Eating below recommended calories - Weight Loss Support

Weight Loss Support

114,595 members60,924 posts

Eating below recommended calories

essex2067 profile image
6 Replies

I've seen lots of posts discussing the above and recommending people don't eat less because their body will go into starvation mode, they'll find it difficult to maintain once they have lost weight etc. My question is has anyone been successful when eating well under, and if so how much under were they?

Written by
essex2067 profile image
essex2067
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
6 Replies
Jessie92 profile image
Jessie92

Hello, yes thats how I lost my 6st in weight my calorie intake rarely went over 1000 cals a day. It took me 18 months and now I only have a stone a lose and im really sturuggling because I cannot cut my calorie intake or I wont function and im doing intense 2 hrs exersices sessions 4 times a week. But im not putting any on, but not loosing like I would like either. So in all fairness I wouldnt recommend it, I wish I would of found the nhs 12 week plan before I started and I could have done it properly!

Good Luck :)

Nrfore profile image
Nrfore in reply to Jessie92

Hi Jessie92, what is the nhs 12 week program? Thanks in advance!

Zest profile image
ZestHealthy BMI in reply to Nrfore

Hi Nrfore,

Here is a link to the NHS 12 week plan:

nhs.uk/Livewell/weight-loss...

Lowcal :-)

Nrfore profile image
Nrfore in reply to Zest

Thank you so much!

Zest profile image
ZestHealthy BMI

Hi Essex2067,

I know you've seen lots of posts discussing the issue of calorie totals etc, but I thought this thread might be helpful - particularly the comment towards the end by someone who was at that time a 'Volunteer' (although the name of the person is 'hidden' as they must have left the site subsequently. The points they made seemed quite helpful, I thought.

Particularly important was the comment that Very Low Calorie Diets shouldn't be attempted unless under Medical Supervision.

Also, you might find it interesting to look at past posts by Gingernut49, as she used the 5:2 diet, and therefore often had fasting days in her week where she only ate 500 calories on those 2 days, but people eat more on the other days.

I can't specifically respond to your actual question from my own personal experience, as I have usually eaten quite a few calories daily - i.e. tending to eat towards the upper end of the recommended window of calories rather than the lower.

Here's the thread I saw which also discusses the issue you are raising:

healthunlocked.com/nhsweigh...

Hope you have a great week.

Lowcal :-)

Venusflytrap profile image
Venusflytrap

I don't know if it helps but I have always lost fastest if I can just hit the recommended daily and weekly totals. Something about being just on the right side of the total, seems to help me best. If I go too low, I can't necessarily keep it up without being hungry and therefore tempted by those foods that don't help! I also lose my ability to eat portion sizes and start sneaking extras. Of course you might not be such a hungry person as I am.

You may also like...

Can eating less than your recommended calorie intake daily, stall weight loss?

Have lost 10 pounds in 9 weeks. Want to loose 2lb instead of always 1lb so tried to be clever an...

Help to eat the right amount of Calories for successful weight loss, once and for all?

encouraging and invaluable here. My question please is... I currently weight 18 Stone 5 pounds...

Are all calories the same?

I have been under my recommended calorie intake, however not weighing food and portion control...

IF vs. Calorie counting

creates weight loss and as long as you are technically eating in a deficit you will lose weight. Is...

Calorie counting or low fat?

to do when my eating issues were bad and I don't want to trigger a relapse. Does eating low fat...