What do YOU class as having an asthma attack?

Was just sitting here wondering, what do you class as having an asthma attack? To me, is when my home nebs aren't working and I have to go into A&E, not simply getting out of breath and needing to take a few puffs of inhlaher. I have brittle asthma so this may be why I have beceom ignorant to when I am having an 'attack', if that makes sense?

Just interested to know where everybody elses boundaries are!!


21 Replies

  • For me, it's when I'm so out of puff, I can't think or carry on a conversation. Sometimes my shoulders ache too. That's the time I need 5 - 8 puff of salbutamol. Other times it's endless cough to the point where reliever almost doesn't work. Sometimes think it would be easier decision if wheezer then I'd recognise and GP would recognise when need help or not.

  • at the moment when i cant talk properly and i have had 10puffs on my trusty blue.

  • I think there are three types of asthma attack.

    1) being a little breathless and just needing to rest for a while.

    2) not being able to breath properly or having a coughing fit when a bit of blue is needed.

    3) a full blown attack which needs medical attention.

    Anyone got any comments on this?

  • I feel the same as you, when nebs don't work and I need to get help - not sure when else I would consider it am asthma attack, but like you have brittle asthma often with no warning as to when an attack i sgoing to happen rest of the time I have grumbling asthma...always there in the background but don't class this an asthma attack. I could be very wrong though.

  • hmmmm....

    good question... brittle myself too so do get the odd lil ones which i take puffs for when get symptoms but i call them blips! still mention them to cons and asthma nurse like been told to do though.

    basically i suppose i class an attack as when i need medical help, or i am at home managing, just.

    1. when breathless, unable to talk in full sentence, titeness, with/without wheeze

    2. home nebs arent working as per plan

    3. other asthma symptoms set in

    need help simply!

  • As a kid, an attack was when I needed hospital help. I still think thats true, so shed loads of ventolin doesn't count for me. Thats a clue that I might need to see the GP.

    I think it will be different for others, I don't need or have nebs at home so some wouldn't agree with my view of an attack. Also, I suspect that if I was new to asthma, I might think that needing more than the standard ventolin dose was an attack. I guess this is a healthy attitude if you don't have experience with this stuff as things can get nasty quickly.

  • Requiring hospital admission.

    Everything else I class as having symptoms ie: having asthma!

  • Anything that requires me to get extra help other than my nebs. If I need anything other than nebs then I'd class that as an attack.

  • I agree with most people and would say that upping blue and nebbing and pred etc is exacerbating and needing hospital is attack

  • This is interesting as it's something I often think about. I have different levels of asthma, from annoying to life threatening.

    If I become wheezy, tight, breathless, which is relieved reasonably quickly with my inhaler, I don't really think of that as an attack, more so a symptom of living with asthma.

    Annoying covers everything from being tight, wheezy, breathless, basically anything that effects me asthma wise, that inhalers don't relieve, and stops me from doing basic things.

    Then I have the asthma attacks where I'm really struggling but don't feel bad enough to warrant calling an ambulance (if I called an ambulance every time I had one of these attacks, like I'm told that should do, I'd pretty much live in hospital!!).

    Then there are the severe attacks where I need urgent medical attention, which often develop into life threatening attacks.

    I should say, this is how I view my asthma, I don't apply these 'levels' to other people!

  • Think this is an interesting question, and probably the answer does depend on how severe someone's asthma is normally - an 'attack' to someone with mild asthma would usually just be a relatively bad breathless/wheeze episode. This is what I considered to be an attack when I was younger and a mild asthmatic, but since coming on here have realised what an attack can mean for some people so now I qualify that by calling them 'mini-attacks' (my consultant called them 'wheezy episodes' though I did point out there was never much wheezing involved).

    These days - no idea for myself but would probably agree with Dave re different types in general. Whether I have asthma or something else I don't have anything that could be called an attack these days, it's too persistent and yes, varies a little depending on time of day/activity but otherwise breathlessness, cough etc are just there pretty much always, and recent rib soreness lasts too long to be counted as an attack as well. (I do get 'sustained' exarcerbation for days/weeks after doing something idiotic).

  • I agree with Glitterdust. If somebody with milder asthma said they'd had an ""attack"", I wouldn't expect it to mean full-on hospital admission, but that's probably what I'd class as an ""attack"" for myself. Everything else I'd just put down to symptoms of asthma.

  • i would say an attack is when you have to to into hospital for treatment and everything else is just living with asthma!

  • True but for us with milder forms that have never seen the inside of A&E, sitting and coughing fit to burst or rushing for a train and becoming so out of breath once on it, that your companion actually contemplates pulling the cord - that, for me and my asthma nurse agrees, is an asthma attack.

    True that so far (cross fingers) most blue puffs taken is around 10 - 12 and all is well again. So, for those of you with more than mild, yes, its a blip. For those of us, who are basically newbies or new adult-onset, its more than a blip. Deaths from asthma, we read everywhere on the web health sites occur most in 'mild' asthma cos either the person or those around them don't see mild asthma as a big deal.

    Myself, I am hampered by not having a GP in the practice who has knowledge of asthma. That is partly why I come on the boards - to learn from others experiences. That should my asthma worsen and go up a step - I'm at stage four apparently - I might have half an idea of what to expect.

  • Interesting to read about the different levels of asthma. I've had mild asthma since childhood but recently have had daily exacerbations (likely a result of a changing work environment) and visited the asthma clinic to clarify some questions e.g. what to look out for that might lead to an attack. I also asked about the difference between asthma and COPD which is basically a chronic condition where the reliever inhaler has no effect. Many asthmatics can develop COPD, mainly as a result of smoking but also if they've worked with asbestos or other similar senstizers.

    One question I have since reading some of the forum's comments is what is brittle asthma?

  • To me it is when u have accute symptoms that ur normal reliever dose does not improve nor control , resulting in a greater requirement of reliever or further assistance from medical people.... I don't think a and e attendance is necessary for it to b classed as an attack.... Tho if any one has any concerns about their asthma should seek medical attention.

  • Oh dear. Sorry everyone but this is the type of post I find really irritating. An asthma attack is when you need to take reliever medication to control symptoms....in my book. We are all going to have different definitions and given the wide disparity in severity some definitions could actually be very misleading to a newly diagnosed person or those who don't understand that ALL asthmatics can potentially be in a life threatening situation.

    If you are unwell for YOU, if you have symptoms not being resolved by your reliever then seek medical advice please.

  • Well said, Feejay. Thanks.

  • Def well said. I think everyone is different and all of us are different in the way of asthma but we are united in having asthma! If that makes sense?!

  • I think FeeJay is right, but I also think that we should be aware that our asthma is likely to change without notice. For example, I had asthma for about 20 years, and an attack was sudden breathlessness, wheezing etc., which was dealt with by ventolin, peak flow back up to normal no problem. About 10 years ago that all changed and I was having trouble breathing all the time, peak flow was less than 50% of best and then an attack was when I had to sit down on the kitchen floor after I'd put the kettle on for a cup of tea. Now it's all change again - I cough and peak flow drops off, so now an attack is when I cough for about an hour without stopping and peak flow goes through the floor.

    I found out the hard way that the fact that the asthma has always presented in one way doesn't mean that it will always present in that way, and twice I didn't realise that it was changing until I was in real trouble.

  • for me it is my reliever not working.

You may also like...