How do I know if I really have asthma... - Lung Conditions C...

Lung Conditions Community Forum

55,057 members65,846 posts

How do I know if I really have asthma...

Osame profile image
11 Replies

My GP diagnosed me with Asthma 6 years ago after 3 chest infections. Currently I’m on sertetide, my question is how do I know for sure that I have asthma? I don’t wheeze nor have I ever done so. If it a very windy day I feel that breathing isn’t as easy as it should be, ventolin makes no difference at such times. I was a smoker for 40 years non smoker for 8, spirometry tests showed large lungs with normal results. My main complaint is constant throat clearing with elastic type mucus at the back of my throat, When I cough up mucus it always feels as though it comes from my throat not my chest. Could seretide cause excess mucus in my throat? Or do my symptoms sound more like post nasal drip?

Written by
Osame profile image
Osame
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
11 Replies
Shancock profile image
Shancock

Post nasal drip causes throat clearing and excess mucus. To really diagnose asthma you should have a lung function test. You should speak to your GP about one and an MRI of the sinuses which can determines PND and/or chronic sinus.

Shancock profile image
Shancock

Also, nasal drip and sinusitis can cause chest infections, the mucus drips into the lungs. You may need treatment for that rather than asthma. GP shouldn't guess, asthma should always be diagnosed via the correct tests.

Osame profile image
Osame in reply to Shancock

Many thanks for your reply

O2Trees profile image
O2Trees

A possibility is silent reflux Osame - the mucus you describe is exactly what silent reflux produces, kind of gluey and coming from the throat. Post nasal drip is part of that too. Talk to your doctor about that. And reflux can cause asthma like symptoms too.

Osame profile image
Osame in reply to O2Trees

Thank you for your reply it gives me something to go back to the doc with.

JollyRancher11 profile image
JollyRancher11

My new Pulmonologist did a ImmunoCap lab test and a Methacholine Challange with the PFT, both were negative for Asthma but he still wants to treat me for it based on symptoms. I suppose those are two of the usual test based on my experience. It's best to see a lung specialist, I asked my GP for a referral...

Osame profile image
Osame

Thank you

Izb1 profile image
Izb1

Hi Osame my doctor treated me for asthma for over ten years, even though I told her I didnt think it was asthma, the sprays made me worse. It was when we have a new doctor for a little while who listened and sent me for ct scan that showed it was bronchiectasis. Ask your doctor to refer you, they are so often wrong. This is a great site for info x

Osame profile image
Osame

Thank you I will do just that. The more I read on this site the more I question my diagnosis, I’m going to ask for a second opinion.

Aim71 profile image
Aim71

I've been on seretide for about 6 months and started to have the same throat mucous problem. My wife, who's a chronic asthmatic, said to use a spacer rather than taking the seretide direct. Been using the spacer for a week and I can't believe the difference - sooo much better. And my asthma has improved too - I think the constant throat clearing was making it worse.

Osame profile image
Osame in reply to Aim71

Hi I was taking my seretide through the spacer. I agree with you the constant throat clearing does seem to make it all worse. Since writing my original post, I took myself off all inhalers after about 2 months it became obvious that I do have cough variant asthma. So now on qvar not as strong as seretide I think. As for the constant throat clearing I’m booked in for a gastroscope at the end of the month.

You may also like...

How do you know when your ventolin is used up?

running out. I rarely had to use my ventolin - mostly when developing a chest infection. Now i need...

Do natural products really work?

milk which is supposed to aid asthma sufferers whilst strengthening lungs! I am all for natural...

Oxygen in hospital- how do you know its on?

and potassium sometimes when we visit, has the nasal oxygen tube that is attached to wall at all...

Anyone else have Eosinophilic Asthma with chronic rhinosinusitis?

with mild asthma this was after being taken to hospital as could not breathe and blue ventolin did...

pleurisy do you think I have this and if so what should I do?

you know what I mean and I feel like I want to cough up phlegm. I’ve been like this for 2 days. I...