Has any one specially a diabetic ever tried... - Diabetes India

Diabetes India

61,842 members12,095 posts

Has any one specially a diabetic ever tried to consciously smell his own urine over a period of time ? Have they noticed any change ?

patliputra profile image
17 Replies

It may appear to be a funny question ,but it may provide information regarding your blood sugar control . In ancient times urine was used as a diagnostic tool for diabetes.

Written by
patliputra profile image
patliputra
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
17 Replies
nataraj28 profile image
nataraj28

It is not sure and not proved

patliputra profile image
patliputra in reply to nataraj28

We are just trying to learn .

pnglr profile image
pnglr

As per my knowledge if there is too much glucose in blood (>200) then there will be some glucose excreted through urine. Even that will be less (just 1-2%) and glucose doesn't have any smell. So I think once can't use smell for diagnosis.

patliputra profile image
patliputra in reply to pnglr

You are absolutely right. We have got accurate and simple tools for making a diagnosis of diabetes. In old days doctors used to taste urine for sweetness to diagnose diabetes.

Normally we do not consciously smell own urine,but every body is aware of smell of urine. So if there is change in smell of urine which is persisting over a period of time ,does it signify some thing ? Does the smell changes if blood sugar remains persistently high ? Returning to normal smell if bs is within normal limits ?

chonmani profile image
chonmani in reply to patliputra

डॉ या वैद्य चखते नही थे।पेशाब किये गए स्थान पर अगर चींटी इकट्ठी होती थी तब मधुमेह मान लिया जाता था।

patliputra profile image
patliputra in reply to chonmani

You will be amazed that many doctors actually tasted urine to determine the sweetness.

chonmani profile image
chonmani in reply to patliputra

I am also.there is nothing like that in medical science.

patliputra profile image
patliputra in reply to chonmani

doctors review.com/history/sep05_history

defeat diabetes.org/diabetes-history

io9.com/.../flavor-wheels-helped-doctors-diagnose-patients-pee

Please visit above mentioned web site for confirmation of what I said about tasting of urine.

in reply to chonmani

Yes, this is by far the best test. When urine dries up , sugar crystal can be seen attracting ants. Even the change of spot for urination will repeatedly reveal the same history

patliputra profile image
patliputra in reply to

Very true. But what about odour,any observation ?

prava71 profile image
prava71

TO me this question is not at all funny!!! In the Olden days chines used to check the Urine by placing it near the Ant Hills and check if Ants are coming to Urine they used to say that sugar levels are high.

now some time i also used to feel when passing the urine, sugar levels might be high or low depending on the smell. but i don;t know whether this is correct. but the results are correlating with accu-check results on high or low basis.

patliputra profile image
patliputra in reply to prava71

There appears to be no study conducted,so let us share our experiences . That way may be some thing comes out of it.

himatbhai profile image
himatbhai

Yes, the smell is different than normal urine. we can judge if the sugar level is increased surely from smell.

patliputra profile image
patliputra in reply to himatbhai

But you need to be very perceptive and observent .

Yes,in old days if aunts were seen round about in the urine of person fell on ground ,he or she was diagnosed with sugar( called those days). ,but the actual damage would have been already done to the concerned person. due to late diagnosing.Sugar equal or more than 180mg/dl.is extracted in urine through kidneys.,

One of Ayurveda ( Vaid) called those days used to drink his own urine in our locality.

patliputra profile image
patliputra in reply to

Yes, even today ,if ants are attracted to the urine , people get alerted for diabetes .

patliputra profile image
patliputra in reply to

What is your take on relationship between changing blood sugar levels and change in odour of urine.

You may also like...

Diabetic while driving car

over the internet diabetic should avoid driving as it may lead to hypo. Need your suggestion.

EXTREME LOW CARB DIET

link and view the article on the above subject.It may be interesting....

high sugar and triglyceride

is diabetic and also has high triglycerides, is it safe to do the LCHF diet? It may control sugar,...

methi powder ( Fenugreek ) cinnomon ( Dalchinni ) and turmeric powder

is daily mostly used in homes also I think it may not to harm a or any side effect may notif...

Study says dairy fat could lower risk of diabetes

risk of diabetes or that whey protein could have some effect on diabetes development, but May said...