Anyone see this?: My mum sent me this... - Asthma Community ...

Asthma Community Forum

21,547 members24,420 posts

Anyone see this?

4 Replies

My mum sent me this link. I don't know if they're really saying anything that new (science reporting in average broadsheet/tabloid usually not that great) but I notice they don't mention the reported side effects of Singulair!

In the end just seems to be 'these pills work better for some asthmatics than some inhalers' - which was surely kind of obvious already!

telegraph.co.uk/health/heal...

Read more about...
4 Replies

Seen it too on the Asthma UK Facebook page. Not sure the article (available nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/N... ) mentioned the full study outcomes ""Study results at 2 months suggest that LTRA was equivalent to an inhaled glucocorticoid as first-line controller therapy and to LABA as add-on therapy for diverse primary care patients. Equivalence was not proved at 2 years"". It's a fair point about treatment adherence but not sure it would save hospital admissions as surely they are less common particularly if used in mild/moderate asthma.

Singulair

Hi Philomena

That article appears on AUK website too.... asthma.org.uk/news_media/ne...

It's reported by AUK as being good research. I tend to accept stuff that AUK endorses. Certainly for me Singulair has improved my peakflow if nothing else! I'm not aware of any side effects for me personally though I expect for many people these occur.

HI Mardi ,

I'm sure the research is good - certainly reputable journal etc and as you say endorsed by AUK - I just tend to find reporting of science in the general media not so good and the article I read and linked to seemed a bit vague and not really saying that much, so interesting to see the original.

I'm not on Singulair myself but have read that it does have some reported not-so-pleasant side effects for some people (my mum asked 'could they not try you on that just to see? so I looked it up and thought I could see why they wouldn't try it unless reasonably sure it would work well for someone) - just wondered why the article I linked to hadn't mentioned them. The study doesn't specifically, though I'm guessing as the quality of life scores increased most people didn't have any problems as I can't imagine side effects improve quality of life!

Be interesting to see if any more comes out on this or there are any other studies.

Edit: TJ, I also thought fair point about it being easier to take pills and making sure you've got the full dose, though the Telegraph article mentions being 'less self-conscious about taking the medication' - surely more an issue with relievers, as most people take their preventers at home most of the time.

Husband drew my attention to it. Reported as if its a new tablet but knew it wasnt. Sone folks do marvellously on Singulair with no side effects. Me, I had really awful side effects when I took it. Feelings of worthlessness and bad dreams. Did not do much for my asthma either. Despite this, my asthma nurse tried me on it several times, even though I said no thanks. :(

PS Husband has tablets for blood pressure, cholesterol and diabetes. Forgets to take them all the time. Be better with an inhaler, if such a thing were possible.

You may also like...

How long before you see effects of Dupi?

wonder how low long folks here took before they noticed any improvements on Dupi. I've been on...

sentive nose has anyone else?

nose and I start have symptom is that normal they don't care about me

Something still not right…. Advice anyone? 🙏🏽

49 year old lifelong asthmatic. Very well controlled with Montelulast and Singulair 200. Never use...

side effects of biologics-anyone effected?

I'm going for blood tests soon but I have done some research and found that they can suppress the...

Spirometry results... can anyone read results?

get in at the Dr's for some time etc. I'm just unsure that I've even got asthma and believe my...