Crackles! Now you hear me now you don't! - Lung Conditions C...

Lung Conditions Community Forum

55,051 members65,842 posts

Crackles! Now you hear me now you don't!

GeorginaS profile image
37 Replies

I think my lung crackles are playing hide and seek! Consultant says crackles, doctor says no crackles! Within a few days of each other! This has happened three times recently.

Am I more weird than I think I am already? 😕

Written by
GeorginaS profile image
GeorginaS
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
37 Replies

Yes they're funny blighters those crackles. I have bronchiectasis and was acting as the 'patient' for doctors taking an exam to be consultants. Half of them could hear crackles and half couldn't and most diagnosed me as COPD!

GeorginaS profile image
GeorginaS in reply to

If it wasn't so serious it would be funny! Doesn't give you confidence for the future of respiratory medicine though does it x

Badbessie profile image
Badbessie

Depending on your state of hydration and a few other reasons you can gain or loose your crackles. A lot depends on where the damage to your lungs is. Even having some slight pulmonary oedema can cause crackles.

GeorginaS profile image
GeorginaS in reply to Badbessie

Thank you for your reply. Really appreciated.

I believe the damage is at the base of my lungs.

Can I lose crackles by keeping well hydrated? x

Badbessie profile image
Badbessie in reply to GeorginaS

Sometimes a small amount of fluid can build up in your lungs and you can get crackles. You move around and the fluid can move too and your crackles go! It can be just a matter of you going to sleep for a while. Keeping well hydrated is always a good idea.

GeorginaS profile image
GeorginaS in reply to Badbessie

Thank you again. I'm finding my lungs now feel dry when I'm in bed. Note I didn't say sleep as I'm getting so little. Before I could cough stuff up a bit but now it's all dried up! No idea if that's good or not 😕 x

Katinka46 profile image
Katinka46

Crackles are tricky. And come in different forms and can be indicative of different diseases. Some GPs are brilliant at the other end of a stethoscope and some consultants can be less so, and vice versa. I did a silly cartoon about crackles a few weeks ago. Scroll down in my posts for a little light relief.

You are not weird, I think all of us here have had differing diagnoses and comments. My consultant in a letter to a professor at the Royal Brompton Hospital mentioned that there had had contradictory ideas about my condition "which has not helped things". I am hoping that the professor can read between the lines and see that there has been a right royal cock-up.

All the best

k

GeorginaS profile image
GeorginaS in reply to Katinka46

Love the 'right royal cock-up' statement. 😀 I'll look for your cartoon.

I'm currently at the Royal Berkshire Hospital and I believe there's an ILD centre in Oxford. Maybe if I move on I'll get a 'nicer' diagnosis 😜

Do you know what you have or could possibly have?

It's very difficult when you feel so vulnerable to also have to cope with conflicting views.

Thanks for getting back to me and your crackle observations x

mrsmummy profile image
mrsmummy in reply to GeorginaS

healthunlocked.com/blf/post......

GeorginaS profile image
GeorginaS in reply to mrsmummy

Thank you x

Caspiana profile image
Caspiana in reply to Katinka46

Is this the cartoon with the box of cereal?? I love that one. xx 💜

Katinka46 profile image
Katinka46 in reply to Caspiana

Yup. I sent it to my LLC who wrote back that he'd forwarded it all his respiratory colleagues "who were highly entertained."

Kxx

Caspiana profile image
Caspiana in reply to Katinka46

Hahahahaha. 😅

GeorginaS profile image
GeorginaS in reply to Katinka46

Loved the drawing by the way 😀x

Poohpoohmad profile image
Poohpoohmad

Same here, depends on Day, time and how l stand strangely!

Ccupcakes profile image
Ccupcakes

Good morning GeorginaS,

Do have look at Katinkas cartoon, I showed it to my LLC and he roared!

Crackles are very odd aren't they? My Rheumy hears them, a locum GP didn't, my GP does, the nurse practitioner and respiratory nurses didn't and my LLC does???? They come and go I think depending on what numbskulls are playing ring o roses in there!

Xxxxx😆😆😆

Ccupcakes profile image
Ccupcakes in reply to Ccupcakes

Seriously tho, I can't say I've noticed a difference in them if I'm well hydrated, I do think it depends on who is on the other end of the Stethoscope and how experienced/ open minded they are, if they don't expect to hear crackles then they won't, like you the damage in my lungs is lower on the left and lower and mid section on the right, and I can hear the crackles myself when I lay on my right side especially if I feel very SOB or wheezy, sometimes it sounds like a herd of hungry hamsters munching on crisps! Other times a sort of squeak a bit like a seagulls cry.

Thankfully the hamsters have been on vacation for the last few weeks! Haven't heard them!

I think by now you know you definitely aren't weird!

Ccxx

GeorginaS profile image
GeorginaS in reply to Ccupcakes

Love the herd of hungry hamsters concept! Hope they stay away for a long time m.

My doctors has heard them and then he doesn't. Same with the consultant, hears them then not.

I think the jury is still out on my weird status and nothing to do with my lungs 😜

Hope your weekend goes well x

Caspiana profile image
Caspiana in reply to Ccupcakes

The hamster comment left me roaring Ccupcakes . xx 💜

GeorginaS profile image
GeorginaS in reply to Ccupcakes

Apparently mine should sound like Velcro being no ripped apart. I heard they were or had made recordings to help GPs identify what's what x

MoyB profile image
MoyB

Does someone need a new stethoscope?

Ccupcakes profile image
Ccupcakes in reply to MoyB

Maybe!!

GeorginaS profile image
GeorginaS in reply to Ccupcakes

🤣

GeorginaS profile image
GeorginaS in reply to MoyB

🤣

Ccupcakes profile image
Ccupcakes in reply to GeorginaS

Did you look at the link Mrs m posted? If you scroll down through it and click on the link stone_uk posted it tells you all sorts about crackles, might need to wait till you've finished laughing at Katinkas picture tho!

Glad my hamsters made you laugh Caspiana, how are you and Chom doing? Is your rainy season nearly over?

Big hugs Cas xxx

GeorginaS profile image
GeorginaS in reply to Ccupcakes

Going to look now x

Badbessie profile image
Badbessie in reply to MoyB

I have my own, it's a littmann. The ability to detect sounds can be affected by the quality of the stethoscope used. A nursing stethoscope is fine for blood pressures etc but when listening to the chest/lungs your ability to detect subtle sounds may be hampered if you use cheap equipment. I can tell the difference between mine and the one I brought my daughter to practice reading blood pressures.

GeorginaS profile image
GeorginaS in reply to Badbessie

That sounds like an interesting idea. I'm new to all of this and sort-of living in denial land at the moment and trying to avoid thinking too much. I'd end up being the crackles police!

I do reckon your right about cheap equipment though. The operator too must have died nothing to do with it.

Thanks for the information about the type of stethoscope x

Ccupcakes profile image
Ccupcakes in reply to Badbessie

Didn't know that Badbessie, thought they were all the same, might explain quite a lot tho, thank you xx

Any tips for the hamsters?? ???

Badbessie profile image
Badbessie in reply to Ccupcakes

lol In all years never actually came across hungry hamster syndrome! Perhaps research is needed to pin down the cause.

Badbessie profile image
Badbessie in reply to Ccupcakes

Plus some people have better hearing than others.

Ccupcakes profile image
Ccupcakes in reply to Badbessie

I'm actually quite deaf, hearing aids both ears, so I can sort of feel / hear them, on bad days they are there all the time , on good days I just have squeaks, it scared me at first but now, well obviously I've learned to laugh, they aren't going away for long so hey, just a part of my newish life living with lung disease, we either laugh or go mad crying.

Stones link was useful tho. Xxxxc

Badbessie profile image
Badbessie in reply to Ccupcakes

Diagnosed at Christmas so still pretty new to Copd. Lol I was slightly mad before diagnosis so not a lot of change for me...lol. I know what you mean about feeling them it is a bit strange!

perusal profile image
perusal

I have really bad crackling when in bed and of a morning but as day goes on it stops so Dr appointment of morning say yes another chest infection but afternoon appointment no problem probably a virus. The last appointment I had after a really bad week I was told by locum someone had put on computer my Copd was resolved! After over ten years I don't think so. I asked if I could have an xray as my mother died of lung cancer at my age and she said no and that my COPD will be worse therefore the pneumonia and chest infections will be more often. Waste of time going.

GeorginaS profile image
GeorginaS in reply to perusal

Good grief! If I was told what you've been told then refused an X-ray I'd be very upset! Was it at your doctors or the hospital when you were refused? If it was at the hospital, ask the doctor to refer you or the other way round. No one can predict for more chest infections so that is I feel very hurtful and inappropriate. Big hug x

perusal profile image
perusal

it was at GP surgery.I will just carry on but I have had a really bad time with my chest since pneumonia in January so thought with the constant chest infections an x-ray would be appropriate seems not. I am refusing antibiotics now as they make me so ill and cause flare ups of diverticulitis I suppose after ten years it is just getting a lot worse. Just have to keep smiling 😊

GeorginaS profile image
GeorginaS in reply to perusal

Hopefully things will settle. I'm ok on doxycycline but not good on others. It's difficult trying to balance the drugs with other conditions and reactions to drugs too. Like you said, keep smiling. I do know that's very difficult x

You may also like...

Lung crackling

started noticing crackling when breathing a few months ago. I've been to the doctors, she gave me...

Lung crackles

mild lung crackling that sometimes occurs at night for years now but lately i feel like it has...

How to get some sleep?

sleeping . I’ve tried all ways but The wheezing and crackling disturbs me. I am worn out and this...

Let me introduce you to my little friend

Interstitial Lung disease...caused by rheumatoid arthritis

childhood which I think has only disguised what was really going on as every time I complained of...