Really weird thing has happened, my dad had his MRI scan on Friday, today he has just had his biopsy and he must have had another blood test when having the MRI scan. Anyway.. the man who did the biopsy was really lovely and my dad asked him his opinion on PSA results in the thousands? My dads was originally 2000. He said well look the other result has come back either 85 or 35 as can’t read the result!?
My dad couldn’t help but feel happy and so am I although we both know it’s still a high result and they are still looking at it being cancer, but surely this is good? He’s had no treatment at all? He did have a 5 mile walk before the original test ( he didn’t know at this point, exercise could affect the result) but from 2000 to double digits? 3 years ago he had a hernia op when they put mesh in could this have something to do with it? So confused!
Written by
Cammie2016
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Thank you so much, I do hope so too, trying not to get my hopes up although I can’t help it. It’s been such a rollercoaster few weeks and feels so so slow! Have to say I am not sure whether it was fair actually telling us that initial result being in the 1000s, terrified the life out of us is an understatement. Maybe they should gather all the results first then let people know. But anyway hope you and your husband are doing ok, always in my thoughts! X
Hi Cammie, PSA readings vary either through machine misreadings, operator misreading or as with me, first told 16.7. 2 weeks later told the fax machine had a spec of dust after the 6 and should have been 167. 2 weeks later up to 200. Biopsies tell the tale and PSA settled as meds come into play. All the best David, still 0.030.
Hi David, I don’t feel like they are being fair, the first test was lost, second they said was 2000 which of course terrified us, now the surgeon that performed the biopsy actually said “shouldn’t really say this but I looked at your scan and what I will say, which I shouldn’t Is I am fascinated by this and will be keeping an eye on your case” and said about the result being lower. My dad was smiling when he cane out, he’s took this as positive, you can’t help but cling to every word etc. Maybe it would be better to not say anything to patients about numbers and opinions etc til they know it all?
Glad you are doing good, thoughts as always with you all.
Don't necessarily trust the PSA results. We all tend to want to rely on a number but they can be very misleading. PSA is probably the best indicator and should be taken under the same conditions every time but often gives false reports. You really don't know which reading 2000, 85, or 35 is right if any of them. But in any case they are all high. The biopsy will give you a better indication but even then if the Gleason scores are 6 or even 7 you are still in the grey zone. Was a Digital Rectal Exam also done? That is the old fashioned way but tells if a nodule is on the prostate which is a good indicator. I don't see how a hernia repair even with mesh done 3 years earlier would effect PSA. Exercise and possibly a recent hernia repair has been rumored to raise the PSA but that would only be short time.
Thanks for replying, it is all very confusing and frustrating, he hasn’t mentioned a digital rectal exam so maybe he hasn’t had that particular test. The surgeon who did the biopsy said although it’s not his field he wants to keep an eye on my dads case as it’s unusual, so god knows what that means, if anything at all. It’s a case of waiting I suppose.
My PSA was normal at 2.7. It was the DRE that spotted the cancerous tumor and lead me to get a biopsy. Gleason 8, but scans didn't show any spread. Opted for HIFU.
How is it possible for my late husband's doctor not to feel any lump or anything when doing the DRE, yet his Gleason scores were 8, and all 12 sections of his prostate had cancer? His PSA was 20.4 when first diagnosed, but I kept holding on to hope that something was not accurate, all because the doctor "couldn't feel anything during the DRE". How naïve could have been!
Patience is the hardest word most of us who are on this journey have to have. Hopefully your dad is not on our journey but if he is then you and he will have to remember a few things. First he will have a new normal. He will not be the same, but that does not mean that life is not still good, just that he will not be able to do all the same things that he used to. Second, you will get conflicting advise from sites like these and from different doctors. Remember even doctors are practicing and all the advise probably worked for some and not necessarily for everyone. Third, all Drugs and Procedures have adverse side effects. Try to way the Risks versus the Rewards for each. Fourth, have patience, too many men start a drug program and when it does not work quickly they want to change drugs.
He should remember that with a caring daughter like you he is in good hands and the journey hopefully will go well.
Cammie, That is certainly good news, keep us posted in biopsy results. I am not sure where they got the 2,000 psa from, almost sounds like it could have been lab error. That happens sometime.
Hi Dan, thanks for your reply, I have no idea, the surgeon said to my dad that although it is not his field he finds his case interesting and will be keeping a close eye on it! Don’t know if that’s good or not?!
That sounds like good news and I hope and pray that it means only good things. I think I would personally want to repeat the scans and blood tests just to make really, really sure...
There was a study done of PSA testing once that showed a certain number of serious mistakes where one patient's blood sample gets mixed up with another. That could account for the problem here.
Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.
Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.
Update on my dad. Need help, hope. Docetaxel over 80?
Update On Dad's Duke visit
Update on Dad and ideas 💡 
My dad, @hopingforthebest1 
