NRAS answer to my question about remission. - NRAS

NRAS

36,427 members45,077 posts

NRAS answer to my question about remission.

cathie profile image
11 Replies

They're agreed that I can put the whole answer on the forum. I hope noone will be in my position in future, but this may be helpful should that be the case. What a brilliant organisation is NRAS, and they work very intelligently with other organisations. Sorry about the formatting, I've tried to make it easier to read though.

?Dear Cathie,

Thank you for your email. I will work through the answers to your questions below in what I hope will be a logical order:

3. What research is there on remission other than what I’ve referred to above

You mentioned in your email that the study you had found suggested that there is little evidence for ‘real remission’. I think that this is because there are differences between full remission, where a disease has completely gone and clinical remission (also called ‘drug-induced’ remission), where the disease effectively lies dormant and shows very low disease activity. RA falls under the latter of these, as the disease is not curable, but can go through periods of remission. Remission can also be measured in different ways, though a common measure is DAS of below 2.6.

Some of the research evidence on remission is outlines in the NICE guidelines for RA,along with recommendations. I know that the NICE guidelines do not cover Scotland, but they are generally recognised in terms of giving valid information and advice on the treatment of RA, so it may be useful to understand some of what they suggest with regards to remission:

On page 6 (slide 18) of the NICE guidelines for RA, they suggest that:

“Where the guidelines refer to sustained disease control, this suggests a minimum of six months of remission or minimal disease activity.”

nice.org.uk/nicemedia/live/...

This implies that treatment should only be stopped if you have been in remission for at least 6 monthsOn page 134 (slide 141) you can see the results of studies looking at remission, as well as the

recommendations that came out of this

RECOMMENDATIONS

R19 In people with established RA whose disease is stable, cautiously reduce dosages of

diseasemodifying or biological drugs. Return promptly to disease-controlling dosages at the

first sign of a flare

R20 When introducing new drugs to improve disease control into the treatment regimen of a person with established RA, consider decreasing or stopping their pre-existing rheumatological drugs once the disease is controlled.

R21 In any person with established rheumatoid arthritis in whom disease-modifying or

biological drug doses are being decreased or stopped, arrangements should be in place for

prompt review. As you can see, they recommend making this change gradually, and highlight the importance that something is put into place so that at the first signs of the RA symptoms returning you can get onto disease modifying medication again.

The SIGN document on management of early RA (which covers Scotland) goes into less detail, but also suggests slow withdrawal of treatment when in remission (page 11, slide 17):

“Where parallel or step-down strategies are employed, DMARDs should be carefully and

slowly withdrawn in patients who are in remission.”

sign.ac.uk/pdf/sign123.pdf

My next consultant appointment is in mid-April. My last infliximab infusion is 15th November.

I think I need a new appointment with her in order to get a more considered opinion before the next due date for my infliximab, which would be mid-Jan. How can I do this if she ignores letters from my GP?I think that if you and your GP have tried to arrange for you to see her before this date and have not had any response you might want to consider making a formal complaint in order to get this resolved.

If the GP has written, but you have not tried to call the hospital to arrange an appointment it would be worth doing this first. The following web page gives information on how to go about complaining about your healthcare:

nhsnss.org/pages/contact/fe...

5. What recourse do I have if treatment is withdrawn?

As per the above, there is a complaints procedure that you can follow. However, if they are looking to withdraw the drugs and you feel that they should be tapered down more gradually I think it would probably be better to seek a 2nd opinion before it gets to this stage (you can ask your GP to arrange this), and to potentially change to a different consultant should the 2nd consultant have an approach that you are more comfortable with

2. Several people on Healthunlocked think that this could be a short sighted cost cutting measure.

Do you have any information on this? The health authority is Lothian. Could it be related to my age? I’m fast approaching 66 and am retired.I do not think that this would have anything to do with your age. Cost may be a part of the issue, but this should only be weighed against the benefit to your health. Biologic drugs are expensive drugs,and they are also powerful drugs, so for both of these reasons it would make sense not to keep you on them unnecessarily. However, they should not be taking you off of them purely to save money if there is good evidence to suggest that you need them in order to keep your condition under control.

4. What evidence is there about the dangers that I might not respond to future biological

treatments?We could not find a huge amount of information on this, but the studies we did find are outlined below. We looked for studies showing people coming off of infliximab and whether they successfully stayed in remission. We also found one study showing whether or not the infliximab was as successful a second time round if they had to go back onto it. I don’t think there would be any study showing whether or not they would respond as well to ‘future biologic treatments’ as you would need to have been on the drug already to know how well you would have responded to it pre-remission. Here are the details of the studies we found

1. In this study, the majority of patients with stable low DAS28 and stable treatment were

able to lower or discontinue infliximab, resulting in a considerable reduction in costs

without influencing their quality of life: ard.bmj.com/content/71/11/1...

2. About 55% of the 102 patients on this study with infliximab and MTX treatment, could

discontinue infliximab for more than 1 year without progression of radiological articular destruction or functional disturbance: ard.bmj.com/content/69/7/12...

3. Reintroducing infliximab: On re-establishing therapy, the ACR response on infliximab

was comparable in 12/14 patients and worse in only two. No adverse reactions were

observed: rheumatology.oxfordjournals...

6. How do we live with a condition that's basically incurable, with such unsympathetic doctors who engage in a guessing game with us. If we have pain, then the treatment isnt working and should be withdrawn. If we say no pain then we're in 'remission' and treatment should be withdrawn.I assume that this last question is largely rhetorical, but an understandable frustration. I suppose the answer, of there is one, is that large decisions like this should not be made on one, single factor, so lack of pain on its own for example would not mean that you were in remission, and they would need to look at a variety of factors before remission was determined (such as measuring your DAS).

Finally, you mention in your email that lupus has been considered as a diagnosis but that you haven’t been given any information on test results for this. I agree that you should be able to see these results, so it might be worth chasing this up if you are going through the above complaints procedure anyway. It might also be worth reading about the diagnosis/symptoms etc of lupus to see if you think they match with your situation:

arthritisresearchuk.org/art...

I hope that this helps to answer your queries, but please feel free to contact us again if any of the above is unclear.

Kind regards

Victoria

Victoria Butler

Helpline & Information Coordinator

NRAS

Written by
cathie profile image
cathie
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
11 Replies

Looks like you've got the official back-up you need, Cathie. Hope that this knowledge of the guidelines means that you get more of a dialogue, a second opinion & time to decide what you want to do. Good luck,

Christina xx

cathie profile image
cathie

Thanks. NRAS are the bees knees for me today!

earthwitch profile image
earthwitch

Really interesting. I think it seems obvious that if you are required to try a withdrawal, it must be slow, and you must be monitored very closely over the period you are withdrawing. With the difficulties you are having getting the rheumatologist to respond to GP, then I think you could argue quite strongly that the mechanism is not in place to support a successful withdrawal of your meds, therefore as long as they are not causing you adverse effects you could argue to stay on them until you can be very sure you will get prompt and regular follow up.

Coulson profile image
Coulson

I previously mentioned that I had not taken Methotrexate for 3yrs in December. I did not mention that the drug was reduced over a period of time and I was monitored as usual at the hospital and I also still had appointments with my Consultant. I was only discharged after being off the drug for a while.

cathie profile image
cathie

I think that the slow gradual withdrawal is crucial isnt it. Just as they were introduced gradually. This has all been really helpful, I hope it is/may be for others.

Victoria-NRAS profile image
Victoria-NRASPartnerModeratorNRAS

Hi Cathie

Really pleased we could help, and thank you for your kind comments. If anyone on here ever has any questions that they feel our helpline might be able to answer, please feel free to contact us:

email: helpline@nras.org.uk

Telephone (Mon-Fri 9.30-4.30): 0800 298 7650

Glad you found the information useful.

Kind regards

Victoria

(NRAS Helpline)

cathie profile image
cathie

It was so reassuring to have your reply - so quickly Victoria too.

I'll be sure to share information about what happens - once there's enough to report.

Best,

Cathie

Hi Cathie, just wanted to show some support, must be a worry for you,really hope you get this sorted but after that fantastic advice I'm sure all will be well even if you do have to stamp your feet a bit! :)

cathie profile image
cathie

Thankyou. I dont think its the system here which is at fault but a young cinsultant a bit too keen to be taking action and more bound up in academic research than thinking if her impact on real people. The struggle continues!

Well done for doing your research and starting with NRAS Cathie. They have been brilliant for me too in the recent past, giving balanced, impartial and generally very intelligent advice and I'm so glad this has been the case for you too. It does sound to me as if this rheumy you saw was far too keen to experiment on you without anything approaching adequate back up plans in place. I hope and feel sure experience and the moral highground will win over youthful and misplaced zeal! Tilda xxxx

cathie profile image
cathie

You're spot on. That's the down side of going to a unit where they are doing research and seeing patients. Interestingly the previous big run in I had was with a similar young tunnel vision person. That was the occasion when I made a private appointment with my main consultant who put me back on the tracks I am at present. Five or six years relatively pain free.

As for the NRAS I will be sure to support anything they do and will be stocking up on xmas cards and any other things like that. XX

PS. Tilda, I hope you're well and that the Tuscan sunshine is doing you good.

You may also like...

Who does NRAS reach? That is the question we want to know the answer to! 📋🤔💭

our first ever NRAS Census we are reaching out to you, our community in as many ways as possible to...

My wife is officially in remission

stick. Your doctors will tell you that diet and lifestyle will have no impact on your disease. They...

DAS At last a web site to answer my question

I came across this site http://www.4s-dawn.com/DAS28/DAS28.html and it explains what my DAS score...

Talking to NRAS about diet

initially in conjunction with drugs, but for many without drugs. I would like to talk to NRAS...

Remission

scanned, can you be said to be in remission? Also, can you evidence synovitis in one part of your...