For my dad: I took my father to the... - Cure Parkinson's

Cure Parkinson's

25,345 members26,645 posts

For my dad

38 Replies

I took my father to the nurologist today and the doctor switched his medication from Stalevo to Madapar. I hope it works better for him. Any views on this ?

Read more about...
38 Replies
Joynb profile image
Joynb

Change over slowly,one pill at a time, changing one more after a few days or even a week. Rapid change can be very unpleasant.

in reply to Joynb

Thanks but how? He used to take three stalevo tablets before so how can he switch to madapar now? Should he take one tablet madapar and then increase his dose? How do you mean one tablet?

Joynb profile image
Joynb in reply to

Step 1: substitute Madopar for Stalevo first thing in the morning, take Stalevo the rest of the day. Do this for at least three days, more of there are any reactionssubstitute

Step 2: continue taking Madopar first thing in the morning and substitute Madopar for Stalevo at the second dose of the day. Again, do this for at least three days, more of there are any reactions

Step 3: continue taking Madopar first and second dose, substitute Madopar for Stalevo at the third dose of the day.

step 4: proceed in the same way for any further doses

All changed, with least risk of reactions

in reply to Joynb

Thank you so much for this..thank you will do so, thank you

shelly9 profile image
shelly9

What was the reason your doctor gave for making the switch ? What strength Stalevo is he taking ?

in reply to shelly9

my father was taking stalevo 50 mg with carbidopa 12.5 and 200mg entakapone,..he was taking these 3 times a day...now just yesterday the doctor switched him to madapar...but ı am scared of making such a sudden switch? also the doctor said he should 'chew' madapor but ı am reading the leaflet and it says it should be swallowed? ı am confused now....the reason the doctor switched was because my father feels tired all day and falls asleep often and also his walking has göne worse :(

park_bear profile image
park_bear in reply to

Does he have the typical Parkinson's resting tremor of hand / arm on one side?

How is his walking affected?

in reply to park_bear

No he does not have tremor. But his walking is bad he is very slow and his arms dont move when he walks and his steps are very little..his posture is forward bent :( i realised however since he took stalevo his walking has gone worse he doesnt lift his feet when he walks :(

park_bear profile image
park_bear in reply to

Does one foot move more easily than the other?

These symptoms you have set forth might or might not be PD. I know 2 neurologists say he has it but the lack of response to stalevo is a negative indication.

in reply to park_bear

Yes his left foot moves more easily than his right foot. His right side seems to be slower. I am really sad to see him not lifting his feet when he walks..sometimes since he doesnt lift his feet when he walks I get scared he may stimble. He can eat drink shave and do other things with his own hands he doesnt have tremor but he is slow in walking..his speech his voice has gone softer too so i ask him to speak up when he talks:(

in reply to park_bear

His dose of levadopa was three times 50 mg..since we saw no improvement the doc raised his dose and switched him from stalevo to madapar three times daily

in reply to

At least 15% of patients with a diagnosis of Parkinson's disease in the population do not fulfil strict clinical criteria for the disease, and approximately 20% of patients with Parkinson's disease who have already come to medical attention have not been diagnosed as such.

jnnp.bmj.com/content/73/5/529

in reply to

The doc said im future dementia may follow with parkinson ...i really dont know...i asked the doc if he was sure of the diagnosis of PD with my father and he said that the clinical tests say so..

I really dont know..i dont know how the dose increase and med switch will work...the doc also said "try one day without any meds and you will see he will be worse off" :(.

in reply to

The future may not "may follow with parkinson ..." Surely we must take responsibility for selecting the treatment, diet, supplement choices, etc. It is totally evident from reading others experience herein with opinionated doctors, incorrect dx and meds as well as 'closed mindedness' from docs regarding alternative treatment will lead many of us to the future dark recesses of Parkinson's.

in reply to

Yes I agree with you totally..I just wish my I could talk to my doc like I can with you all in here but whenever I ask him something he gets so offended and says 'dont you trust me? This is beyond rudeness' bla bla and to be frank I get really upset with his attitute but he is the only well renown movement disorder specialist nurologist here :( thank you so much

he was taking stalevo with 50 mg levadopa, 12.5 carbidopa, and 200 mg entakapone

shelly9 profile image
shelly9

I am in the process of moving from Sinemet to Stavelo. I suggest you find patients who actually made the switch. My research did not find any who did. My doctor said Medapar was very similar Sinemet.

in reply to shelly9

every med Works differently to each individual I guess...were you happy with sinemet?

shelly9 profile image
shelly9 in reply to

Sinemet works for me but Stavelo might be better by lasting longer.

The entacapone in Stalevo (or its generic equivalent) is there to help ameliorate the medication off periods.

in reply to

yes but stalevo didnt work well for my dad. he took it for 3 months but no sign of improvement infact hes göne worse

in reply to

It may be that your Dad is not reacting to levodopa because his diagnosis of PD was not correct. MSA or PSP are other possibilities.

in reply to

But they had an MR scan done

Greenday profile image
Greenday in reply to

It is extremely hard for MRI to detect the atrophies caused by MSA, PSP or other parkinsonian syndromes and differentiate from PD, especially at the early stages of the disease and most specialists have not the expertise or tools required to analyze those scans anyway.

in reply to Greenday

what does msa and psp stand for ?

Greenday profile image
Greenday in reply to

Regarding MSA I thoroughly explained in your former post. healthunlocked.com/parkinso...

MSA:

emedicine.medscape.com/arti...

PSP:

emedicine.medscape.com/arti...

Both syndromes often have low response to levodopa

in reply to Greenday

thank you so much for this

in reply to Greenday

Thank you so much

in reply to Greenday

I had three neurologists say that my father was Parkinson...but ı dont know

Greenday profile image
Greenday in reply to

I personally better trust the machines than the doctors. PET and SPECT scans can differentiate parkinsons from syndromes. Did you visit a movement disorder specialist with expertise in PD? Maybe eventually it is all about the correct medicines, dosage and doctor. If you father won't see any improvement then other possibilities may exist. Also an exercise routine is equally important, you should not depend only on drugs.

in reply to Greenday

yes the neurolgist is a specialist in movement disorder...ı wonder if madapar will work for him but ı dont know how should chew this tablet

ı dont know how to switch. the doc said just leave the stalevo and give him three tablets of madapar...but ı am worried

Greenday profile image
Greenday in reply to

Both Stalevo & Madopar? I'm not sure anyone in this forum take both of this combination... Maybe your doctor wants to test his response to madopar first before switching?

in reply to Greenday

No not the combination, the doctor had prescribed stalevo, which my dad took for 3 months..now the doc is switching from stalevo to madapar...

in reply to

the doctor said my dad should 'chew' madapar and then drink water..but is that a tablet to chew??

Greenday profile image
Greenday in reply to

chewable madopar??? Does your dad have swallowing difficulties? Ask your doctor why you dad needs to chew it instead of swallowing which is the recommended way.

in reply to Greenday

I really dont know :( the more questions ı ask him he gets annoyed

park_bear profile image
park_bear in reply to

Consider changing docs if you can. Not good if you can't ask regarding medication instructions.

You may also like...

Please help my dad

life anymore and cannot walk. His medication Prolopa is not really working anymore and he is...

My dad is tired for most of the day. any suggestions?

we ran to get his wheelchair. Since he has switched to mucuna he has never touched his wheelchair.

What is the safest and most effective CBD protocol for moderate PD? My Dad takes sinement and is reaching his bodies tolerance (sadly).

Proud Parkie Dad

Our Dad's Decision to Try NUPLAZID & How We Are Going to Pay for This Expensive Medicine

impacts on him and his family. The most serious problems involve Mom, who also wants to keep him...