00, my sense of smell is much better and I feel better than ever. I never had a resting tremor, but occasionally have an "intentional tremor" in which I tremble slightly when drinking from a glass, etc. The intentional tremor disappears and I feel completely normal if I don't eat until 5:00. It's much easier to do than I anticipated. I encourage you to try it.

Written by
jimcaster profile image
jimcaster
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
75 Replies
MBAnderson profile image
MBAnderson

But, Jim what about that morning coffee?

No food till 2 PM. I'm impressed. Really. I don't eat after 7 PM or before 11 AM, but now you've inspired me so now I want to try for a 6 hour window like you.

I've never seen it discussed anywhere, but do you think a morning coffee undermines the fast?

jimcaster profile image
jimcaster in reply to MBAnderson

I have never liked coffee, so that's not an issue for me, but I don't think it would be a big deal either way. In fairness, I should admit that I take half of my supplements in the morning so I'm not 100% pure either. 😊

KERRINGTON profile image
KERRINGTON in reply to jimcaster

But, don't we need to take many of our vitamin supplements with food ?

jimcaster profile image
jimcaster in reply to KERRINGTON

Good question. I have always taken supplements and vitamins twice a day usually on an empty stomach with no I'll effects which I can determine.

KERRINGTON profile image
KERRINGTON in reply to jimcaster

Yes, I use to do that too, till I read about how we are just wasting $, and not getting benefits if we don't take our supplements with food. Google each supplement, and see what it should be taken with...unless it's like B1 with special orders from dear DR C !

MBAnderson profile image
MBAnderson in reply to KERRINGTON

True. A few can be taken on an empty stomach, but most should be taken with food depending on a few things but mostly whether or not they are water or fat soluble.

Kia17 profile image
Kia17 in reply to MBAnderson

Hi Marc

For me morning coffee with MCT oil C8 , butter and Mannitol won’t ruin my everyday intermittent fasting.Kia

ParlePark profile image
ParlePark in reply to Kia17

Ditto.

MBAnderson profile image
MBAnderson in reply to ParlePark

Thanks you two. I was so hoping that would be the answer.

dadcor profile image
dadcor in reply to Kia17

Hi Kia, could you recommend a good source of MCT C8 oil? Thks

Kia17 profile image
Kia17 in reply to dadcor

Hi Dadcor

I get it from here;

shop.ketosource.co.uk/produ...

Its been said that this “MCT C8 is the purest in the market.”. For me works very well.

AmyLindy profile image
AmyLindy in reply to Kia17

Same 🚩w modification: I use coconut oil, ghee and mannitol. Fats help Stretch the fasting period, nicely & give supplements something to grab onto.

Kia17 profile image
Kia17 in reply to AmyLindy

I replaced Butter with Ghee in my morning coffee few months ago.

AmyLindy profile image
AmyLindy in reply to Kia17

That’s my fav morning beverage...

AmyLindy profile image
AmyLindy in reply to Kia17

Me too- the coffee mix serves as a low carb meal substitute and vitamin substrate!

Livin_MY_life profile image
Livin_MY_life in reply to MBAnderson

I’m with you MB. 11:30 is my limit. Maybe its the am coffee or the am supplements or MAYBe the combo of both, but by 1130 I have to eat! Evenings nothing after 7. I recently started with a trainer at the gym who of course was horrified with my eating schedule but OK with choices...Hohummm!!! try living with PD buddy and we’ll discuss. I’ll give him credit though, he did listen to my reasons and moved on from there. Sometimes the look of apathy pays off 😏

MBAnderson profile image
MBAnderson in reply to Livin_MY_life

Ha.

in reply to MBAnderson

Not if it's black coffee.

M1tz1 profile image
M1tz1 in reply to MBAnderson

I don't think you need worry about the morning coffee, MBAnderson. I listened to discussions on the Awakening from Alzheimer's online series, and programme host, Peggy Sarlin, and Dr Perlmutter seem to have OKed it. Dr Perlmutter advocates fasting. 🙂

bassofspades profile image
bassofspades in reply to MBAnderson

Coffe is ok but without sugar, use mannitol instead, and heavy cream has no lactose,instead of milk. Take vitamins with fish oil and coconut oil for fat solubility. Intermittent fasting is all about no carbs no protein for 12 hrs a day or longer.

MBAnderson profile image
MBAnderson in reply to bassofspades

Thank you, thank you.

ParlePark profile image
ParlePark in reply to bassofspades

Ditto, kinda. Mannitol, MCT with Coconut oil or ghee butter and also take supplements same time. Breakfast at 8 dinner between 3:30-4:30.

AmyLindy profile image
AmyLindy in reply to ParlePark

Dinner so early! What time do you go to sleep ? 💤 I don’t have the willpower to fast through evenings at home!

ParlePark profile image
ParlePark in reply to AmyLindy

Usually 2200 hrs. Just got used to it. I eat plenty - just between 0800-1630 approximately most days.

dadcor profile image
dadcor

Do you have days with no food at all? Also do you keep any special diet?

jimcaster profile image
jimcaster in reply to dadcor

As of yet, I have not tried to go without food all day, but I'm confident I could do it. For now, when I do eat, it's nothing pre-packaged. Lots of vegetables, nuts, fish, fresh fruit, greens, etc.

MBAnderson profile image
MBAnderson in reply to jimcaster

Sure you could do it, no trouble. I Haven't eaten since yesterday at 7 PM and don't feel bothered by it, although I do drink a lot.

AmyLindy profile image
AmyLindy in reply to MBAnderson

What do you drink a lot of 🍷? That phrase has “a lot of” connotations...

MBAnderson profile image
MBAnderson in reply to AmyLindy

Tap water, mineral water, and cold green tea.

AmyLindy profile image
AmyLindy in reply to jimcaster

Ditto

64sa8ndF profile image
64sa8ndF

We don’t eat after 5.30pm until 8am the following morning, would that count?

jimcaster profile image
jimcaster in reply to 64sa8ndF

Google "intermittent fasting for brain health" and you'll get lots of info. I think what you are doing is good, but I think an even longer period without food could be even better.

in reply to 64sa8ndF

Yes. You are doing better than 99% of the population!

NewHope1961 profile image
NewHope1961

I have just started the following fasting strategy: one bowl of fruits, berries and green tea no coffee, no lunch until 12:30 , no beef, chicken and fish only. Ask me what about results in 30 days

jimcaster profile image
jimcaster in reply to NewHope1961

Please report back in 30 days and I'll do the same.

AmyLindy profile image
AmyLindy in reply to NewHope1961

How’s the 30 day (plus) results @newhope1961 ?

NewHope1961 profile image
NewHope1961 in reply to AmyLindy

Fasting helps, but the biggest positive effect is 1.5 hours of exercise every morning, treadmill, yoga, rock steady and sandune blocks. Exercise is as far as I know the only proven way to stop the progression

NewHope1961 profile image
NewHope1961 in reply to AmyLindy

One thing Specifically I did notice that helps is no milk , eggs or cheese......however THE best thing I have ever done was change my exercise routine to what I just described in the last 30 days

sparkyparky profile image
sparkyparky

“It works” means ...?

Isn’t it “the placebo effect?”

Lots of things work if you believe in them. If it helps you, do it. But I won’t be. I need more than “faith “ in fasting 🤔

jimcaster profile image
jimcaster in reply to sparkyparky

I tried to be specific. Enhanced sense of smell, decreased intentional tremor, and a feeling of normalcy, which I associate with mental clarity and reduced anxiety. I'm going to continue doing this several days per week to see if my handwriting improves. There's a lot of legitimate research identifying the specific benefits of fasting, but to each his own...

NewHope1961 profile image
NewHope1961 in reply to sparkyparky

Meaning I simply feel better, very little tremors and stiffness

colourmepurple profile image
colourmepurple

I have done this on a limited basis - nothing until 11.30am, nothing after 7.30pm. this is the only way I have managed to lose weight. However, it does play havoc with medications which have to be taken with food three times a day!

Alanjohn1943 profile image
Alanjohn1943

I've not been eating till after12 noon for the past six months and have been much better

buzbyc profile image
buzbyc

There's a fair amount of research out there around the benefits of intermittent fasting, particularly focused on gut-health, which we all know is directly connected to brain health. I would highly recommend the podcasts by a UK Dr called "Feel better, live more", with the following episode particularly relevant:

drchatterjee.com/healing-ib...

On a personal note I have been intermittently fasting 3 days a week for the last 3 weeks and there's no doubt that meds work better on these days, although my thinking is that this may be primarily related to protein avoidance.

Nick

shanaandbear profile image
shanaandbear

Is constipation a problem?

jimcaster profile image
jimcaster in reply to shanaandbear

Not for me. I've never had that problem.

amykp profile image
amykp

I do IF too, nothing but plain green tea in the morning to start my day. Coffee w/ MCT and heavy cream and supplements usually not until about 2:00. I try to finish my last bit of dinner by 8:00pm, 7:00 if possible.

It's for the autophagy! And I don't take sinemet yet, so it has nothing to do w/ medication absorbtion.

bassofspades profile image
bassofspades

Great post JC! I recommend a book called The Obesity Code for great information on intermittent fasting . It's not hard or scary at all!

jimcaster profile image
jimcaster in reply to bassofspades

Thanks! I'll check out the book!

Danasr profile image
Danasr

I IF as well dx April 18 and I feel as though my tremor has not progressed. I have a lot more energy, less brain fog, no longer diabetic & have lost 35 pounds. Easiest lifestyle change I’ve ever made.

MBAnderson profile image
MBAnderson

IMHO, the jury has come in on (intermittent) fasting -- it's good To do. I put it At # 3 in importance, right behind exercise and sleep.

Kia17 profile image
Kia17

The purpose of the IF is to adapt our body to use fat converted to ketons as a source of energy rather than glucose to tackle the problem associated with Insulin resistance, therefor we will need to avoid eating carbs or protein during our fasting (anything that raises insulin or blood sugar not allowed) no matter fruits or bread ,...etc.The more hours we don’t eat the better results we will get. I think avoiding gluten is also a great help adding even more value to the IF.

bassofspades profile image
bassofspades

2 more cents....no animal in nature, including the human body, was designed to eat 3 meals a day! And breakfast is not the most important meal of the day. It is the most important meal of the day to SKIP!

in reply to bassofspades

bass......now you tell me ! 😜😜😜

Art

bassofspades profile image
bassofspades in reply to

😂

bassofspades profile image
bassofspades in reply to

Every new day is another opportunity to try it . It's not as hard as it looks

AmyLindy profile image
AmyLindy in reply to bassofspades

Ha- it is certainly the easiest meal to skip! Especially w a yummy fatty coconut cream coffee!

unsinkable profile image
unsinkable

Most of my life I have had a 6-8 hour window of eating,for me it works well. I once read that having coffee, if loaded with cream, butter etc is considered a meal.....so probably not best to have along with your first meal. Dr. Pamela Fergusson,RD,PHD, says if you can't manage this way you can do a 5-2 pattern, which is for 2 days a week men can have 600 calories and women 200, then for 5 days eat as you normally would......

John_morris71 profile image
John_morris71

Jim,

My mother has dinner at around 7.30pm in the night and then she only has Bullet-Proof Coffee at around 7.30am the next morning and nothing till lunch at 12.00noon-12.30 pm. Seemed to have increased her energy levels./alertness to some extent, but any benefit towards reducing tremors seems minimal. Even then, it has improved her a lot, comparing before vs after she started fasting. It has now been almost 8 months since she has been doing it.

narcisa56 profile image
narcisa56

Hi, Jim,

I started intermittent fasting on my son's recommendation a week ago - I eat between 11.00 a.m. and 7:00 p.m. So far have noticed no improvement, hope I will :) I feel that drinking wine increases my tremor (mostly intentional as well).

Is it possible not to lose weight with this regimen? I'm already too slim..............:(

ion_ion profile image
ion_ion in reply to narcisa56

This is strange. Usually the alcohol reduces the tremor for PD or Essential Tremor. Regarding the fasting I put a post in early June. I had a colonoscopy and stopped eating for two days and also cleaned my digestive system. All the symptoms just went away for a while. They came back but in a reduced intensity.

AmyLindy profile image
AmyLindy in reply to ion_ion

Fascinating...

jimcaster profile image
jimcaster in reply to narcisa56

I agree with Ion. I don't have a resting tremor, but my occasional intention tremor is reduced by alcohol. I'm not sure about the weight loss aspect, but I assume if you load up on calories between 11 and 7, you should be okay. One final thought--of the more than one dozen things I do or take to combat the progression of PD, I have very little idea what is specifically helpful. I'm not as concerned about getting "better" as I am about not getting worse. Intermittent fasting is one of many things I am throwing at the wall, in the hope that something sticks. The research seems fairly compelling and fortunately I don't find fasting to be very difficult. I may not be getting better, but I'm confident I'm better doing something than if I did nothing. Good luck!

ion_ion profile image
ion_ion in reply to jimcaster

After the event I described above my symptoms got reduced and also I reduced the medication, too. B1 from 2g to 1g, c/l from 3x 100/25 to 2x100/25 and amantadine from 2x 100 to zero.

AmyLindy profile image
AmyLindy in reply to jimcaster

It is an efficient lifestyle change W/ zero side effects/downside !

ParlePark profile image
ParlePark in reply to jimcaster

I feel same Jim.

in reply to jimcaster

Hi jimcaster, isn’t essential tremor the one that responds to alcohol? I have heard that it is often used as a differential diagnosis indicator that distinguishes it from PD.

jimcaster profile image
jimcaster in reply to

I've read that, too. Unfortunately, even though they are mild, I have several other symptoms which are consistent with PD (micrographia, poor sense of smell, poor arm swing when walking, bradykinesia) to believe the diagnosis of PD from a Movement Disorders Specialist at Mayo Clinic is correct. I also believe that PD is not a single disease, but an array of related disorders with multiple causes...

jeeves19 profile image
jeeves19

Jim. Are you still fasting? Just wondered after reading this thread. If you are, do you think it helps?

jimcaster profile image
jimcaster in reply to jeeves19

I am approximately 5 days per week. As with everything else I am doing, I can't attribute any particular benefit to it, but it is very easy for me to do and I'm not aware of any detriments. Even before my diagnosis, I was rarely hungry and rarely full.

jeeves19 profile image
jeeves19

Thanks and you’re lucky not to be hungry!

bassofspades profile image
bassofspades

Im glad this topic is still going. Ive been intermittent fasting for most of a week {cheated Friday } and have been enjoying good results. I haven't taken any meds or supplements in 9 hours and haven't had the slightest tremor . I fasted 22 hours today and 21 yesterday. Coffee is ok and water when fasting. I was a little unsteady in the morning.

The reason I think this works is that it lets autophagy occur, and to me, that means your body is disposing of the tangled misfolded proteins that choke our dopaminergic neurons . I predict studies will come out as this trend in intermittent fasting gains popularity.

jimcaster profile image
jimcaster in reply to bassofspades

I hope you are right!

in reply to bassofspades

Congratulations. By coffee okay do you mean no milk and sugar?

bassofspades profile image
bassofspades in reply to

the way I drink my coffee is with 2 spoonfuls of coconut oil, a bit of heavy cream and a spoonful of mannitol.

Coconut oil is MCT (medium chain triglyceride) and is supposed to be OK. Anecdotally, it awesome for your health but I cant prove that. Ive been ingesting the stuff for years and I have PD anyway!

Heavy cream has no lactose, no sugar, so technically it shouldnt cause an insulin reaction in your bloodstream.

As for Mannitol, again, anecdotally, its good for PWP, but I cant prove this either. ive seen fruit flies do great on the stuff in videos. Because mannitol is only partially absorbed by the body, it significantly reduces the rise in blood glucose and insulin levels that occur following the ingestion of glucose.

Disclaimer - Im not officially a dietitian, though I often talk like I am!

You may also like...

Intermittent Fasting 16/8 DOESN'T WORK For Humans

rodents they based 16/8 intermittent fasting on have metabolisms 16 times faster than ours. Watch...

Intermittent fasting

Intermittent fasting protects nigral dopaminergic neurons– Fasting every other day vs weekly...

DBS doesn't seem to work?

feeling any better. I can say, My tremors and distonia on presurgery status, taking much more...

Why Many People Are Abandoning Intermittent Fasting

that some YouTubers are turning against intermittent fasting on the Zoom call today. This video is

How Much Carbidopa Levodopa After 5-10 Years? Any other meds?

9:00 a.m., noon, 3:00 p.m., 6:00 p.m., and 9:00 p.m. although timing varies slightly from day to...