Clearly Defined Mets - Radiate or not?? - Advanced Prostate...

Advanced Prostate Cancer

20,785 members25,896 posts

Clearly Defined Mets - Radiate or not??

98 Replies

First, thanks to all of you for your input - Fish, George 71, Nalakrats and everyone else. I have six Mets that are clearly defined on my scans.

One on each hip bone, two on my spine and one each on a rib. I too am very interested in radiation treatments to see if we can get rid of these mets. I am currently only on casodex not any form of ADT

What does everybody think? Should I have these done before going on ADT or go on ADT first. My PSA has been very steady at 1.5 the last 6 months. never any higher than that since on casodex for 6 years.

Thanks so much for your thoughts

Read more about...
98 Replies
NPfisherman profile image
NPfisherman

I had stereotactic radiation on one lytic bone lesion---on my clavicle--- while on ADT---PSA prior to radiation was .23--2 weeks before tx-- The lesion was revealed on Axumin scan with PSA of about 3 --1 month before...I have f/u next month post treatment...

There is a COMET-10 trial which is supposed to happen but I don't know when...try google it....Treating up to 10 lesions....The SABR-COMET trial for oligometastatic disease has resulted in multiple trials for oligometastatic disease--see below on page 4

cancer.gov/about-cancer/tre...

A certain poster here will say there is no proven value to stereotactic radiation treatments---not proven in phase 3... I think Dr Heron of UPMC might disagree---see study below:

sciencedaily.com/releases/2...

I got on ADT right away when I found out the beast was back and got treated later---I preferred to push back on the cancer and then hit it with radiation--will post my f/u results.

You may wish to message TWTJr--a poster here who is a retired Radiologist--19 year battle with the beast--about 6 years ago--he had radiation to 6 lesions--similar description to yours--being a retired Radiologist and person treated/survivor--he can give you his opinion/ feedback on start ADT, radiation treatment--which one first, etc...

Whatever you decide....good luck...

All the best,

Fish

in reply to NPfisherman

Thanks so much fish. You guys are all so helpful

NPfisherman profile image
NPfisherman in reply to

We are all on this hell ship together...warriors in the same battle--glad to be of assistance--I do advise contacting TWTJr--nice guy and he had radiation twice in his 19 year battle...I will post my results after f/u at UPMC next month...best of luck

Fish

in reply to NPfisherman

SHU

in reply to

Don't Understand

NPfisherman profile image
NPfisherman in reply to

Our new slogan...LOL... we must separate the wheat from the chaff as they say in the Bible... You know what happened to the chaff, right??

NPfisherman profile image
NPfisherman in reply to

Here is info on SABR-COMET-10

clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show...

See trial locations--make contact---they will do it for free if you qualify and get in...

Good luck,

Fish

in reply to NPfisherman

Thanks Fish:

I just sent Dr. Palma an application for the trial.

Sure appreciate your help.

Tom

NPfisherman profile image
NPfisherman in reply to

Hope it works out, Tom...Good luck, my man...

Fish

tallguy2 profile image
tallguy2 in reply to NPfisherman

This is an outstanding reply. Thank you for posting!

NPfisherman profile image
NPfisherman in reply to tallguy2

Anything to help another survive on this hell ship....we are all crew mates until this cancer, or we, are no more... You are most welcome...

Fish

in reply to NPfisherman

You are the best Fish

NPfisherman profile image
NPfisherman in reply to

I try and be a better Fish every day...God knows my failures, but I keep trying to be the best Fish... it's coming I think...

Fish

in reply to NPfisherman

Thanks

tango65 profile image
tango65

This study involves different cancers including prostate cancer: (SABR-COMET Study)

ascopost.com/News/59410

redjournal.org/article/S036...

It seems that there is a survival benefit in patients with 5 or less metastases. There are planning a new study treating patients with up to 10 metastases.

in reply to tango65

Thanks so much

GP24 profile image
GP24

Please be aware that the mets you know are just the tip of the iceberg. This patient has a clear bone scan and lots of mets when using a PSMA PET/CT:

up.picr.de/35089055sw.png

in reply to GP24

Very scary - my PSA is only 1.5

Thanks

tango65 profile image
tango65 in reply to

I believe the SABR-COMET study was done in patients studied with conventional scans.

GP24 profile image
GP24 in reply to

I did not want to scare you, just indicate that mets on the bone scan are just a part of the ones that are present. So if you radiate the ones you see with a bone scan you just address the biggest ones. How much this will help I do not know.

On the image the mets are just the small black spots. The big black areas are healthy organs that also show up in a PSMA PET/CT.

Thanks

One hell of a situation tce.. unless your Dr has given you a reason not to trust I’d go with his or her professional advice. I’m surpised that you’re not already on adt.. if doc suggests start both now . I’d follow it. Hit this with a sledge hammer if you need to. Invest in hope..push that sucker down and keep it running. It’s all about jumping hurdles , when APC says jump , we say how high. If we don’t ride it’s back and try to slow it’s roll ,it will make quick work of us. I say throw the kitchen sink at it and see what sticks.. Good luck tce, youll do the right thing. Keep jumping .. Scott

in reply to

Thanks Scott - Are you on Lupron?

in reply to

I was until the orch. On test adt drug tak -700 until failure..

in reply to

How is your PSA

in reply to

What Psa? I’m kidding 31/2 yrs .04... but that also put me with T =3 or almost zero T baby. It’s a walk on the wild side.

NPfisherman profile image
NPfisherman in reply to

You listenin' to Lou Reed, my man.... skip the ad....

youtube.com/watch?v=oG6fayQ...

in reply to NPfisherman

My mantra. “Then he was a she” Gotta go with the flow...

Jbooml profile image
Jbooml in reply to

Agreed...someone should devise and test a rotating trials involving newer and newer evolving therapies...like a course of antibiotics if the drug doesn’t knock the sh!t out of the cancer burden in two weeks try something else. My PSA dropped from 912 to .12 in a month but we all know that’s just the start of the long battle. Good results don’t mean we can relax...we have to get every last remaining malignant clone...and then prepare the environment for eutrophication....better both at once.

George71 profile image
George71 in reply to Jbooml

here is one easy add on - kills circulating cancer stem cells - My dermatologist prescribes it for acne and rosea -- said people take Doxy for years -- very safe.

medicalnewstoday.com/articl...

Jbooml profile image
Jbooml in reply to George71

And....while I’m still on my pulpit...why don’t we have a universally accreting PC liquid biopsy array...we all dump much of our hopes in big Pharma’s lap...but if the WHO were to reach out to all participating nations to fund such a project...it would stand as a model for all cancers efficient detection and treatment.

in reply to George71

Fascinating . Thank you ..

Moespy profile image
Moespy

I think most would agree that a year or so from now the F18 DCFPyL PSMA Pet Scan will be SOC for detecting mets. Having had this scan on a trial at NIH I can attest to it's sensitivity. I had 2 bone scans, 2 conventional CT scans and and 1 MRI with endorectal coil that found 0 mets 30 days prior to the PSMA Scan. Then the F18 DCFPyL Scan lit up a pelvic lymph node that was biopsied and found to be PCa.

I have now started ADT and will have all of the pelvic nodes radiated in 30 days or so and will continue on ADT for 24 months.

The reason for this decision was to kill the met found on the scan and the micro mets in the other nodes that cant be seen by any scan. The ADT will help the effectiveness of the radiation and will systemically treat the rest of the micro mets in my body. I could have just done radiation but that would allow the cancer to grow that is located outside of the radiation field. My RO and MO are fully on board with and agree with this decision.

Having related this information my point is if you look at the image that GP24 posted (and the point of that comparison) earlier in this string it stands to reason that a more systemic approach may be warranted in the case of multiple mets.

You might discuss hitting this with ADT, followed by radiation to the mets and then Docetaxel (chemo). May not be possible but if it were me this might be the treatment question I would ask.

Jim

NPfisherman profile image
NPfisherman in reply to Moespy

Best of luck, Jim....May it all work as planned and you get to escape this hell ship !!

Fish

sandy4510 profile image
sandy4510 in reply to Moespy

We found three nodes on an auxumin scan last fall when the other scans and 3t MRI showed nothing. Was it hard for you to find someone who would radiate your nodes? Our ur thinks it is pointless. I think it's time for an oncologist.

in reply to sandy4510

Thanks Sandy:

My MO here at the Mayo Phoenix says it only helps with bone pain.

Another Doctor at Mayo says radiation can be curative.

I do not know who to believe.

in reply to

Tce if you can talk to Dr. Paraminder Singh at Mayo in Scottsdale , he’s the pc specialist that made the right calls for me. A great man.

in reply to

I go to Dr. Brice at Mayo Phoenix. I think it might be hard to change??

in reply to

Is Brice a pc specialist ? If not ... Singh is.. maybe a consult ... good news is that you’re at mayo .. Singh stepped up to Mayo from U of A medical center here in Tucson . You’re in good hands .. Take care tce

Moespy profile image
Moespy in reply to sandy4510

My RO at John's Hopkins wants to radiate the pelvic node and start ADT. He thinks if not curative it will definitely push things out in the future. I need think it is far from pointless but an MO will have his side of treatment that may lead him/het to think this way.

I would definitely consult with a well qualified RO.

Best wishes,

Jim

in reply to Moespy

Will do. Thanks Jim

in reply to Moespy

Hey Moespy , if your Dr recommends RT and adt , I’d do it. I did both together. It can throw you for a loop but it can push PC down well.

Unless a guy is ready to cash it in . Doing nothing with an aggressive APC is fatal . Until I lose the will to live I’ll do whatever poison given to stall the pc. Enjoy life

407ca profile image
407ca in reply to sandy4510

Sandy

My oncologist and radiologist both think radiating the nodes to be beneficial. Not necessarily a cure but beneficial as it reduces tumor burden.

All the best.

in reply to 407ca

For me , that’s enough said. Knock pc out ..

NPfisherman profile image
NPfisherman in reply to sandy4510

Sandy,

With 3 mets, you could qualify for stereotactic radiation trial for oligometastatic disease (<5 lesions) . The info is on page 4 on the site below:

cancer.gov/about-cancer/tre...

I had treatment at UPMC... good RO team---Dr. Heron, Dr. Burton, Dr. Olson--initial data from Dr. Heron below:

sciencedaily.com/releases/2...

Something to think about....you got rid of the mother ship(prostate)-- you can think about eliminating the rest....The cost is $80,000 for stereotactic radiation--if you qualify for the trial, it's free...

All the best,

Fish

sandy4510 profile image
sandy4510 in reply to NPfisherman

Thank you!

Ahk1 profile image
Ahk1 in reply to Moespy

Jim,

Are you considering chemo too for your approach?

I keep thinking about your approach which I will discuss with my MO in a week from now.

Thanks

Moespy profile image
Moespy in reply to Ahk1

No chemo (docetaxal) but have asked for Zytiga (abirsterone) which according to the Stampede Trial would be the early treatnent with fewer than 3 mets. If I had 5 or more mets I would then ask for chemo.

My MO is not ready to give me Zytiga at this time, saving it for the future.

I look forward to hearing what your MO and RO say.

Jim

Ahk1 profile image
Ahk1 in reply to Moespy

Thanks Jim. Will keep you posted

tallguy2 profile image
tallguy2 in reply to Moespy

Exactly my reasoning, Moespy. That PET with Axumin resulted in actionable information for both of us.

407ca profile image
407ca

I myself am being radiated for 4 nodes and 1 sternum met. So, naturallt it is my belief that radiating distant mets is beneficial. My doctors from MD Anderson, Cleveland Clinic, and a European teaching hospital agree that reducing tumor burden is beneficial. Nobody says "cure" but benificial nonetheless.

cesanon profile image
cesanon

"I am currently only on casodex not any form of ADT"

It would seem a no brainer, no matter what, to add lupron and Avodart to the mix.

The general rule is not to bother with localized treatment with more than 5 metastasis.

Tall Allen posted some clinical trials on this a month or 2 ago.

There is a strong cases to use only intermittent ADT, as opposed to staying on it long term.

Notwithstanding anything else, if you have Mets near your spine, that is a dangerous location. Maybe they need a good hit of radiation treatment.

Survivor1965 profile image
Survivor1965

Hello tce,

When I had bone mets on my spine and ribs I had cryoablasion done at Mayo Rochester. I read much about it being done here but it worked great for me.

And I’m no oncologist but why not get on ADT right away? Like someone else mentioned, those mets could be the top of the iceberg. Like my Dr told me, hit it like a nuclear bomb on a dandelion. What do you gain by waiting.

Best, John

Survivor1965 profile image
Survivor1965 in reply to Survivor1965

Sorry, *dont read much about it here

in reply to Survivor1965

Thanks so much John

Break60 profile image
Break60

I don’t understand why guys use just casodex . I’ve had mets radiated three separate times ( see profile) but also went on ADT3. No recurrence in any areas radiated. It’s controversial to radiate but so far it’s worked for me. If you can see mets there are millions you can’t see. You need a rifle and a shotgun.

in reply to Break60

And a bazooka ..

Break60 profile image
Break60 in reply to

Bazooka is big rifle!

Thanks - We pray every day on it.

Thanks Nalakrats

Decided to get my first Lupron shot this Friday.

Tough decision but I believe it is time and so do the doctors.

Don't you also recommend Avodart and metformin?

Does it help?

in reply to

It’s one hec of a club.. welcome aboard.. strap in amigo .... it a hell of a ride.... much luck ..and many prayers ...a new way of living , takes some acceptance ... but you can do it just like most of us already have.. enjoy whatever you can in life..

in reply to

Thanks Lulu

Are you glad you got your jewels removed?

in reply to

Just Glad to be alive. Minus juevos a small price to pay . It’s not like i didn’t get my money out of those pups in the 40 odd yrs since puberty . It’s wierdly liberating for me to let go off my macho bs that drove my life into the dust .. happiness is where we find it. Hope you finding some in the storm too . Peace

in reply to

So do you have to still be on Lupron?

in reply to

No more Lupron since 9-16 orch.still on a test adt that targets adrenal T ....

in reply to

Did dr. Sing at Mayo get you that medicine

in reply to

Yes, he was in charge of the test. It failed for most and is terminated. I’m

On until failure.. They still provide it to me.

in reply to

Good luck - would Lupron help?

in reply to

I did Lupron until orch . That was the point no more Lupron. Whatever I’ve done I’ve been clear over 3yrs. The Lupron did work.. I’m happy not to being shot up anymore. Never liked shots ..

in reply to

Thanks Lulu. Get my 3 month shot on 3-4-19

in reply to

I got my first and only firmagon shot and my dx on Friday the 13th 3-15 . Then Lupron shots til orch. Plus being that I was also on the test drug .Who knows what side effects are from which. ? I had built a Great Wall,by 53 of invincible macho thinking. I had a great fall. Still feel a bit like Humpty Dumpty ... all the kings horses and all the kings me , couldn’t put humpty dumpty back together again . My chemistry is held together by bailing wire . I’m doing the humpty dance with APC and adt in a war of attrition. Make the most of every day not in brutal pain . Lupron can throw us for a loop . Even make ya a bit loopy , but if it’s your best bet to live . It’s not really a hard decision . Mine was life or death . The alternative is not good. I think once stage four we all take this with us to the bitter end . Have fun and enjoy what you may alone the way . I’m being frank . APC & adt are mental and physical misery . I’m getting much better after yrs of strughle with self and the world . If one is lucky to get by this round with APC . He cant ever rest on his laurels and say “ I’m cured” My dr. Not APC specialist . A fine man . Said “ you’re cured” to me..My blood has been so good . He’s a hemotolagist onocologist.. not a pc .. but as you read these pages of HU like I have for two years now you will realize it’s a new path of life.... no easy fixes ... I say do more than these dam medical drs tell you to do for yourself .. for me that meant diet nutrition and exercise . Whatever they say . Do better than that .. if we extend our stay long enough , who knows? A real solution might evolve. “ There are lies, dam lies , and stats” Mark Twain ... live healthier than ever before and be happy with life.. or there is no point to any of this. Sorry to babble .. keep investing in tce and heal thyself. . peace...

in reply to

You are the best Lulu. So appreciate your condor.

in reply to

I appreciate life more now each day . Tce you’ve entered the twilight zone. This isn’t the end for you , it’s a twist in the road for sure . Time to start building the new path.. forget about the past , and the future , live for today and love and be loved . Be kind to everybody . I experienced road rage like emotions with no T.. being cool and collect might help any of us live longer . Cut all external stressors ..

in reply to

Your are correct LuLu - thanks for the kind words.

tallguy2 profile image
tallguy2 in reply to

Ask your doctor to prescribe something to help with the hot flashes and sweats that are almost a certainty with ADT. I have been on ADT since first diagnosis in 2012 and use the generic venlafaxine. This antidepressant has a nice feature of eliminating about 95% of the sweats.

Good luck!

in reply to tallguy2

Thanks Tallguy:

I will. Get my 3 month shot of Lupron on 3-4-19.

Sure appreciate your help.

Tom

TWTJr profile image
TWTJr

No definitive proof of improved longevity, as of yet, but as more and more studies being reported, I believe they will ultimately show some benefit, and great benefit in a few. The concept of reduced tumor load may be valid, as well as the concept of radiation and subsequent cell death inducing a beneficial immune response also may play a part. I had 6 lesions treated a number of years ago, and all irradiated lesions remain "cold." Of course, my data is anecdotal, implying no proof, but knowing the course I have had, to me the treatment likely was beneficial.

in reply to TWTJr

Thank you TWTJr -you are highly recommended to me by George 71 and the Fish. I have watched lectures by Eugene Kwon at Mayo Rochester and he is a big proponent of radiate the mets as a curative rather than just palliative solution. I live in Scottsdale and my MO at Mayo Phoenix says the only reason is for bone pain. I am going to ask for a consult with a RO. I guess you have been fighting this disease for many years and I have for 17. My MO says I am "Lucky" because my PSA is onlt 1.5 and I have only been on Cassodex. This week I am going to get my first ADT shot. Had a shot 17 years ago after surgery and before radiation. Really do not like the side effects. Are you on ADT? What is your secret?

Thanks

TWTJr profile image
TWTJr in reply to

Yes, I will confirm that if you go for stereo Rx, insist on therapeutic, not palliative dose. However, you may need to work with your therapist and complain of pain, any at all, with insurance covering the treatment a complicating aspect. Working with radiotherapist and insurance may get reimbursement.

in reply to TWTJr

What is stereo Rx? Thanks

TWTJr profile image
TWTJr in reply to

short for stereotactic radiotherapy, which is a focused radiotherapy to a relatively small region as opposed to a broad field of radiation. It is completed by moving the radiotherapy tube during treatment, guided by computer control.

in reply to TWTJr

Thanks - are you on ADT now?

TWTJr profile image
TWTJr in reply to

Yes, I am additionally on a trial at MDA, which is basically androgen suppression.

in reply to TWTJr

Thanks - so appreciate your input.

I start ADT Friday

in reply to

A day to remember.... you’ll get in touch with your feminine side for sure. 4 yrs for me on adt ..it’s a party... you’ll handle it... not without side effects, but you’ll handle those too. Treatment I see as us Paying our dues to extend life ..

in reply to TWTJr

Didn’t have that 20 yrs ago I assume.

Break60 profile image
Break60 in reply to

Also known as SBRT.

in reply to

Adt sucks ..I expect you to do well RT. ..if you do choose

in reply to TWTJr

Anyone can read out stats.. your anecdotal history helps someone facing now , what you’ve already faced.Great job surviving ..Thank you

cfrees1 profile image
cfrees1

You say you are on Casodex, so you are already on ADT without realizing it. Casodex is one of the earliest version of ADT. So I think you simply mean that you haven't started Lupron yet. Just an FYI in case you are resisting ADT for fear of the side effects. Casodex has many of the same SEs.

in reply to cfrees1

Start Lupron shot Friday. SE not to bad with Cassodex. What are you on???

cfrees1 profile image
cfrees1 in reply to

I have been on Lupron for over 3 years. Added Casodex for a year until it stopped working. Now I'm on Apalutamide too. I have lots of the side effects but they are not too bad for me and I can function just fine. They are kind of a minor annoyance now that I have reconciled myself to never having another erection. Since I don't have much of a sex drive anyway, it's not such a big deal.

in reply to cfrees1

10-4 on the erectionless life style. What is Apalutamide. What do you mean the Cassodex stopped working? I am going to have my mets radiated.

Thanks Tom

cfrees1 profile image
cfrees1 in reply to

"Stopped working" means that even while I was on it, my PSA started to rise again. So I moved on to Apalutamide (aka Erleada). That is a new drug which was approved for non-metastatic, castrate-resistant disease. As of right now, although I have PSA, so I know that cancer is still there, the volume of cancer is so low that we can't find it yet with current available scans. Current PSA is 0.23.

in reply to cfrees1

That is just wonderful that your PSA is that low. You have no visible Mets

cfrees1 profile image
cfrees1 in reply to

LOL, oops I had an extra zero in there. 0.23. pretty low but not as low as I'd like.

in reply to cfrees1

Looks good

All “C” treatments have side effects. The best , extended life...

You may also like...

update on husbands radiation to pelvic mets

getting reoccurring lymph node mets after radiation and 2 years adt. He is not adt resistant yet....

Radiation therapy for METS study

study is to determine the usefulness of radiating small METS early to compare survival time. My RO...

Radiation Therapy For Bone Mets?

Hello my Dads doctor suggested radiation for his bone mets. Before I make an appointment and go for...

Should I Get My Mets Radiated?

about getting my 3-4 mets radiated. My largest met (in my \\"hip\\") was radiated 6 yrs ago. Posts...

Painful Mets to ribs. Radiation or operation.

bed. She says no spinal cord compression but met on rib needs dealing with. Our Dr is away until...